AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Hello from the other thread! The time has come for us to find out what we as a forum have deemed The Top Video Games of All Time! Thank you to everyone who has devoted their time to compiling their lists and/or advised me on the particulars of the poll, you've all made what was already an enjoyable undertaking as straightforward as possible. We had 16 participants, namely:

andyd1010
Arsalan
BleuPanda
Edre Peraza
Emerald
FrankLotion
Krurze
Live in Phoenix
mjf314
mileswide
Nassim
Nick
ordinaryperson
Schüttelbirne
Vacantjoy
ValenN

Considering these 16 voters chose 791 different titles, not everyone's favourite games made the cut, so let's start by showcasing the nominations that received a sole #1 placing and nothing from anyone else:

Emerald's #1: Shenmue 1&2 (1999 & 2001)




ordinaryperson's #1: Mother 3 (2006)

Last edited by mileswide on Sun Apr 25, 2021 2:28 am, edited 1 time in total.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

And now a brief run-through all the games to gain more points than the equivalent of a single number 1 vote (100 points) without managing to crack our top 100:

Rank | Title/Alternate title | Release year | Platforms | Points (Votes)

118 | Final Fantasy IV [JPN]/Final Fantasy II [INTL] | 1991 | Various | 100.993 (3 votes)
117 | Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood | 2010 | Various | 101.239 (3 votes)
116 | Bloodborne | 2015 | PS4 | 101.714 (2 votes)
115 | Metroid Prime 2: Echoes | 2004 | GBC | 101.768 (2 votes)
114 | RollerCoaster Tycoon | 1999 | Various | 102.002 (2 votes)
113 | Sonic the Hedgehog 2 | 1992 | Various | 103.284 (2 votes)
112 | Assassin's Creed III | 2012 | Various | 106.190 (2 votes)
111 | The Walking Dead: Season 1 | 2012 | Various | 106.293 (3 votes)
110 | Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock | 2007 | Various | 106.381 (2 votes)
109 | Gears of War | 2006 | Various | 106.948 (3 votes)
108 | We Love Katamari | 2005 | PS2 | 107.855 (3 votes)
107 | Streets of Rage II | 1991 | Various | 107.866 (3 votes)
106 | Pikmin 2 | 2004 | Various | 108.414 (2 votes, including ValenN's #1)
105 | The Sims 3 | 2009 | Various | 108.430 (3 votes)
104 | Half-Life | 1998 | Various | 109.089 (3 votes)
103 | EarthBound | 1994 | SNES | 110.741 (2 votes)
102 | Zelda II: The Adventure of Link | 1987 | NES | 111.494 (2 votes)
101 | Final Fantasy | 1987 | NES | 111.818 (2 votes, including Live in Phoenix's #1)
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Right, now we've reached the top 100! I'll aim for a presentation of 20 entries a day, which might or might not slow down when we start the top 20.

Each entry will be prefaced with a quote from the game, then one from a review of the game. The latter will be an excerpt of a professional review sourced from Metacritic in most cases but I may resort to user reviews from Rate Your Music's gaming sister site, Glitchwave, which will also provide the listed primary and secondary genres for each game as well as the title's rank on said site. This will accompany the game's rank from Play That Game, a games review aggregation site many of you will know is run by AMF user Mulholland.

Either side of this information will be the relevant game's applicable platforms and its poll results as well as the name of all of its 'fans', not just the highest voters. A photo of the box art for one of the game's editions will be placed next to a screenshot from the appropriate version as ever.

But if I go on any more, I'll run an even greater risk of confusing or boring you all, so let the rollout commence! Do feel free to comment or ask questions at any time though:
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Ei-ei-poo
"The level designs are, quite frankly, ingenious. Featuring curves, ramps, narrow paths, moving platforms, and obstacles of all kinds, the levels are as awe-inspiring as they are frustrating", Cinescape
100. Super Monkey Ball 2 (2002)



112.084 points/3 votes
Platforms: GameCube
Genres: Rolling platformer, Fantasy; Party, Sports, Comedy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 1146/484
Fans: Nick (#25), Emerald (#43), FrankLotion (#94)

Acoustics
"Their rising all at once was as the sound of a thunder heard remote."
--Milton
"It's still not very accessible to non-grognards, and it's still fairly boring when it comes to multiplayer (turn-based games just involve too much waiting around for other people to finish up). But it's also still incredibly addictive, begging you to stay up just five minutes more, just to see what happens in the next turn", GamesRadar
99. (Sid Meier's) Civilization V (2010)



113.710 points/3 votes
Platforms: PC, Mac
Genres: 4X, Turn-based strategy, Historical; Government simulation
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 148/154
Fans: Edre Peraza (#5), FrankLotion (#124), BleuPanda (#246)

I may be but small, but I will die a colossus.
"Get into its mindset and be prepared for one of the most engrossing gaming experiences available", Gameplanet
98. Dark Souls (2011)



114.104 points/2 votes
Platforms: PS3, Xbox 360, PC, PS4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch
Genres: High fantasy, Action RPG; Gothic, Medieval, Open world
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 38/4
Fans: BleuPanda (#6), FrankLotion (#61)

Well, you may have roasted my robot, but I'm the master chef around here... and I reckon it's about time your goose was cooked!
"Pretty much just like the second game. Many people haven't played this one, but if you liked the previous two, you won't be disappointed", Nintendo Life
97. Donkey Kong Country 3: Dixie Kong's Double Trouble! (1996)




115.000 points/2 votes
Platforms: SNES, GBA
Genres: 2D Platformer, Fantasy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 1010/555
Fans: mjf314 (#15), ValenN (#27)

*main character bumps into ghost and folds in on himself*
"[This game] marked the moment when video games transcended the arcade vending industry that birthed it to become a medium and business in its own right...[it] handily demonstrated the appeal of video games on every level", 1up, 2012 (h/t Play That Game)
96. Pac-Man (1980)



115.694 points/2 votes
Platforms: Arcade, virtually every console ever
Genres: Maze chase, Arcade, Ghost
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 54/1392
Fans: Live in Phoenix (#13), mileswide (#30)

I just got some...satisfaction!
""An outstanding game. It looks great, is very well balanced, and is easy to get started with. The game has more strategy and fewer mouse gymnastics than the average RTS game", Computer Games Magazine
95. Age of Empires II : The Age of Kings (1999)



115.953 points/3 votes
Platforms: PC, Mac, PS2
Genres: RTS, Historical, Medieval; War
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 152/140
Fans: Nick (#6), FrankLotion (#104), Nassim (#193)

Looks like they want me to sit in their fancy chair
"Dealing with themes like religion, racism, and xenophobia, Columbia is a richer and more nuanced setting than even Rapture, and the unveiling of the city’s culture is masterfully executed", Game Informer
94. BioShock Infinite (2013)



116.595 points/4 votes
Platforms: Xbox 360, PC, PS3, PS4, Xbox One, Mac, Nintendo Switch
Genres: FPS, Steampunk, Dystopian, Alternate history; Time travel, Postmodernism
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 133/755
Fans: Emerald (#33), FrankLotion (#54), BleuPanda (#89), Nassim (#137)

I'm Wario, I'm a-gonna win! (sorry, wrong game)
"Nintendo completely re-invented their portable platformer and gave their greedy new character his own game instead of merely plopping him down into the middle of just another standard Super Mario Land presentation. A wealth of new gameplay combined with a unique visual and musical style make the game stand on its own", IGN, 2009
93. Super Mario Land 3: Wario Land (1994)



116.667 points/2 votes
Platforms: Game Boy, 3DS
Genres: 2D Platformer, Fantasy; Comedy, Action-adventure
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 770/1221
Fans: mileswide (#14), Nassim (#27)

Do not betray my expectations
"While the game has some minor pacing and audio problems, the brave new art style, tightly evolved gameplay and humorous story takes the famous series in a bright, new direction", GameRevolution
92. The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker (2002)



117.857 points/2 votes
Platforms: GameCube
Genres: Action-adventure, High fantasy; Open world, 3D platformer, Pirate
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 47/47
Fans: FrankLotion (#3), BleuPanda (#79)

Why do I feel so numb? Is it something to do with where I come from?
"A collection of interface tweaks and non-earth-shattering new features designed to make the experience more enjoyable and less frustrating", 1UP
91. Rock Band 2 (2008)



118.745 points/4 votes
Platforms: Xbox 360, PS3, PS2, Wii
Genres: Rhythmic, Music; Singing
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 357/182
Fans: andyd1010 (#39), Nassim (#48), FrankLotion (#58), BleuPanda (#214)
Wow! This is a nice chest!
"The best Game Boy game ever, an adventure so engrossing and epic that we can even forgive the whole thing for being one of those 'It's all a dream!' fakeouts", EGM, 2006

