New report errors

[lagire]

Cloud Nine of George Harrison is 4 on allmusic

Lord Willin' of clipse is choice cut instead of neither on RC

4 Way Street of Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young is 4.5 on allmusic

[lagire]

the cooker of lee morgan is 3.5 on allmusic
Sarah Vaughan with Clifford Brown is 5 on allmusic

A Night at Birdland Vol. 2  of art blakey is 4.5 on allmusic
burn of deep purple is 4.5 on allmusic
Our Mother the Mountain  of Townes Van Zandt  is 4 on allmusic

[Henrik]

Note to myself: Gang Starr's "Step in the Arena" seems to be from 1990.
http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=250169

[Henry]

I noticed two items in the acclaimedmusic.net home page that may need to be corrected.

The first item is located in the TOP ALBUMS OF 2012 section. The hyperlink is stated as "Top albums of 2011." Should it instead be "Top albums of 2012.

The second item is located in the TOP ALBUMS OF 2011 section. The parenthetic expression after the "Top 100 albums of 2011" hyperlink presently states "(January 2nd 2011)." Perhaps instead it should read (January 2nd 2012)"

[Henrik]

I noticed two items in the acclaimedmusic.net home page that may need to be corrected.

The first item is located in the TOP ALBUMS OF 2012 section. The hyperlink is stated as "Top albums of 2011." Should it instead be "Top albums of 2012.

The second item is located in the TOP ALBUMS OF 2011 section. The parenthetic expression after the "Top 100 albums of 2011" hyperlink presently states "(January 2nd 2011)." Perhaps instead it should read (January 2nd 2012)"

Man, was I late with this correction. I saw it myself weeks ago! Thanks for reminding me, Henry.

[Nassim]

The Choice is Yours (revisited) by Black Sheep should be from 1991

[mattschroeder]

The link to Labelle seems to be broken.

[lagire]

CHRISTGAU:
A Rainbow in Curved Air - terry riley - A-
Robyn - Robyn - A-
The Mona Lisa's Sister - graham parker - C+
Dedication 2: Gangsta Grillz - DJ Drama & Lil Wayne - choice cut
High Land, Hard Rain - Aztec Camera - A-
Immigres / Bitim Rew - youssou n'dour - B+ / Nelson mandela - B
Fountains of Wayne - Fountains of Wayne - A- / Utopia Parkway - A-
David & david - boomtown - A-

SCARUFFI:
Music for the Masses - depeche mode - 5 / 6 - violator
A Rainbow in Curved Air - terry riley - 8.5 / "In C" - 7
"Heartbreaker" - ryan adams - 6 / 5 - "Rock'n'Roll" / 6.5 - Cold Roses / 5 - Easy Tiger
X&Y - coldplay - 4.5 / Viva La Vida or Death and All His Friends - 5.5
Songs the Lord Taught Us - cramps - 8
Blow by Blow - jeff beck - 7
Cryptograms - deerhunter - 7/ Microcastle - Weird Era Cont. - 6.5
Wild Wood - paul weller - 6
Ringleader of the Tormentors - morrissey - 5
Baduizm - Erykah Badu - 7
Black on Both Sides - mos def - 7
Tidal - Fiona Apple - 7 / When the Pawn... - 6.5/ Extraordinary Machine - 5.5
Let The Blind Lead Those Who Can See But Cannot Feel - atlas sound - 6.5
The XX - XX - 6.5
Pinkerton - weezer - 6
Album - girls - 6.5
Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend - 7
Standing in the Way of Control - gossip - 5.5
The Turning Point  - John Mayall - 7/Blues Breakers with Eric Clapton - 6.5
Degüello - zz top - 6
Chosen Lords - aphex twin - 5
innovator - Derrick May - 8
The Holy Bible - Manic Street Preachers - 6.5
Rejoicing in the Hands - Devendra Banhart - 6.5
Fur & Gold - Bat for Lashes - 6.5
Thunder, Lightning, Strike - go! team - 7
Era Vulgaris - Queens of the Stone Age - 5
The Devil, You & Me - the notwist - 6
Evangelista - Carla Bozulich - 7.5
peter case - peter case - 6.5
Starfish - the church - 5.5
David & david - boomtown - 7.5

