This one at least I found. From this book:
https://books.google.fr/books?id=8ZwZcZ ... navlinks_s
Jeff Wagner is a veteran heavy metal journalist who was a co-editor for the magazine Metal Maniacs before it ceased publication.
The 50 albums list is an appendix in the book. There are actually 51 entries because as the guy who posted the list on RYM states, Wagner considers two albums by maudlin of the Well as one entry.
http://rateyourmusic.com/list/Jhyn/mean ... ff_wagner/
Not sure what Black Sabbath are doing here, and unusual choices for Dream Theater (aside from the first) and Opeth.
Angra | Holy Land | 1996
Arcturus | La masquerade infernale | 1997
Atheist | Unquestionable Presence | 1991
Ayreon | Into the Electric Castle | 1998
Believer | Dimensions | 1993
Black Sabbath | Sabbath Bloody Sabbath | 1975
Celtic Frost | Into the Pandemonium | 1987
Coroner | Mental Vortex | 1991
Crimson Glory | Transcendence | 1988
Cynic | Focus | 1993
Cynic | Traced in Air | 2008
Death | Human | 1991
Devin Townsend | Terria | 2001
Disharmonic Orchestra | Pleasuredome | 1994
Dream Theater | Images and Words | 1992
Dream Theater | Awake | 1994
Dream Theater | Octavarium | 2005
Enslaved | Monumension | 2001
Evergrey | Solitude Dominance Tragedy | 1999
Fates Warning | Awaken the Guardian | 1986
Fates Warning | Perfect Symmetry | 1989
Hammers of Misfortune | The Locust Years | 2006
In the Woods... | Omnio | 2003
Iron Maiden | Seventh Son of a Seventh Son | 1988
maudlin of the Well | Bath | 2001
maudlin of the Well | Leaving Your Body Map | 2001
Mayhem | Grand Declaration of War | 2000
Meshuggah | Destroy Erase Improve | 1995
Mind Over Four | The Goddess | 1990
Obliveon | Nemesis | 1993
Opeth | Morningrise | 1996
Opeth | Still Life | 1999
Pain of Salvation | One Hour by the Concrete Lake | 1998
Pain of Salvation | Be | 2004
Pan.Thy.Monium | Khaooohs | 1993
Psychotic Waltz | Into the Everflow | 1992
Queensrÿche | Rage for Order | 1986
Queensrÿche | Operation: Mindcrime | 1988
Rush | 2112 | 1976
Rush | A Farewell to Kings | 1977
Rush | Moving Pictures | 1981
Sigh | Hail Horror Hail | 1997
Spiral Architect | A Sceptic's Universe | 2000
Thought Industry | Mods Carve the Pig: Assassins, Toads and God's Flesh | 1993
Vauxdvihl | To Dimension Logic | 1994
Voivod | Dimension Hatröss | 1988
Voivod | Nothingface | 1989
Voivod | Angel Rat | 1991
Watchtower | Energetic Disassembly | 1985
Watchtower | Control and Resistance | 1989
Zero Hour | The Towers of Avarice | 2001
Jeff Wagner - Mean Deviation: 50 essential prog metal albums (2010)
Jump to
- Music
- ↳ Music, Music, Music...