90. The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening (1993)



118.745 points/3 votes
Platforms: Game Boy, GBC
Genres: Action-adventure, High fantasy; 2D platformer, Open world
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 139/138
Fans: Nassim (#8), Live in Phoenix (#64), BleuPanda (#217)

What is a man? A miserable pile of secrets!
"Everything is animated with an amazing attention to detail, and the special effects used throughout provide an atmosphere that just begs to be experienced", EGM
89. Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (1997)



119.446 points/3 votes
Platforms: PS1, Saturn, Xbox 360, PSP, PS4, App, Mac
Genres: Metroidvania, Gothic, Vampire, Fantasy; Action RPG
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 37/29
Fans: BleuPanda (#34), Live in Phoenix (#43), Emerald (#45)

This was supposed to be a very special feast
"Production-wise, this is the best Capcom's ever done, with believable performances (wait 'til you see the Baker's son. Something about him is so freakishly real to me) and wonderfully creepy audio design", Destructoid
88. Resident Evil 7: Biohazard (2017)



120.608 points/2 votes
Platforms: PS4, PC, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, Amazon Luna, Stadia
Genres: Survival horror; FPS, Psychological horror, Sci-fi, Black comedy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 160/473
Fans: Arsalan (#4), BleuPanda (#59)

You're like a cockroach! Revolting!
"Fluid controls, good graphics and sound, and gameplay that rocks the gaming world proclaim this one a winner. The Weapon Master and other modes will keep you busy for a while, and the multiplayer fights seem to never get old", Gaming Trend
87. Soulcalibur II (2002)



122.104 points/3 votes
Platforms: Arcade, GameCube, PS2, Xbox, PS3, Xbox 360
Genres: Fighting, Fantasy; Arena fighting, High fantasy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 198/363
Fans: ValenN (#15), Emerald (#48), FrankLotion (#96)

I got gas
"Pure, exhilarating glee will envelop your soul, demanding that you keep playing "just one more game" into the wee hours of the morning", EGM
86. Mario Kart: Double Dash!! (2003)



123.402 points/3 votes
Platforms: GameCube
Genres: Kart racer, Fantasy; Vehicular combat
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 348/339
Fans: Nick (#17), andyd1010 (#28), FrankLotion (#184)

Didn't you know that two thirds of the world's greatest assassins are women? Do you want to die now? Or after your female friend? Which will it be?
"A brilliant, technically stunning, well thought through release that's sure to influence action adventure games for many years", Arcade
85. Metal Gear Solid (1998)



123.673 points/3 votes
Platforms: PS1, PC
Genres: Stealth, Espionage, Sci-fi, Action-adventure; Mecha, Cyberpunk, Postmodernism
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 9/32
Fans: Emerald (#31), BleuPanda (#39), FrankLotion (#46)

I banish you to forever twinkle in the heavens, BE GONE!!
"It's a reminder of why this silly little hobby of ours is so wonderful. Sure, the game contains no political satire, no poetic justice, no character development. But if what Miyamoto and Tezuka crafted isn't a work of art, then the definition of "art" needs to be amended", Nintendo Life, 2009
84. Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island (1995)



123.873 points/2 votes
Platforms: SNES, GBA
Genres: 2D Platformer, Fantasy, Dinosaur
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 97/46
Fans: mjf314 (#7), Nassim (#36)

I don't want your mother's ghost haunting me because her only child became a garbage burner
"It’s a game that rewards the long-haul with deep, inventive missions which eschew the usual fetch and kill structure", Edge Magazine
83. Fallout 3 (2008)



124.866 points/3 votes
Platforms: PC, PS3, Xbox 360
Genres: Western RPG, Open world, Post-apocalyptic, Sci-fi, Action RPG; FPS, Black comedy, TPS, Alternate history
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 46/632
Fans: ordinaryperson (#8), FrankLotion (#53), BleuPanda (#179)

Shooting you was a pleasure but dating you was only business
"I could go on and on trying to explain the plethora of intricate details - the realistic gang rivalries, the things you can do with prostitutes, the hysterical 'Rampages' that allow you to go on mass killing sprees - but..just drop 50 bucks on this gem and cherish your inner criminal", Game Revolution
82. Grand Theft Auto III (2002)



125.865 points/3 votes
Platforms: PS2, PC, Xbox, Mac, App
Genres: Crime, Open world, Mission-based driving, Action-adventure; Black comedy, TPS
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 34/512
Fans: Krurze (#5), Live in Phoenix (#61), FrankLotion (#265)

The music is nice here
"A refined version that makes the original obsolete. added tons of new designs/themes for attractions/scenery and helpful tools that felt like they should have been in the original", neotokyo, Glitchwave, 2016
81. RollerCoaster Tycoon 2 (2002)



127.032 points/3 votes
Platforms: PC
Genres: Business simulation, Amusement parks; Sandbox
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 1660/181
Fans: Nick (#12), ValenN (#30), FrankLotion (#249)
Last edited by mileswide on Tue Apr 20, 2021 10:11 am, edited 1 time in total.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
Nassim
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2156
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 2:35 pm
Location: Lille (France)

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Nassim »

Half Life out of the top 100 is the first big surprise imo !

I guess Fallout 3 showing up is a good sign for New Vegas !
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Full disclosure about the above edits: I had to update the Donkey Kong Country 3 screenshot and the setting I've selected means it shouldn't expire now. I'd also forgotten to cut andyd1010's ballot from 40 to 39 after he chose not to replace Pokémon Yellow at #37. Luckily, that only affected Rock Band 2, which has leapfrogged The Wind Waker. No other changes!
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Another thing I forgot to mention! The underlining of some of the platforms indicates our forum's preference for the platform in question e.g. both mjf314 and Nassim suggested that they preferred the original Super Nintendo edition of Yoshi's Island, so SNES gets underlined in that entry.

Hope that's clear :music-rockon: (has the headbanging emoji disappeared mid-post??)
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
Live in Phoenix
Full of Fire
Posts: 1788
Joined: Wed Jan 02, 2013 12:50 am

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Live in Phoenix »

Looks like my #5 is getting in. I maybe underrated it, but it's also gotten on my nerves in the last year.
NatalieChapman
Debut
Posts: 1
Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2021 5:35 pm

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by NatalieChapman »

I don't know why, but I have a similar relationship to number 5 :D !
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Nassim wrote: Tue Apr 20, 2021 10:10 am I guess Fallout 3 showing up is a good sign for New Vegas !
Live in Phoenix wrote: Tue Apr 20, 2021 4:28 pm Looks like my #5 is getting in.
I'm giving nothing away at this stage! All I will say is that sadly at least one voter's #1 is in the next block of 20...
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
FrankLotion
Unquestionable Presence
Posts: 550
Joined: Sat May 05, 2018 9:15 pm

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by FrankLotion »

I’m truly impressed by the amount of detail you’ve put into all these entries!

This list is already full of surprises, I never would’ve expected Half-Life or Mother 3 to not make the top 100, or for Super Monkey Ball 2 to make the cut (which I’m clearly a fan of).
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

FrankLotion wrote: Tue Apr 20, 2021 10:54 pm I’m truly impressed by the amount of detail you’ve put into all these entries!

This list is already full of surprises, I never would’ve expected Half-Life or Mother 3 to not make the top 100, or for Super Monkey Ball 2 to make the cut (which I’m clearly a fan of).
*nervously checks for mistakes* Nah, it looks like we're good- at least as far as those titles are concerned! The next 20 should be served up within the next hour, stay tuned...
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

NatalieChapman wrote: Tue Apr 20, 2021 5:38 pm I don't know why, but I have a similar relationship to number 5 :D !
Welcome to the forum, hope you're enjoying this poll!
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

You seem to know a lot about a battle you never showed up to
"Here is an endlessly lavish, detailed production based in a newborn universe that is not only filled with unfamiliar faces but also brims with daring ideas and mechanics", Eurogamer
80. Xenoblade Chronicles (2010)



127.679 points/2 votes
Platforms: Wii
Genres: Action RPG, JRPG, Sci-fi, Open world; Fantasy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 166/169
Fans: ordinaryperson (#7), BleuPanda (#31)

I'm still better than you! You got lucky, you little punk!
"For the first time I can remember, an extreme-sports game actually has a real story", OPM
79. Tony Hawk's Underground (2002)



128.744 points/2 votes
Platforms: PS2, GameCube, GBA, Xbox, App, PC
Genres: Skateboarding; Comedy, Open world, Adventure, Mission-based driving
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: UR/292
Fans: Krurze (#11), Nick (#21)

SUSPENSION SMASH!
"Without a doubt the greatest racing game the world has ever seen. Nothing else with four wheels can match its pace, ferocity and skill", GamesTM
78. Burnout 3: Takedown (2004)



129.049 points/2 votes
Platforms: PS2, Xbox
Genres: Arcade racer, Vehicular combat
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 112/131
Fans: Krurze (#4), Emerald (#41)