ALL MUSIC:
Viva La Vida or Death and All His Friends - coldplay - 4
red - king crimson - 4.5
Medicine Show - The Dream Syndicate - 3.5
Risqué - chic - 4.5
Full Force - Art Ensemble of Chicago - 4
High 'n' Dry - DEF LEPPARD - 4
Microcastle - Weird Era Cont. - deerhunter - 4
22 Dreams - paul weller - 4.5
New Amerykah, Part 1: 4th World War - Erykah Badu - 4.5
Let The Blind Lead Those Who Can See But Cannot Feel - atlas sound - 3.5
Soft Machine - The Soft Machine - 4.5
Go Bo Diddley - Bo Diddley - 4.5 / Bo Diddley's Beach Party - 5
Mother's Milk - red hot chili peppers - 3.5
Santogold - Santigold - 4
Birk's Works - Dizzy Gillespie - 4.5
Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs - Marty robbins - 4.5
Only by the Night - Kings of leon - 3
Ella Wishes You a Swinging Christmas - Ella Fitzgerald 4.5
Straight Outta Compton - N.W.A - 5
Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend - 4.5
Stay Positive - the hold steady - 3
Chega De Saudade - joao gilberto - 4.5
The Pretty Things - The Pretty Things - 4
Revival - Gillian Welch - 4
Time (The Revelator) - Gillian Welch - 4.5
Da Drought 3 - lil wayne - 4 / Tha Carter III - 4
Funky Kingston - Toots & The Maytals - 4
Far Beyond Driven - pantera - 3
The Devil, You & Me - the notwist - 3.5
Be Altitude: Respect Yourself - The Staple Singers - 4
Scoundrel Days - a-ha - 3.5
Big Audio Dynamite - this is Big Audio Dynamite - 4
Hard Line - the blasters - 3.5
Evangelista - Carla Bozulich - 4.5
Brotherhood of Breath - chris mcgregor - 4

Music Story: (added recently on this site)

La Mémoire Neuve - dominique a - 3.5

Other:

Wayne Shorter "native dancer" is in collaboration with milton nascimento and is dated 1974.

[Nick]

I'm not sure if other people have this problem, but whenever I go to a year page (such as "The Top Songs from 2009" page or a page for any other year) there are a number of bubbling under songs that appear above the phrase "Some songs "bubbling under" the all-time top 3000:", and then a number of songs that appear below that phrase. Here's an example of what I'm talking about-

30 2898 Miike Snow
Animal

31 2905 The Pains of Being Pure at Heart
Young Adult Friction

32 2947 Fuck Buttons
Surf Solar

Joker
Digidesign

The Big Pink
Velvet

Bon Iver
Blood Bank

Passion Pit
The Reeling

Neko Case
This Tornado Loves You

Julian Casablancas
11th Dimension

Camera Obscura
French Navy

Basement Jaxx
Raindrops

Editors
Papillon

Some songs "bubbling under" the all-time top 3000:
Arctic Monkeys
Cornerstone

Fever Ray
When I Grow Up

Dirty Projectors and David Byrne
Knotty Pine

Neko Case
People Got a Lotta Nerve

The Avett Brothers
I and Love and You

Pet Shop Boys
Love Etc.

Burial
Moth

Darkstar
Aidy's Girl's a Computer

Big Boi feat. Gucci Mane
Shine Blockas

Black Eyed Peas
I Gotta Feeling

[Nick]

Panic at the Disco's "I Write Sins Not Tragedies" is from 2005, not 2006.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Fever_Yo ... _Sweat_Out

[Nick]

The Flaming Lips song "Waitin' for a Superman" is incorrectly labeled as "Waiting for Superman".

[Listyguy]

Lauryn Hill's "The Zion" should also be credited to Santana.

[Nick]

The Spiritualized song "Stop Your Crying" is incorrectly labeled "Stop Your Cryin'".

Reference: http://www.allmusic.com/album/let-it-co ... 0000006555

Also, I've mentioned this before, but does Dido really deserve dual credit for Eminem's "Stan"? I can understand giving her credit if Dido actually recorded her part specifically for "Stan" or Eminem and Dido worked together in the studio on the song, but "Stan" only contains a sample of the original song (Dido's "Thank You"), not any actual original contribution from Dido. Using this logic, shouldn't The Clash get dual credit for "Paper Planes" and Chic get dual credit for "Rapper's Delight"?

[Nassim]

Smog does not appear on the list of artists starting by S, though early albums by Bill Callahan are rightfully under the moniker Smog on each of their own pages.

[lagire]

Hello, Henrik

did you see all the corrections i have done above, because i often edit this post.