- ↳ Rank the tracks
- ↳ Rank the tracks, the sequel
- ↳ Rate the album
- ↳ Poll creations
- ↳ Division game
- ↳ Critics' Lists
- ↳ ALL TIME
- ↳ Artists’ favourites
- ↳ DECADES
- ↳ EOD 2010s
- ↳ 2010s (published later)
- ↳ 2000s
- ↳ 21st century
- ↳ 1990s
- ↳ 1980s
- ↳ 1970s
- ↳ 1960s
- ↳ 1950s
- ↳ Other year spans
- ↳ YEARS
- ↳ EOY 2023
- ↳ Not eligible lists
- ↳ EOY 2022
- ↳ EOY 2021
- ↳ EOY 2020
- ↳ EOY 2019
- ↳ EOY 2018
- ↳ EOY 2017
- ↳ EOY 2016
- ↳ EOY 2015
- ↳ EOY 2014
- ↳ EOY 2013
- ↳ EOY 2012
- ↳ EOY other/various
- ↳ EOY archive
- ↳ Lists published later
- ↳ GENRES
- ↳ Books
- ↳ Genre magazines/websites
- ↳ Subgenres
- ↳ Other magazines/websites
- ↳ COUNTRIES AND LANGUAGES
- ↳ Argentina
- ↳ Australia
- ↳ Bangladesh & Bengali language
- ↳ Bolivia
- ↳ Brazil
- ↳ Canada
- ↳ Chile
- ↳ China
- ↳ Colombia
- ↳ Cuba
- ↳ Denmark
- ↳ Dominican Republic
- ↳ Estonia
- ↳ Finland
- ↳ France & French language
- ↳ Germany & German language
- ↳ Ghana
- ↳ Greece
- ↳ Hungary
- ↳ India
- ↳ Indonesia
- ↳ Ireland
- ↳ Israel
- ↳ Italy
- ↳ Jamaica
- ↳ Japan
- ↳ Mali
- ↳ Mexico
- ↳ Namibia
- ↳ The Netherlands & Dutch language
- ↳ New Zealand
- ↳ Nigeria
- ↳ Norway
- ↳ Peru
- ↳ Poland
- ↳ Portugal
- ↳ Romania
- ↳ Russia
- ↳ Slovakia
- ↳ South Africa
- ↳ South Korea
- ↳ Spain
- ↳ Sweden
- ↳ Taiwan
- ↳ Turkey
- ↳ UK
- ↳ Uruguay
- ↳ USA
- ↳ Venezuela
- ↳ CONTINENTS AND GROUP OF COUNTRIES
- ↳ Africa
- ↳ Arabic language
- ↳ Europe
- ↳ Former Yugoslavia
- ↳ Latin American & Spanish language
- ↳ Non-English languages
- ↳ ARTISTS
- ↳ The Beatles
- ↳ David Bowie
- ↳ Bob Dylan
- ↳ Led Zeppelin
- ↳ Madonna
- ↳ Prince
- ↳ Radiohead
- ↳ The Rolling Stones
- ↳ Bruce Springsteen
- ↳ Neil Young
- ↳ OTHER CATEGORIES
- ↳ Christmas music
- ↳ Debut albums or singles
- ↳ EP’s
- ↳ Female artists
- ↳ Live albums
- ↳ Mixtapes
- ↳ Soundtracks
- ↳ CATEGORIES NOT IN AM DATABASE
- ↳ Guitar music
- ↳ Racial identity
- ↳ Religions
- ↳ Sexual orientation and gender identity
- ↳ LIST OF LISTS
- ↳ REGULARLY UPDATED LISTS
- ↳ NOT PRIORITISED LISTS
- ↳ Single critics & musicians
- ↳ Specific lists (from broader sources)
- ↳ Party
- ↳ Racial identity
- ↳ Sexual orientation and gender identity
- ↳ Short lists
- ↳ Artist lists (albums)
- ↳ Midyear lists
- ↳ Playlists
- ↳ EOY criteria not fulfilled
- ↳ NOT ELIGIBLE FOR ACCLAIMED MUSIC
- ↳ Artist rankings
- ↳ Sales/charts
- ↳ Readers’ lists/public vote
- ↳ Negative or neutral lists
- ↳ Meta lists
- ↳ Compilation albums
- ↳ Radio programmes
- ↳ Artists choose favourites of their own music
- ↳ Not really a list of best albums or songs
- ↳ Other/various exclusion criteria
- ↳ Duplicate topics
- Off-topic
- ↳ Films, Movies, Motion Pictures...
- ↳ General Discussion
- Other
- ↳ Testing Grounds