GROU!
"An immensely enjoyable experience...[which] made me smile more than any game has for years", Pocket Gamer
77. Pokémon GO (2016)



130.000 points/2 votes
Platforms: App
Genres: Monster collector, Augmented reality; MMORPG, Fitness
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 342/4419
Fans: Live in Phoenix (#5), andyd1010 (#35)

Checked and loaded um me self
"A beautifully constructed and powerfully atmospheric mystery that you really have to work to solve", PC Gamer
76. Return of the Obra Dinn (2018)



131.405 points/3 votes
Platforms: Switch, Mac, PC, Xbox One, PS4
Genres: Graphic adventure, Mystery, Adventure puzzle; Crime investigation simulation, Time travel, Fantasy, Lovecraftian horror
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 378/UR (4.11 from only 205 ratings)
Fans: BleuPanda (#10), Nassim (#60), FrankLotion (#73)

I have plenty of outlets
"Tactile, bloody and substantial. One of gaming's most exciting open worlds - but only when you're online", PC Gamer UK
75. Assassin's Creed II (2009)



131.577 points/3 votes
Platforms: PS3, Xbox 360, PC, Mac, PS4, Xbox One
Genres: Action-adventure, Historical, Sci-fi; Open world, Stealth, Alternate history
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 91/894
Fans: andyd1010 (#8), FrankLotion (#67), BleuPanda (#81)

Welcome! Welcome, new galaxy!
"These are quite simply some of the greatest level designs of all time, constantly reversing the laws of gravity and physics to keep you guessing", Game Informer
74. Super Mario Galaxy (2007)



132.194 points/3 votes
Platforms: Wii
Genres: 3D Platformer, Space, Fantasy; Sci-fi, Puzzle platformer, Rolling platformer, Collect-a-thon platformer
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 44/51
Fans: Emerald (#25), BleuPanda (#26), FrankLotion (#64)

It's positively air-conditioned up here, man!
"The game's new, open-ended structure, excellent audio, enhanced trick system, and improved graphics combine to make this a superlative sequel to a series that's always had high standards", GameSpot
73. SSX3 (2003)



133.918 points/3 votes
Platforms: GameCube, PS2, Xbox, GBA, Gizmondo
Genres: Snowboarding, Trick-racing, Open world
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 391/191
Fans: Emerald (#16), Nassim (#18), BleuPanda (#238)

*the sound of marching feet*
"Its unimaginable twist may leave you dumbfounded, confused, and quite possibly speechless, but it will fuel heated discussion with your friends about its meaning, its message, and its intentions", IGN
72. INSIDE (2016)



135.135 points/2 votes
Platforms: Xbox One, PC, PS4, Switch, App, Mac
Genres: Puzzle platformer, Dystopian, 2D platformer, Cinematic platformer; Stealth, Physics puzzle, Sci-fi, Psychological horror, Surrealism
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 136/141
Fans: Arsalan (#1), BleuPanda (#49)

What is it now? I've a mountain of infernal parchmentwork
"This is the kind of video game fighting that puts your heart in your mouth, an exhilarating whirl of slashes and strikes and dodges", The Guardian
71. Hades (2020)



135.417 points/2 votes
Platforms: Switch, Mac, PC
Genres: Roguelite, Myth and folklore, Hack and slash; Action RPG, Isometric RPG, Social simulation
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 737/UR (4.10 from 198 ratings)
Fans: BleuPanda (#7), Nassim (#23)

Clear out! Move aside, please. Watch it, buddy. Excuse me. Move it, move it, move it
"You can combo off of everything in this game. Seriously I mean everything! Cars, people, sidewalks, buildings, rails, ramps, stop signs...", Gaming Age
70. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 (2001)



135.650 points/3 votes
Platforms: PC, PS1, PS2, GBC, GameCube, Xbox, GBA, PC, N64, Mac
Genres: Skateboarding
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 405/114
Fans: Emerald (#23), Krurze (#30), FrankLotion (#51)

I drink, mostly. And yell at people on the internet
"Building on Towerfall's sublime movement mechanics, this nails the flow of leaping through levels. A story peppered with endearingly earnest characters, makes this fantastic adventure a triumph", OPM
69. Celeste (2018)



138.261 points/3 votes
Platforms: Switch, PC, Mac, PS4, Xbox One, Stadia
Genres: 2D platformer, Low fantasy; Single-screen platformer, Vertical platformer, Surrealism
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 175/UR (4.09 from 439 ratings, surely enough to qualify for the chart?)
Fans: ValenN (#11), Nick (#23), BleuPanda (#194)

"My rage is so hot right now I could cook YOU in it!
"Deceptively deep, this is the new blueprint for action RPGs and one of the last must-haves for the N64", Hot Games
68. Paper Mario (2000)



142.292 points/3 votes
Platforms: N64
Genres: Turn-based RPG, JRPG, Fantasy, Comedy; 3D platformer
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 405/108
Fans: andyd1010 (#16), mjf314 (#16), BleuPanda (#141)

HEEL FLIP
"There are so many modes, multi-player games and features that could easily have you seeing less and less daylight as time goes on", Gamesradar+
67. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 (2000)



142.707 points/2 votes
Platforms: PS1, PC, GBC, Dreamcast, GBA, Mac, N64, App
Genres: Skateboarding
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 104/146
Fans: Nassim (#10), andyd1010 (#13)

You don't need a reason to help people
"A masterpiece of an adventure game. For anyone not to fall in love with it would truly amaze me. Everything is set just right and you are drawn into the story right from the very offset", Gamestyle
66. Final Fantasy IX (2000)



149.112 points/3 votes
Platforms: PS1, App, PC, PS4, Switch, Xbox One
Genres: JRPG, Turn-based RPG, High fantasy; Card battle, Steampunk
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 161/78
Fans: Nick (#7), BleuPanda (#35), FrankLotion (#81)

What is this 'puff-puff' of which you speak?
"It's not unusual for RPGs to draw inspiration from real world locations, but it is unusual for them to have this much variety or follow through", PC Gamer
65. Dragon Quest XI: Echoes of an Elusive Age (2017)



149.159 points/3 votes
Platforms: 3DS, N64, PC, Switch, Xbox 360, Stadia
Genres: JRPG, Turn-based RPG, High fantasy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 831/UR (4.07 from 118 ratings)
Fans: ValenN (#12), ordinaryperson (#27), BleuPanda (#65)

Don't give up on the sun. Don't make the sun laugh at you
"A rollercoaster ride from start to finish", Mean Machines
64. Sonic the Hedgehog 3 (& Knuckles) (1994)



149.845 points/3 votes
Platforms: Sega Mega Drive/Genesis, PC
Genres: 2D platformer, Fantasy, Sci-fi
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 473 (541)/488 (216)
Fans: Emerald (#11), ValenN (#16), BleuPanda (#158)

"Hello" is the beginning of "good-bye"
"This is the only kiddie game on earth where the gameplay exceeds its childish nuisances. 90% of the time I don't even think about or notice them", GameZone
63. Pokémon Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald (2002)



152.275 points/3 votes
Platforms: GBA
Genres: Turn-based RPG, JRPG, Monster collector, Fantasy, Sci-fi
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 527/322
Fans: Nick (#4), ValenN (#24), BleuPanda (#247)

Your stupid friends aren't much help, they stand there while I make you yelp!
"The level designs are simply delightful, loaded with creativity, secrets, and memorable characters", Allgame
62. Banjo-Kazooie (1998)



153.394 points/4 votes
Platforms: N64, Xbox 360
Genres: 3D platformer, Collect-a-thon platformer, Comedy, Fantasy; Action-adventure
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 129/151
Fans: mjf314 (#13), mileswide (#26), Nassim (#126), BleuPanda (#130)

Wheels up!
"An incredibly polished game with beautiful visuals, a high frame-rate, magical playability and an excellent menu system", Digital Foundry
61. Mario Kart 8 (2014)



155.030 points/4 votes
Platforms: Wii U, Switch
Genres: Kart racer, Fantasy; Vehicular combat
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 62/193
Fans: Nick (#15), Emerald (#46), BleuPanda (#56), Nassim (#97)
Last edited by mileswide on Sun Apr 25, 2021 2:31 am, edited 3 times in total.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
Nick
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2771
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2012 9:28 pm
Location: New York State

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Nick »

mileswide wrote: Wed Apr 21, 2021 3:30 am
69. Celeste
Should have "(2018)" added here. Great rollout, really enjoying it!
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Nick wrote: Wed Apr 21, 2021 3:40 am
mileswide wrote: Wed Apr 21, 2021 3:30 am
69. Celeste
Should have "(2018)" added here. Great rollout, really enjoying it!
Whoops, cheers for spotting that, I'm grateful for the praise too!
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
Nassim
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2156
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 2:35 pm
Location: Lille (France)