[McJagger]

The Upsetter's "Blackboard Jungle Dub" is #29 on WOEBOTS/Matthew Ingram "100 Greatest Records Ever" list (http://rateyourmusic.com/list/funks/woe ... _complete_), but the album's inclusion in that list is not on its page on this site. I think you might have been confused because it is listed as "Upsetters 14 Dub Black Board Jungle" on Ingram's list, but it is the same album as "Blackboard Jungle Dub" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upsetters_ ... ard_Jungle).

[lagire]

comets on fire link seems to be broken

[Jirin]

Here's an error with the forum, not the list, I don't know where to post those.

My browser has a hard time remembering that I'm logged in. I often have to log in, then when I click on a thread, I have to log in again, then when I click reply, I have to log in again.

I've mostly noticed it while using Safari on Mac.

For instance, it just happened trying to make this post.

[JR]

for Henrik. I noticed that the 2004 Rolling Stone rating for the Whitney Houston album doesn't appear in the info for that album. Are there some albums for which that info did not get added to their info? Thanks.

[Nick]

Cake's song "The Distance" is from 1996, not 1997.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fashion_Nugget

[Bucky the Badger]

Ramble On by Led Zeppelinbis 440 on RS 500 best songs, probably other places

[o.m.]

"Paparazzi" is from 2008...
http://www.discogs.com/Lady-Gaga-The-Fame/master/11126

[Listyguy]

"I'm Eighteen" by Alice Cooper was released as a single in November, 1970 (it was only known as "Eighteen" on the single, but it was the same song).
http://rateyourmusic.com/release/single ... en___body/

[pauldrach]

In the artist listings Billy Ward & the Dominoes are spelled "Dominos".

[o.m.]

"Disco Inferno" is from 1976...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disco_Inferno

[Barry]

"Don't Speak" should be under 1995 I think.

[Nick]

Christina Aguilera's "Beautiful" is from 2002, not 2003. Don't ask me how I know that.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beautiful_ ... ra_song%29

[Nick]

Todd Rundgren's song "Hello It's Me" was first released by Rundgren on his 1972 album "Something/Anything?" and is not from 1966. However, it was recorded first by his old band Nazz and released by Nazz in 1968.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hello_It%27s_Me

[Nick]

On the AM home page, it says "Top 3 Songs of All Time" and below that has the singles cover for "Like a Rolling Stone", "Satisfaction", and "Good Vibrations". Since "Good Vibrations" is now the number 4 song of all time, shouldn't it be replaced with the single cover for "Smells Like Teen Spirit"?

[Nick]

Jay-Z's song "Big Pimpin'" was originally released in 1999, not 2000.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vol._3..._ ... _S._Carter

[Nick]

The Big Pink's song "Dominos" was ranked as the 18th best song of 2009 by Pitchfork, not the 42nd best as this website says. You must have gotten this confused with The Big Pink's "Velvet", which was ranked as the 42nd best song of 2009 by Pitchfork, not the 18th best as this website says.

http://pitchfork.com/features/staff-lis ... of-2009/6/

http://pitchfork.com/features/staff-lis ... of-2009/9/

[Nick]

Miranda Lambert's 2007 album "Crazy Ex-Girlfriend" is now 5 stars on Allmusic, not 4.5 stars.

http://www.allmusic.com/album/crazy-ex- ... 0000488438

[Nick]

Mumford & Sons song "Little Lion Man" is from 2009, not from 2008.

http://rateyourmusic.com/release/single ... _lion_man/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Lion_Man

[Stephan]

Even though the single was not released until 2008, the Love Your Ground EP had Little Lion Man on it, so 2008 is correct.

[Jonathon]

I just noticed that Sufjan Stevens Michigan album doesn't get credit for the 2003 Pitchfork list, where it placed #3 of the year.

[Nick]

The Britney Spears song "...Baby One More Time" was released in 1998, not 1999.

http://rateyourmusic.com/release/single ... more_time/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...Baby_On ... %28song%29

[Listyguy]

The band "Godspeed You! Black Emperor" is listed as "Godspeed You Black Emperor!".

[Harold]

The band "Godspeed You! Black Emperor" is listed as "Godspeed You Black Emperor!".

That's where the exclamation point used to be, until 2002. The two GY!BE albums currently on the AM top 3000 date from the GYBE! era, so that's probably why they're listed that way. Considering that Allelujah! Don't Bend! Ascend! will likely be joining them, the listing should probably be updated to what Walter Sobchak would call "the preferred nomenclature."