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Nassim »

There are 3 games in that section (INSIDE, THPS 3 and Final Fantasy IX) that I think are better than a lot of games I actually put in my list, but I still didn't vote for because I remember feeling let down compared to the previous game(s) in the serie (or compared to LIMBO for INSIDE)... still probably should have put INSIDE in my list (less regrets for the other 3)
User avatar
BleuPanda
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 3673
Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2012 1:20 am

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by BleuPanda »

I had Mario Kart 8 at 56; I think you accidentally listed ValenN in my place.
User avatar
Live in Phoenix
Full of Fire
Posts: 1788
Joined: Wed Jan 02, 2013 12:50 am

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Live in Phoenix »

NatalieChapman wrote: Tue Apr 20, 2021 5:38 pm I don't know why, but I have a similar relationship to number 5 :D !
Talking about Pokémon Go, right? The pace has gotten crazy. And (obviously) there's no real end to the game. Usually I just play games that can be beaten, or games like Asteroids where your character dies pretty quickly.
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

BleuPanda wrote: Wed Apr 21, 2021 4:49 pm I had Mario Kart 8 at 56; I think you accidentally listed ValenN in my place.
So I did, sorry about that but thanks for alerting me to it!
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Coming up next, we have the highest ranked games with no more than 2 voters...
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Triangle man, triangle man
"And despite its difficulty, the game constantly lures you back, persuading you that this time, you've got it figured out; this time, the high score is yours", Gamesradar+
60. Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved (2003 or 2005 as a standalone game)



155.319 points/2 votes
Platforms: Xbox (as a Project Gotham Racing minigame); Xbox 360, PC
Genres: Twin-stick shooter
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 537/876
Fans: andyd1010 (#1), Emerald (#22)

I will have my revenge - on a Prophet, not a plague!
"The Forge and the replay functionality raise the bar for console shooters so high, it may never be surpassed this generation", IGN
59. Halo 3 (2007)



156.93 points/2 votes
Platforms: Xbox, Xbox 360, PC, Xbox X/S
Genres: FPS, Alien, Sci-fi, War, Space; Vehicular combat, Arena shooter
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 85/258
Fans: andyd1010 (#5), FrankLotion (#12)

Regret, regret, regret
"Thanks to the wonders of the technology du jour, bump-mapping, every object, creature, and surface has a distinct texture that reflects light differently. Simply walking around the world is a joy, and you'll marvel over the level of detail on even the smallest elements of the game", Gamespy
58. Halo 2 (2004)



158.170/3 votes
Platforms: Xbox, PC
Genres: FPS, Alien, Sci-fi, War, Space; Vehicular combat, Arena shooter
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 84/261
Fans: andyd1010 (#6), Nick (#27), FrankLotion (#82)

You're bluffing, lizard face!
"There's a certain intensity of action and sense of urgency that only a 2D platformer can deliver. This game is a great way to rediscover that feeling for yourself", Game Informer, 2003
57. Donkey Kong Country (1994)



158.584 points/3 votes
Platforms: SNES, GBC, GBA
Genres: 2D platformer; Fantasy, Comedy, Adventure
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 130/184
Fans: mjf314 (#6), Nick (#33), Nassim (#62)

The heart may be weak. And sometimes it may even give in. But I've learned... that deep down there's a light that never goes out!
"I really don’t think anyone else could have woven as complex and enthralling a story into such enjoyable gameplay and kept it as true to both Square and especially Disney fans", Total PlayStation
56. Kingdom Hearts (2002)


158.774 points/3 votes
Platforms: PS2
Genres: Action RPG, JRPG, Hack and slash, Fantasy; 3D platformer, Rail shooter, Action-adventure
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 203/440
Fans: Schüttelbirne (#2), FrankLotion (#30), BleuPanda (#146)

Phew! I'm free! But...where am I?
"No matter which side of the gaming coin you come from, this whole new universe of planets is the most inventive, exuberant and, yes, fun set of challenges and diversions yet seen in the platform game genre", games (TM)
55. Super Mario Galaxy 2 (2010)



158.834 points/3 votes
Platforms: Wii
Genres: 3D platformer, Space, Fantasy; 2D platformer, Sci-fi, Collect-a-thon platformer, Rolling platformer, Puzzle platformer, Dinosaur
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 63/43
Fans: Emerald (#20), BleuPanda (#25), FrankLotion (#28)

Well, ain't that sweet. You're in the wrong place, honey. Stripper's quarters are that way
"[Its] greatest strength is in tying its disparate pieces together, binding the gunplay and conversation systems into something that meshes, while creating an action-RPG that knows stats should be there, but that they should never get in the way of a good headshot", Edge Magazine
54. Mass Effect 2 (2010)



159.524 points/2 votes
Platforms: PC, Xbox 360, PS3
Genres: Action RPG, Space, TPS, Western RPG, Alien, Sci-fi; Tactical shooter
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 12/120
Fans: BleuPanda (#3), FrankLotion (#14)

Man! I just had a shower!
"While the arcade-style play has been carried over from the previous two in the series, many awesome new moves have been added", Game Zero
53. Teenage Mutant Ninja* Turtles: Turtles in Time (1991)



165.193 points/3 votes
Platforms: SNES, Arcade
Genres: Ninja, Time travel, Beat 'em up, Low fantasy, Belt scroller, Arcade
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 317/521
Fans: ValenN (#6), ordinaryperson (#24), Nassim (#67)

Into the abyss will I run!
"When you can finally crack a song that initially seemed far beyond your skill level, and not just play it but perform it - arched back, windmilling arms, grins and grimaces and devil-horn salutes - it transcends a mere video game. It’s interactive entertainment taken to an entirely new level", WHAM! Gaming
52. Guitar Hero II (2006)



167.231 points/3 votes
Platforms: Xbox 360, PS2
Genres: Rhythm, Music; Party
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 439/553
Fans: andyd1010 (#4), Nassim (#13), FrankLotion (#259)

It's a beautiful day outside. Birds are singing, flowers are blooming. On days like this...kids like you...SHOULD BE BURNING IN HELL
"What really makes [the game] is the story and writing, which is on the one hand hilarious enough to suck you in from the start, and is also, by the end, rather heartfelt as well", Yahtzee
51. Undertale (2015)



175.741 points/3 votes
Platforms: PC, PS4, PS Vita, Switch, Xbox One, Xbox X/S
Genres: Turn-based RPG, Fantasy, Absurdist comedy, Postmodernism; Satire, Bullet hell, Graphic adventure
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 173/63
Fans: ordinaryperson (#2), BleuPanda (#15), Nassim (#155)

There's nothing like the sound of hundreds of voices screaming in unison
"With so much story and variation of play ... fans may become lost in the world for months at a time", Nintendo Power
50. Final Fantasy VI (1994)



179.780 points/4 votes
Platforms: SNES, PS1, GBA, App, PC
Genres: JRPG, Turn-based RPG, Steampunk, High fantasy; Post-apocalyptic, Open world
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 45/35
Votes: ordinaryperson (#14), FrankLotion (#35), BleuPanda (#44), Nassim (#56)

He touched my butt!
"It's an unusual game that offers a serious challenge, as well as gorgeous graphics, a strong soundtrack, plenty of style, and good replay value", GaneSpot
49. Jet Set Radio Future (2002)



182.512 points/2 votes
Platforms: Xbox
Genres: 3D platformer, Extreme sports, Crime; Action-adventure, Dystopian
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 566/211
Fans: Nassim (#3), Emerald (#4)

It's like a meaty explosion in my mouth
"Its sprawling dungeon design and stylish, fully realized world are an absolute joy to explore, and even after three playthroughs...I find myself itching to go back to try different dialogue options", IGN
48. Persona 5 (2016)



186.257 points/3 votes
Platforms: PS4, PS3
Genres: JRPG, Turn-based RPG, Low fantasy, Social simulation; Monster collector, Stealth, Mystery, Crime Satire, Dungeon Crawler, Black comedy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 163/21
Fans: Nassim (#11), BleuPanda (#13), Emerald (#32)

I'm fine. Two plus two is...ten, in base four, I'm fine!
"Rich with a surprising degree of warm humour, the way the game progresses from being a simple set of perfunctory tasks to a full-on part of the Half-Life story is absolute genius", Eurogamer, 2008
47. Portal (2007)



193.141 points/5 votes
Platforms: PC, Xbox 360, PS3, Mac, App
Genres: Physics puzzle, Puzzle platformer, Sci-fi, 3D platformer, Comedy; Postmodernism, Black comedy, FPS
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 23/72
Fans: Vacantjoy (#10), Nick (#18), Nassim (#72), BleuPanda (#113), FrankLotion (#179)

A hot date in the rainforest? With two women!
"This is still inarguably a textbook example of how to put together a FPS that's built to last. It's also one that represents one of the very last instances of genuine innovation in a single-player FPS", Nintendo Life, 2011
46. GoldenEye 007 (1997)



194.651 points/4 votes
Platforms: N64
Genres: FPS, Espionage; Stealth
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 18/497
Fans: ordinaryperson (#19), mileswide (#21), andyd1010 (#33), Nassim (#51)

Raise thy sword by the light, and head to the place where the sword's light gathers
"A fiction of unquestionable thematic richness, of riveting emotional power, whose fundamental artistic qualities are completely fused with its interactivity", Edge Magazine, 2007
45. Shadow of the Colossus (2005)


197.124 points/3 votes
Platforms: PS2 (original); PS4 (2018 remake)
Genres: Action-adventure, Fantasy; Open world, Puzzle platformer, Tragedy, Cinematic platformer, 3D platformer
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 27/12
Fans: Emerald (#5), BleuPanda (#11), FrankLotion (#43)

"These creatures, which could engulf other living beings and take away their energy, proved to be strong and prolific"
"It's got everything I look for: playability, hidden tricks, powerful weapons and steamingly evil baddies", Super Play
44. Super Metroid (1994)



200.746 points/3 votes
Platforms: SNES
Genres: Metroidvania, Alien, Space, Sci-fi; Run and gun, Action horror
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 24/10
Fans: BleuPanda (#4), Live in Phoenix (#19), ordinaryperson (#25)

Either you got a lazy eye or a lack of respect
"It is also richly cinematic and even literary, serving up breathtaking digital vistas reminiscent of John Ford films along with a mix of deftly scripted stories", New York Times
43. Red Dead Redemption II (2018)



204.692 points/3 votes
Platforms: PS4, Xbox One, PC, Stadia
Genres: Western, Open world, TPS, Action-adventure, Crime ; Hunting, Black comedy, Survival, Fishing, FPS, Mission-based driving, Card game, Historical, Satire
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 120/UR (4.30 from 460 ratings)
Fans: Arsalan (#3), Krurze (#3), BleuPanda (#112)

Chik!
"Nintendo and Game Freak have tweaked the original and built a sequel that's long, challenging and tremendous fun to play", IGN
42. Pokémon Gold/Silver/Crystal (1999)



206.821 points/4 votes
Platforms: GBC
Genres: JRPG, Monster collector, Turn-based RPG, Fantasy; Sci-fi
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 173/67
Fans: Nick (#9), BleuPanda (#24), andyd1010 (#36), FrankLotion (#50)

I don't think I can ever forgive you for that. But I would like to try
"Because the game spent so much time convincing me to care about these characters, its emotional high notes were even more effective, and its many sad scenes even more devastating", Polygon
41. The Last of Us (2013)



208.413 points/4 votes
Platforms: PS4, PS3
Genres: TPS, Zombie, Post-apocalyptic, Action-horror; Survival horror, Stealth, Tragedy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 13/77
Fans: Arsalan (#8), BleuPanda (#20), FrankLotion (#25), Nassim (#106)

*I'm trying to ignore the fact that the word 'ninja' was considered too violent for British audiences...

EDIT 2: Added PTG/GW ranks to Undertale and increased gaps between some of the entries.
EDIT 3: Corrected Vista to Vita.
Last edited by mileswide on Fri Apr 23, 2021 12:13 am, edited 3 times in total.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
Emerald
Strange Fruit
Posts: 64
Joined: Sun Apr 23, 2017 7:26 pm

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Emerald »

Correction on #59. I didn't vote for Halo 3.
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Emerald wrote: Thu Apr 22, 2021 7:10 pm Correction on #59. I didn't vote for Halo 3.
Cheers Emerald! Not sure how that happened aside from my idiocy, I've got it as FrankLotion's #12 on my spreadsheet...
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
Nick
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2771
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2012 9:28 pm
Location: New York State

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Nick »

Pretty amazing that Halo 2 and Halo 3 are right next to each other, both on this list and on Play That Game. I guess it's because they're so similar.
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Nick wrote: Thu Apr 22, 2021 8:41 pm Pretty amazing that Halo 2 and Halo 3 are right next to each other, both on this list and on Play That Game. I guess it's because they're so similar.
That stood out to me too, I'd have expected a little more backlash from the critics if Halo 3 followed the formula that closely.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Next up, we have the respective best rated titles on Play That Game and Glitchwave as well as a game that was once awarded a mark above 10/10, what could they possibly be? We'll find out in a matter of hours!
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
mjf314
Start Me Up
Posts: 21
Joined: Mon Dec 14, 2020 2:34 am

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mjf314 »

mileswide wrote: Fri Apr 23, 2021 4:17 am Next up, we have the respective best rated titles on Play That Game and Glitchwave as well as a game that was once awarded a mark above 10/10, what could they possibly be? We'll find out in a matter of hours!
#1 Play That Game is Tetris. #1 Glitchwave is Bloodborne, but Bloodborne was one of the runners-up, so I'm not sure what you mean.
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Oh, that Nintendo thing...
"The huge roster of well done, interesting characters combined with the wackiness of the in game items and the interactivity and challenges of the various stages packs the game full of memorable moments regardless of which portion of the game you decide to spend time with", GameShark
40. Super Smash Bros. Brawl (2008)



212.469 points/4 votes
Platforms: Wii
Genres: Platform fighting, Fantasy; 2D platformer, Beat 'em up, Sci-fi, User generated content, Space, Action-adventure
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 157/630
Fans: ValenN (#7), ordinaryperson (#9), Nassim (#58), FrankLotion (#86)

Our time has passed, John
"[The game] culminates with a memorable, unexpected finale that strays from traditional storytelling techniques and instead relies on the sense of immersiveness only a video game can impart", Game Informer
39. Red Dead Redemption (2010)



212.998 points/4 votes
Platforms: Xbox 360, PS3
Genres: Western, Open world, TPS, Action-adventure, Crime, Tragedy; Black comedy, Hunting, Mission-based driving, Horse racing, Card game
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 17/63
Fans: FrankLotion (#8), ordinaryperson (#17), Nassim (#41), BleuPanda (#54)

Courage need not be remembered, for it is never forgotten
"It's a game that allows you to feel gradually more and more empowered yet simultaneously manages to retain a sense of challenge and mystery--which, together, creates a steady, consistent feeling of gratification throughout the entire experience...the most impressive game Nintendo has ever created", GameSpot
38. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (2017)



213.074 points/4 votes
Platforms: Switch, Wii U
Genres: Open world, Action-adventure, High fantasy; Survival, Action RPG, Post-apocalyptic, Physics puzzle, Action puzzle, Sandbox
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 39/6
Fans: Nick (#3), FrankLotion (#32), BleuPanda (#38), Nassim (#53)

I live for this part!
"A near flawless example of the perfect balance between 'falling back on what works' and 'pushing the genre forward", RPGFan
37. Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4 (2008)



213.890 points/3 votes
Platforms: PC, PS2, Vita
Genres: JRPG, Turn-based RPG, Mystery, Low fantasy, Social simulation; Monster collector, Dungeon crawler, Comedy, Crime, ADV, Dating sim, Myth & folklore
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 99/52
Fans: BleuPanda (#2), Emerald (#8), Nassim (#42)

It doesn't matter who I am...See? I'm real
"It's frightening, deep, clever, and tries to improve the genre, if just a little, and in the end, that's all I really want", IGN
36. Silent Hill 2 (2001)



214.752 points/4 votes
Platforms: PS2, Xbox, PC
Genres: Psychological horror, Survival horror; Surrealism, Mystery, Tragedy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 50/1
Fans: Arsalan (#6), BleuPanda (#8), Emerald (#40), FrankLotion (#190)
That MIT education really pays for itself
"It's the best game we've ever played. Period. The story is gripping, the tension is palpable, the action is almost non-stop, the presentation is superb. Not only does it innovate on many different levels, but it's also massive entertaining for the entire ride", Maximum PC
35. Half-Life 2 (2004)



215.623 points/3 votes
Platforms: PC, Xbox, Xbox 360, PS3, Mac, App
Genres: FPS, Dystopian, Sci-fi, Alien; Action-horror, Zombie, Physics puzzle, Post-apocalyptic
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 4/42
Fans: Vacantjoy (#2), ordinaryperson (#12), BleuPanda (#28)

Doo-doo-doo-doo doo-doo-doo doo-doo-doo doo-doo-doo ad infinitum...
"One of the most addictive computer games this side of the Berlin Wall ... [it] is not the game to start if you have work to do or an appointment to keep. Consider yourself warned", Compute!
34. Tetris (1984)



216.146 points/5 votes
Platforms: Game Boy, IBM, too many to list
Genres: Falling block puzzle
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 1/256
Fans: Edre Peraza (#11), mileswide (#11), Live in Phoenix (#38), BleuPanda (#104), FrankLotion (#228)