[Listyguy]

You have the Cure's "Lovesong" (#1974) listed as "Love Song". There is no space.

[Nick]

David Bowie's album "Scary Monsters" should be listed as "Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps)".

[Nick]

The Michael Andrews/ Gary Jules rendition of "Mad World" was originally released in 2002 on the "Donnie Darko" Soundtrack. This website says that "Mad World" was released in 2003.

http://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/ ... nie_darko/

http://www.allmusic.com/album/donnie-da ... 0000659827

[Live in Phoenix]

I hate to bring this up in light of the '80s poll, but I got the deluxe edition of The Pretenders' first album today, and it said how it first came out in December 1979. So then I decided to check Wikipedia, and it says it came out 27 December 1979. I guess five whole days in the '70s still makes it a '70s album?

[Nick]

I hate to bring this up in light of the '80s poll, but I got the deluxe edition of The Pretenders' first album today, and it said how it first came out in December 1979. So then I decided to check Wikipedia, and it says it came out 27 December 1979. I guess five whole days in the '70s still makes it a '70s album?

Hmmmmmm very interesting....

I did some research myself and found that Rate Your Music, Allmusic, and Discogs all say it was released on January 19th, 1980.

http://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/ ... retenders/

http://www.allmusic.com/album/pretenders-mw0000387388

http://www.discogs.com/Pretenders-Prete ... ster/69563

How are we going to call this one?

[Live in Phoenix]

The CD booklet, besides remarking "Simply titled Pretenders, it arrived in December 1979," later states in the credits, "Pretenders was originally issued as Sire #6083 (12/27/79)." I see that Rate Your Music and Allmusic have a different date ... it's all pretty nuts!

[Henrik]

Someone wanted to change the release year to 1979 at RYM, but it was denied with the following comment:

We can't accept this correction. Here's why.
First, wikipedia is not the best source
Second, here is why 1980 is more likely than 1979
http://www.pretendersarchi...Pretenders.html
Also scans of both UK and US issues show 1980 printed as the year of the release.
http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=1161224
http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=370135

Sometimes it's very important to check additional sources.

[Live in Phoenix]

Argh if I can read small print correctly, the back cover of the UK record says "1979 a Real Recording distributed by **** Records Ltd." with no other date, whilst the U.S. back cover says 1980 Real Records. All in all some some very interesting info to me, but anyway I'm done pondering this, I think I'm off to lie down or cry or put my head between my legs...


EDIT:
(I wanted to comment on the January 19, 1980 release date, though, for anyone who’d love to spend time reading an extra paragraph about this. There were discrepancies between some ‘79/’80 U.K. and U.S. release dates that wreaked havoc on my “Rolling Stone 100 Greatest Albums of the 80’s” book: London Calling is the #1 album of the 1980s, when it never came out in 1980, except stateside in January. Gang of Four’s Entertainment release date is listed as May 1980, Public Image Ltd.’s Second Edition is from March 1980, and The Special’s debut is from, uh, “December 1979” (they mention the album’s U.S. release in 1980). The Pretenders album is listed as January 1980, but because the band was based in the U.K., I wouldn’t be altogether surprised if the 12/27/79 number is the initial U.K. release, and 1/19/80 is the U.S. release. But that is speculation and inference, and I can’t prove that one.)

[Nick]

James Brown's album "The Payback" was originally released in 1973, not 1974 according to AllMusic.
However, RYM says it's a 1974 release. What to do here? If it really is a 1973 release, then not only will the album's date need to be changed, but the song "The Payback"'s date will need to be changed as well.

http://www.allmusic.com/album/the-payback-mw0000086793

http://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/ ... e_payback/

[Nick]

Fleetwood Mac's song "Go Your Own Way" was originally released in December 1976, not 1977 like this website says.

http://rateyourmusic.com/release/single ... r_springs/

[pauldrach]

Betty Everett's "The Shoop Shoop Song (It's in His Kiss)" is currently listed under 1964 while it was originally released on her debut album "You're No Good" in December 1963 under the name "It's in His Kiss (The Shoop-Shoop Song)".

see
http://www.soulfulkindamusic.net/veejay.htm
http://bsnpubs.com/veejay/veejay1071-1154.html

[o.m.]

The KLF's "3 A.M. Eternal" is currently listed under 1991 while it was originally released as a single in May 1989 under the name "3 A.M. Eternal (Pure Trance 2)"...

http://www.discogs.com/KLF-3-AM-Eternal ... ase/140702
http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_KLF