Oh, you are a truly extraordinary specimen... I look forward to breaking you
"The size of the game is daunting. I still have a ways to go to reach 100 percent, but I wouldn’t be surprised if I have invested over 60 hours so far", Game Informer
33. Batman: Arkham City (2011)



221.124 points/4 votes
Platforms: Xbox 360, PS3, PC, Wii U, PS4, Xbox One
Genres: Open world, Action-adventure, Superhero, Beat 'em up; Stealth, Sci-fi, Crime investigation simulation
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 72/319
Fans: Nassim (#7), Emerald (#13), FrankLotion (#26), BleuPanda (#102)

A scattered dream that's like a far-off memory...A far off memory that's like a scattered dream....I want to line the pieces up....yours and mine
"[It] satisfies all our lofty expectations with an immersive and jubilant adventure", GamePro
32. Kingdom Hearts II (2005)



229.751 points/4 votes
Platforms: PS2
Genres: Action RPG, JRPG, Fantasy, Hack and slash; Rail shooter, Action-adventure, 3D platformer, Comedy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 249/143
Fans: ValenN (#2), Schüttelbirne (#8), BleuPanda (#50), FrankLotion (#105)

I don't care about her happiness, I care about discipline and loyalty
"A game with a compelling and nonlinear storyline, a great protagonist who you can't help but like, and a plethora of online multiplayer features in addition to its lengthy story mode", GameSpot
31. Grand Theft Auto IV (2008)



231.392 points/4 votes
Platforms: PS3, Xbox 360, PC
Genres: Open world, Crime, Mission-based driving, TPS, Satire, Tragedy; Black comedy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 90/542
Fans: Arsalan (#2), Krurze (#12), FrankLotion (#24), BleuPanda (#196)

He has seen my face, we can't let him live
"Both an exciting return to form and the most successful fusion yet of video games with Hollywood-style storytelling", GameSpy
30. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (2004)



236.735 points/4 votes
Platforms: PS2, 3DS, Vita, PS3, Xbox 360
Genres: Stealth, Espionage, Action-adventure, Sci-fi, Cold War; Low fantasy, Survival, Mecha, Alternate history
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 48/8
Fans: Emerald (#7), BleuPanda (#16), ordinaryperson (#30), FrankLotion (#33)

What odd little fellows. They seem to know you! And...not like you
"Each kingdom is absolutely packed with charm, clever objectives, gorgeous visuals, a stellar soundtrack", Giant Bomb
29. Super Mario Odyssey (2017)



238.165 points/4 votes
Platforms: Switch
Genres: 3D platformer, Fantasy, Collect-a-thon platformer; 2D platformer, Open world
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 89/5
Fans: Emerald (#10), FrankLotion (#16), ValenN (#18), BleuPanda (#40)

Squirtle Squirtle!
"As an RPG, the game is accessible enough for newcomers to the genre to enjoy, but it will entertain hard-core fans as well. It's easily one of the best Game Boy games to date", GameSpot
28. Pokémon Red/Blue/Yellow (1996)



238.335 points/5 votes
Platforms: GB
Genres: Turn-based RPG, Monster collector, JRPG, Fantasy; Sci-fi
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 41/252
Fans: FrankLotion (#9), Nick (#16), andyd1010 (#18), Nassim (#93), BleuPanda (#138)

Hey, flying raccoons! You didn't happen to see where those two pesky plumbers went...did ya?
"In an era where platform games were still usually little more than right-to-left obstacle courses punctuated by boss battles, this was the game that introduced the overworld map screen, allowing you to choose which levels to play, or replay", Eurogamer, 2007
27. Super Mario Bros. 3 (1988)



246.447 points/5 votes
Platforms: NES, Arcade, GBA
Genres: 2D platformer, Fantasy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 29/34
Fans: mjf314 (#4), Live in Phoenix (#9), Nassim (#50) BleuPanda (#71), FrankLotion (#115)

It's just a kiss away!
"It's fun for even the most musically challenged, and it's a great game to play with friends and family. It may have a steep price tag, but you get more than your money's worth", GamerNode
26. Rock Band (2007)



252.645 points/4 votes
Platforms: Xbox 360, PS3, PS2, Wii
Genres: Rhythm, Music, Singing
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 165/573
Fans: Live in Phoenix (#6), andyd1010 (#11), Nassim (#14), FrankLotion (#62)

OUR PRINCESS IS IN ANOTHER CASTLE!
"The sense of excitement, wonder and – most of all – enjoyment felt upon first playing this masterpiece of videogame can't barely [sic] be put into words", Polygon, 2017
25. Super Mario Bros. (1985)



263.092 points/5 votes
Platforms: NES, GBC (Deluxe), Arcade
Genres: 2D platformer, Fantasy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 26/299
Fans: Live in Phoenix (#11), FrankLotion (#13), ordinaryperson (#22), Nick (#26), BleuPanda (#136)

I think we're just getting started
"GoldenEye was the standard for multiplayer console combat. It has been surpassed", Edge
24. Halo: Combat Evolved (2001)



268.079 points/5 votes
Platforms: PC, Xbox, Mac, Xbox One, Xbox X/S
Genres: FPS, Alien, Sci-fi; Vehicular combat, Arena shooter, War, Action horror
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 19/369
Fans: andyd1010 (#7), Live in Phoenix (#12), FrankLotion (#18), Nick (#31), BleuPanda (#244)

Mmmmm...the smell of rotten fruit
"The puzzles are still clever, the dungeons are still brilliantly laid out, the control is spot-on, and the graphics still look sweet", GameNow
23. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past (1991)



268.577 points/5 votes
Platforms: SNES, GBA
Genres: Action-adventure, High fantasy; Open world, Dungeon crawler
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 16/53
Fans: mjf314 (#1), BleuPanda (#18), FrankLotion (#38), Live in Phoenix (#49), Nassim (#57)

Begone! You don't belong in this world, monster!
"Its entertaining single-player content helps keep the game rich with interesting things to do, as well as bolstering its spirit of loving homage to the games that have graced Nintendo consoles", GameSpot
22. Super Smash Bros. Ultimate (2018)



271.103 points/6 votes
Platforms: Switch
Genres: Platform fighting, Fantasy; Sci-fi, User generated content, Board game, Party, Action-adventure
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 206/UR (4.07 from 453 ratings)
Fans: Nick (#5), ValenN (#13), ordinaryperson (#16), BleuPanda (#88), FrankLotion (#144), Nassim (#158)

Life is but a passing dream, but the death that follows is eternal
"It takes the series in interesting new directions and refines many of the series' most important elements", GameSpot
21. Final Fantasy X (2001)



271.706 points/4 votes
Platforms: PS2
Genres: JRPG, Turn-based RPG, High fantasy, Sci-fi; Romance, Sports, Water sports, Steampunk
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 83/308
Fans: FrankLotion (#1), Schüttelbirne (#4), BleuPanda (#14), Nassim (#144)
Last edited by mileswide on Sat Apr 24, 2021 2:42 am, edited 2 times in total.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

mjf314 wrote: Fri Apr 23, 2021 4:47 am
mileswide wrote: Fri Apr 23, 2021 4:17 am Next up, we have the respective best rated titles on Play That Game and Glitchwave as well as a game that was once awarded a mark above 10/10, what could they possibly be? We'll find out in a matter of hours!
#1 Play That Game is Tetris. #1 Glitchwave is Bloodborne, but Bloodborne was one of the runners-up, so I'm not sure what you mean.
If you look at the chart page, it does indeed place Bloodborne at number 1 https://glitchwave.com/charts/top/game/all-time/ but Silent Hill 2's page shows our #36 at the top https://glitchwave.com/game/silent-hill-2/

I can't be certain but I'd imagine the chart page reflects the order of the most recent update, rather than being a real-time ranking. If it's anything like RYM, it'll be done weekly, so there can always be movements in between. In any case, we were both right!
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
Krurze
Unquestionable Presence
Posts: 659
Joined: Tue Aug 12, 2014 10:10 pm
Location: Hamburg

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Krurze »

Enjoying the rollout!

But GTA IV looks suspiciously similar to GTA V here... :)
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Krurze wrote: Fri Apr 23, 2021 9:14 am Enjoying the rollout!

But GTA IV looks suspiciously similar to GTA V here... :)
Not many people know this but they're actually the same game, Rockstar just removed 'I' from the title and hoped no one would notice ;) I'll have to take your word for it as the only GTA I've played is Vice City but I've swapped the screenshot for one that I'm more reliably informed is from 4, thanks either way Krurze!
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
Emerald
Strange Fruit
Posts: 64
Joined: Sun Apr 23, 2017 7:26 pm

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Emerald »

I didn't vote for Half-Life 2.
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Emerald wrote: Fri Apr 23, 2021 10:37 pm I didn't vote for Half-Life 2.
Sorry, that fans section for Half-Life 2 was wholly wrong, but I've now rectified it in its entirety, ta for the tip-off!

Addendum: Just the fans section was wrong, I'd actually got the right data on my spreadsheet, so the score for Half-Life 2 is unchanged.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

HaDOUken!
"Beautifully drawn and animated sprites, tons of speech and the most exciting, action-packed head-to-head conflict yet seen in an arcade game", CVG
20. Street Fighter II: The World Warrior (1991]



271.809 points/5 votes
Platforms: Sega Mega Drive/Genesis, Arcade, SNES, GB, Master System
Genres: Fighting; Martial arts, Fantasy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 22/427
Fans: mileswide (#2), Live in Phoenix (#4), ValenN (#25), FrankLotion (#121), BleuPanda (#137)

Moratta
"Be assured that all those people staring at the TV screen in total disbelief and utter confusion at the carnage they are witnessing will soon be sniffing around that spare joypad, wondering how they can get in on the action", IGN
19. Super Smash Bros. Melee (2001)



274.712 points/5 votes
Platforms: GC
Genres: Platform fighting, Fantasy; 2D platformer, Sci-fi
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 30/53
Fans: andyd1010 (#2), Nick (#13), FrankLotion (#22), Nassim (#46), BleuPanda (#119)

She divided it into 8 units
"Not only is this the best game of the classic series, it's arguably the best game in the history of the NES.", Pocket Games
18. The Legend of Zelda (1986)



276.387 points/5 votes
Platforms: NES, GBA
Genres: Action-adventure, High fantasy, Open world; Dungeon crawler
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 40/409
Fans: Live in Phoenix (#2), mjf314 (#8), Schüttelbirne (#9), FrankLotion (#180), BleuPanda (#189)

Let's a-go!
"Deatchmatch in karts", IGN
17. Mario Kart 64 (1996)



278.861 points/6 votes
Platforms: N64
Genres: Kart racer, Fantasy; Vehicular combat
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 105/413
Fans: mileswide (#9), mjf314 (#10), andyd1010 (#25), Nick (#34), Nassim (#88), FrankLotion (#263)

A city at the bottom of the ocean? Ridiculous....
"Sure, it's fun to play, looks spectacular and is easy to control. But it also does something no other game has done to date: It really makes you feel", L.A. Times
16. BioShock (2007)



228.289 points/4 votes
Platforms: PC, Xbox 360, Xbox One, PS3, PS4, Mac, App, Switch
Genres: FPS, Steampunk, Action horror, Dystopian; Satire, Action RPG, Postmodernism
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 6/119
Fans: Vacantjoy (#1), BleuPanda (#1), FrankLotion (#21), Live in Phoenix (#57)

They're really scraping the bottom of the barrel this time!
"Pleasing to play, beautiful, varied, long completely realised and benefitting from a soundtrack of a high quality, this game is simply one of the best in the Super Nintendo's roster", Jeux vidéo
15. Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy King's Quest (1996)



291.785 points/4 votes
Platforms: SNES, GBA
Genres: 2D platformer, Fantasy; Pirate
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 379/48
Fans: Nassim (#2), ValenN (#3), mjf314 (#3), BleuPanda (#241)

Ya...ING! or however you transcribe a Kirby Strike
"A fighter that is easy enough for anyone to pick up, yet it has enough multiplayer appeal to stay interesting for a good long time", GameSpot
14. Super Smash Bros. (1999)



302.999 points/5 votes
Platforms: N64, Switch
Genres: Platform fighting, Fantasy; Sci-fi, Party
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 205/666
Fans: mileswide (#1), andyd1010 (#3), Edre Peraza (#8), Nassim (#136), FrankLotion (#146)

Please take refuge. We are fine here. We shall greet the morning... together
"There's just so many subtle touches and intricacies that it boggles the mind. The way that time flows...is what's most impressive", IGN
13. The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask (2000)



307.475 points/5 votes
Platforms: N64, GC
Genres: Action-adventure, High fantasy, Time travel, Surrealism; Psychological horror, Open world, Fantasy
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 78/7
Fans: Schüttelbirne (#1), Emerald (#9), BleuPanda (#12), andyd1010 (#34), FrankLotion (#131)

Science Team has vapour for brains
"Retro Studios has set a new standard with its impressive level design. Every area has its own unique presence, yet all are definitely part of the same world", Tech TV
12. Metroid Prime (2002)



324.327 points/4 votes
Platforms: GC, Wii
Genres: Action-adventure, FPS, Alien, Sci-fi; 3D platformer, Metroidvania, Space, Action-horror
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 35/49
Fans: Nick (#2), FrankLotion (#4), BleuPanda (#9), Emerald (#17)

I'm different
"The team has painted a much richer picture that seizes your attention in a steel grip even if it’s telling a similar story", Game Informer
11. Portal 2 (2011)



343.113 points/6 votes
Platforms: Xbox 360, PC, Mac, PS3
Genres: Physics puzzle, Puzzle platformer, Sci-fi, 3D platformer, Comedy; Postmodernism, Black comedy, FPS, Dystopian
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 20/41
Fans: Vacantjoy (#3), ordinaryperson (#15), BleuPanda (#27), Emerald (#28), Nassim (#28), FrankLotion (#45)
Last edited by mileswide on Sat Apr 24, 2021 10:10 am, edited 2 times in total.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

The top 10 is to be unveiled later!
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
FrankLotion
Unquestionable Presence
Posts: 550
Joined: Sat May 05, 2018 9:15 pm

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by FrankLotion »

Pretty sure it doesn’t change the ranking but I think you put Krurze instead of me in the Biggest Fans section of Metroid Prime, still think the presentation has been amazing so far :music-rockon:
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

FrankLotion wrote: Sat Apr 24, 2021 9:21 am Pretty sure it doesn’t change the ranking but I think you put Krurze instead of me in the Biggest Fans section of Metroid Prime, still think the presentation has been amazing so far :music-rockon:
Correct on both counts (i.e. you should be there instead of Krurze obviously and the score hasn't altered at all) but I appreciate you highlighting it! While on that entry, I remembered the fact I'm English and added a 'u' to 'vapour', which accounts for the second edit to that post.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
User avatar
Live in Phoenix
Full of Fire
Posts: 1788
Joined: Wed Jan 02, 2013 12:50 am

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Live in Phoenix »

The rollout emphasizes newer games, so the top 10 is pretty wide open to me. There are only a few games that come to mind, and I'm not sure how many votes they got.
mjf314
Start Me Up
Posts: 21
Joined: Mon Dec 14, 2020 2:34 am

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mjf314 »

I'm surprised to see the original Zelda above A Link to the Past, because I thought most people like A Link to the Past more. Actually the votes seem to agree with this, because 3 of the 4 people who voted for both games gave a better rank to A Link to the Past.
Nick
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2771
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2012 9:28 pm
Location: New York State

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Nick »

Live in Phoenix wrote: Sat Apr 24, 2021 2:15 pm The rollout emphasizes newer games
Does it though? Only 2 of the games in the 11-20 range came out in the past 15 years. I guess it's all just a matter of perspective, but to me, games that came out in the 1990s are definitely "older" games (I was born in 1991 for what it's worth).
User avatar
Live in Phoenix
Full of Fire
Posts: 1788
Joined: Wed Jan 02, 2013 12:50 am

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Live in Phoenix »

Nick wrote: Sat Apr 24, 2021 6:42 pm
Live in Phoenix wrote: Sat Apr 24, 2021 2:15 pm The rollout emphasizes newer games
Does it though? Only 2 of the games in the 11-20 range came out in the past 15 years. I guess it's all just a matter of perspective, but to me, games that came out in the 1990s are definitely "older" games (I was born in 1991 for what it's worth).
Yeah, "newer" is kind of a meaningless description unless you played games when I mostly played them.
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Live in Phoenix wrote: Sat Apr 24, 2021 2:15 pm The rollout emphasizes newer games, so the top 10 is pretty wide open to me. There are only a few games that come to mind, and I'm not sure how many votes they got.
I hope I'm not revealing too much but, similar to what Nick's said about the previous block of ten, only 3 games from the past decade appear in our top 10.
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
mjf314
Start Me Up
Posts: 21
Joined: Mon Dec 14, 2020 2:34 am

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mjf314 »

I can think of 5 games from the 90s that I'm pretty sure will make the top 10. I'm not sure about the other 5.
Emerald
Strange Fruit
Posts: 64
Joined: Sun Apr 23, 2017 7:26 pm

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Emerald »

You're doing a great job with the rollout!

On a side-note, I've noticed 2 correction errors with the games listed. The image you put for Shenmue II, came out in 2001, not 2004. Sonic 3 & Knuckles is listed as one game on Glitchwave, at #216.
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

Emerald wrote: Sat Apr 24, 2021 9:14 pm You're doing a great job with the rollout!

On a side-note, I've noticed 2 correction errors with the games listed. The image you put for Shenmue II, came out in 2001, not 2004. Sonic 3 & Knuckles is listed as one game on Glitchwave, at #216.
Ta Emerald! I've modified the release year for Shenmue 1&2 to 1999 and 2001 respectively, while adding the Glitchwave rank for Sonic & Knuckles of 216 in brackets but keeping the Sonic 3 placing of 488. Let me know if this isn't right :)
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
Emerald
Strange Fruit
Posts: 64
Joined: Sun Apr 23, 2017 7:26 pm

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Emerald »

mileswide wrote: Sun Apr 25, 2021 2:34 am
Emerald wrote: Sat Apr 24, 2021 9:14 pm You're doing a great job with the rollout!

On a side-note, I've noticed 2 correction errors with the games listed. The image you put for Shenmue II, came out in 2001, not 2004. Sonic 3 & Knuckles is listed as one game on Glitchwave, at #216.
Ta Emerald! I've modified the release year for Shenmue 1&2 to 1999 and 2001 respectively, while adding the Glitchwave rank for Sonic & Knuckles of 216 in brackets but keeping the Sonic 3 placing of 488. Let me know if this isn't right :)
Play That Game lists both games separately. There's actually 3 different rankings for Sonic 3 on Glitchwave. Sonic & Knuckles is #498. Sonic 3 is #488. Sonic 3 & Knuckles is #216.
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

It's game time!
"The best looking console game of all time. It is its franchise's redeemer. It is a masterpiece of video game storytelling. It is genuinely tense and occasionally even scary. It is one of the best action games ever released", NintendoWorldReport
10. Resident Evil 4 (2005)



347.969 points/5 votes
Platforms: GC, PC, PS2, Wii, App, PS3, Xbox 360, PS4, Xbox One, Switch
Genres: Action horror, TPS; Survival horror, Zombie, Sci-fi, Occult
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 5/22
Votes: FrankLotion (#5), Vacantjoy (#6), Emerald (#6), BleuPanda (#23), Live in Phoenix (#41)

Don't take this personally, but you getting jacked!
"With its strong story, well-written dialogue, terrific voice cast, impressive graphics, great in-game sound, and extremely entertaining and varied gameplay, [this game] is a stupendous thrill ride that shouldn't be missed", GameSpot
9. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (2004)



350.057 points/6 votes
Platforms: PS2, PC, Xbox, Mac, App, Xbox 360, PS3
Genres: Open world, Mission-based driving, Crime, Action-adventure; Black comedy, Satire, TPS, Racing
Rank That Game/Glitchwave rank: 51/61
Votes: Krurze (#1), Vacantjoy (#4), Edre Peraza (#13), Emerald (#27), BleuPanda (#80), FrankLotion (#126)

Computer gamers with their computer rigs. All they do is cry. They will never get the game
"Rockstar has expanded and improved upon so much of what's special about video games as mainstream spectacles, from the playful use of characters to the refined take on world design", Polygon
8. Grand Theft Auto V (2013)



350.586 points/6 votes
Platforms: PS3, Xbox 360, PS4, Xbox One, PC, PS5, Xbox X/S
Genres: Crime, Mission-based driving, Open world, TPS, Satire, Black comedy; Racing, Action-adventure, Sports
Rank That Game/Glitchwave rank: 30/124
Votes: Edre Peraza (#2), ValenN (#5), Krurze (#14), FrankLotion (#20), Nassim (#66), BleuPanda (#153)

The black wind begins to blow
"[The game is] able to give players the freedom to choose to experience or not experience entire sections of narrative, in any order they wish. This modular style of narrative allowed the developers to create linear character arcs and subplots while still giving players freedom within the overall narrative", GamaSutra, 2012
7. Chrono Trigger (1995)



362.040 points/5 votes
Platforms: SNES, PS1, DS, App, PC
Genres: JRPG, Time travel, High fantasy, Turn-based RPG; Post-apocalyptic, Prehistorical, Medieval, Sci-fi
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 9/15
Fans: Emerald (#3), ordinaryperson (#3), mjf314 (#9), BleuPanda (#21), Nassim (#35)

Hooray! Thank you for rescuing me
"A masterclass in side-scrolling platforming design, to the point that modern 2D game developers should be encouraged to study it as a pre-requisite of mastering their craft", Nintendo Life, 2019
6. Super Mario World (1990)



387.674 points/7 votes
Platforms: SNES, GBA
Genres: 2D platformer, Fantasy; Dinosaur
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 14/15
Fans: mjf314 (#5), Emerald (#12), ordinaryperson (#13), FrankLotion (#29), Live in Phoenix (#30), Nassim (#44), BleuPanda (#64)

I used to be an adventurer like you...
[It's] extremely ambitious, and at its core, extremely successful...when you look back on the experience, it's not the rough spots that'll stand out, but the broad, heroic feeling of being the powerful and change-affecting center of a richly constructed world, GameTrailers
5. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim (2011)



395.267 points/6 votes
Platforms: PC, Xbox 360, PS3, PS4, Xbox One
Genres: Action RPG, Open world, Western RPG, High fantasy; Dungeon crawler, Myth and folklore, Medieval
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 11/517
Fans: Krurze (#2), ordinaryperson (#6), Vacantjoy (#7), FrankLotion (#7), BleuPanda (#43), Nassim (#156)

The only limit is your imagination
"Intuitively interesting and contagiously fun, with an unparalleled scope for creativity and memorable experiences", PC Gamer
4. Minecraft (2011)



396.994 points/6 votes
Platforms: PC, App, Xbox 360, PS3, PS4, Xbox One, Vita, Wii U, Switch, New 3DS
Genres: Sandbox, Survival, Fantasy; User generated content, Zombie, Exploration, MMO
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 21/438
Fans: Edre Peraza (#1), Nick (#1), Vacantjoy (#5), Krurze (#24), FrankLotion (#34), BleuPanda (#172)

Words aren't the only thing that tell people what you're thinking
"Moments of high melodrama are blended with scenes of sheer poetry and vision", Next Generation
3. Final Fantasy VII (1997)



437.993 points/6 votes
Platforms: PS1, PC, App, PS4, Switch, Xbox One
Genres: JRPG, Turn-based RPG, Dystopian, Sci-fi, Steampunk; Cyberpunk, High fantasy, Post-apocalyptic
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 7/66
Fans: Nassim (#1), FrankLotion (#2), ordinaryperson (#4), Nick (#8), BleuPanda (#45), Live in Phoenix (#47)

Wah! Hoo-hoo. YA-HOO! Ha-ha!
"The first true 3D game to play as good as the 2D games of the 16-bit era. ... As such, it represents the new high-water mark of both gameplay and graphic sophistication", Next Generation
2. Super Mario 64 (1996)



440.306 points/8 votes
Platforms: N64, 3DS
Genres: 3D platformer, Fantasy; Collect-a-thon platformer, Open world, Action-adventure
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 3/27
Fans: Schüttelbirne (#6), mileswide (#6), FrankLotion (#11), mjf314 (#12), Nick (#28), Live in Phoenix (#44), Nassim (#71), BleuPanda (#135)


Which means that our winner, with a lead of nearly 100 points over second place is...

1. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1998)!
"The flow of time is always cruel... its speed seems different for each person, but no one can change it... A thing that does not change with time is a memory of younger days"
"This is the masterpiece that people will still be talking about ten years down the road. This is the game that perfectly exhibits the "quality not quantity" mantra that Nintendo has been touting since the N64 was released. In a word, perfect. To call it anything else would be a bald-faced lie", GameSpot


533.578 points/8 votes
Platforms: N64, 3DS
Genres: Action-adventure, High fantasy, Time travel; 3D platformer, Open world, Puzzle
Play That Game/Glitchwave rank: 2/39
Fans: Emerald (#2), mjf314 (#2), Schüttelbirne (#3), Nick (#19), BleuPanda (#22), ordinaryperson (#23), Nassim (#26), FrankLotion (#66)
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
Nick
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2771
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2012 9:28 pm
Location: New York State

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by Nick »

Thanks for the rollout, mileswide! It was great following along! And I’m happy that I voted for all of the top 4 games on our list.
User avatar
mileswide
Full of Fire
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:08 pm
Location: Nottingham, England

Re: AMF's Top Video Games of All Time (2021 Edition): RESULTS!

Post by mileswide »

A big thanks to you all for your patience with the number of errors and the lag in time in the rollout, not to mention your participation in the poll and during the results stage, I can only imagine how much time and deliberation went into all of your lists!

Here's the spreadsheet, give yourselves free rein to juggle the data and make alternative lists as you wish, please say if it doesn't open for whatever reason:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1MJV8T2 ... p=drivesdk
I'd give it all gladly if our lives could be like that
Post Reply