EOY 2019 - Pazz & Jop Rip-Off

Critics’ end of year 2019 lists.
Post Reply
Donchano
Strange Fruit
Posts: 93
Joined: Sun Nov 03, 2019 2:42 am

EOY 2019 - Pazz & Jop Rip-Off

Post by Donchano » Thu Jan 09, 2020 1:03 pm

[With the demise of beloved New York City alt-weekly The Village Voice in 2018, you can turn to Glenn Boothe and Keith Artin’s own version of the paper’s famous Pazz & Jop, an annual poll of top music releases in a given year compiled from music writers and editors across the country.

Their so-called “Village Voice Paz & Jop Rip-Off Poll” was conduced via private Facebook group, which now includes over 1,100 members—music writers, business execs, or artists themselves. Hundreds of people added their Top 10 Albums of 2019 picks, and the results are now available. {/quote]

http://floodmagazine.com/73002/village- ... s-of-2019/

Full list (Top 1129) : https://pastebin.com/raw/UZfYcxYB?fbcli ... e1PycBHjag

Top 250 :

1. Purple Mountains - s/t (POINTS: 1608, VOTES: 129)
2. Angel Olsen - All Mirrors (POINTS: 660, VOTES: 64)
3. Billie Eilish - When We All Fall Asleep, Where Do We Go? (POINTS: 595, VOTES: 57)
4. Lizzo - Cuz I Love You (POINTS: 582, VOTES: 54)
5. Weyes Blood - Titanic Rising (POINTS: 472, VOTES: 40)
6. Sharon Van Etten - Remind Me Tomorrow (POINTS: 441, VOTES: 40)
7. Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds - Ghosteen (POINTS: 429, VOTES: 35)
8. 75 Dollar Bill - I Was Real (POINTS: 406, VOTES: 40)
9. Lana Del Rey - Norman Fucking Rockwell (POINTS: 383, VOTES: 35)
10. Fontaines DC - Dogrel (POINTS: 356, VOTES: 34)
11. Cate Le Bon - Reward (POINTS: 337, VOTES: 31)
12. Mdou Moctar - Ilana: The Creator (POINTS: 335, VOTES: 35)
13. Big Thief - Two Hands (POINTS: 327, VOTES: 30)
14. Big Thief - U.F.O.F. (POINTS: 305, VOTES: 34)
15. Kim Gordon - No Home Record (POINTS: 293, VOTES: 30)
16. Aldous Harding - Designer (POINTS: 287, VOTES: 26)
17. The Paranoid Style - A Goddamn Impossible Way of Life (POINTS: 249, VOTES: 20)
18. Ex Hex - It's Real (POINTS: 246, VOTES: 24)
19. Brittany Howard - Jaime (POINTS: 245, VOTES: 25)
20. Tyler, the Creator - IGOR (POINTS: 234, VOTES: 22)
21. black midi - Schlagenheim (POINTS: 229, VOTES: 23)
22. Jamila Woods - Legacy! Legacy! (POINTS: 221, VOTES: 23)
23. Carsie Blanton - Buck Up (POINTS: 207, VOTES: 20)
24. DIIV - Deceiver (POINTS: 205, VOTES: 18)
25. Better Oblivion Community Center - s/t (POINTS: 203, VOTES: 19)
26. Michael Kiwanuka - Kiwanuka (POINTS: 202, VOTES: 16)
27. Bruce Springsteen - Western Stars (POINTS: 198, VOTES: 19)
28. Vampire Weekend - Father of the Bride (POINTS: 192, VOTES: 20)
29. Pernice Brothers - Spread the Feeling (POINTS: 187, VOTES: 19)
30. The New Pornographers - In the Morse Code of Brake Lights (POINTS: 184, VOTES: 23)
31. The Highwomen - s/t (POINTS: 179, VOTES: 18)
32. Bill Callahan - Shepherd in a Sheepskin Vest (POINTS: 176, VOTES: 17)
33. Sturgill Simpson - Sound & Fury (POINTS: 157, VOTES: 15)
34. FKA Twigs - Magdalene (POINTS: 156, VOTES: 15)
34. Deerhunter - Why Hasn't Everything Already Disappeared? (POINTS: 156, VOTES: 13)
36. Little Simz - Grey Area (POINTS: 155, VOTES: 13)
37. Guided By Voices - Zeppelin Over China (POINTS: 152, VOTES: 14)
38. Chance the Rapper - Big Day (POINTS: 150, VOTES: 16)
39. that dog - Old LP (POINTS: 149, VOTES: 16)
40. The National - I Am Easy to Find (POINTS: 147, VOTES: 14)
41. Oh Sees - Face Stabber (POINTS: 145, VOTES: 15)
42. Sleater-Kinney - The Center Won't Hold (POINTS: 142, VOTES: 13)
43. Jenny Lewis - On the Line (POINTS: 141, VOTES: 15)
44. Wilco - Ode to Joy (POINTS: 133, VOTES: 16)
44. Yola - Walk Through Fire (POINTS: 133, VOTES: 14)
46. Swervedriver - Future Ruins (POINTS: 131, VOTES: 13)
47. Guided By Voices - Warp and Woof (POINTS: 130, VOTES: 10)
48. Wand - Laughing Matter (POINTS: 121, VOTES: 11)
49. Mike Krol - Power Chords (POINTS: 120, VOTES: 12)
50. Possible Humans - Everybody Split (POINTS: 119, VOTES: 12)
51. Danny Brown - uknowhatimsayin¿ (POINTS: 118, VOTES: 15)
51. Miranda Lambert - Wildcard (POINTS: 118, VOTES: 13)
53. The Stroppies - Whoosh (POINTS: 117, VOTES: 13)
53. Raphael Saadiq - Jimmy Lee (POINTS: 117, VOTES: 10)
55. The Comet Is Coming - Trust in the Lifeforce of the Deep Mystery (POINTS: 114, VOTES: 13)
55. Charly Bliss - Young Enough (POINTS: 114, VOTES: 12)
57. Joshua Abrams & Natural Information Society - Mandatory Reality (POINTS: 113, VOTES: 10)
58. Mekons - Deserted (POINTS: 111, VOTES: 8)
59. Bob Mould - Sunshine Rock (POINTS: 110, VOTES: 12)
60. Ariana Grande - thank u, next (POINTS: 108, VOTES: 11)
60. Steve Gunn - The Unseen In Between (POINTS: 108, VOTES: 11)
62. Arthur Russell - Iowa Dream (POINTS: 105, VOTES: 9)
62. Damon Locks' Black Monument Ensemble - Where Future Unfolds (POINTS: 105, VOTES: 9)
64. Drab Majesty - Modern Mirror (POINTS: 103, VOTES: 11)
65. Matana Roberts - Coin Coin Chapter Four: Memphis (POINTS: 102, VOTES: 9)
66. Freddie Gibbs & Madlib - Bandana (POINTS: 101, VOTES: 11)
67. Rachid Taha - Je Suis African (POINTS: 100, VOTES: 9)
68. Rapsody - Eve (POINTS: 99, VOTES: 12)
69. Sunwatchers - Illegal Moves (POINTS: 98, VOTES: 10)
69. Taylor Swift - Lover (POINTS: 98, VOTES: 8)
71. Anderson.Paak - Ventura (POINTS: 95, VOTES: 11)
71. Thigh Master - Now For Example (POINTS: 95, VOTES: 10)
71. (Sandy) Alex G - House of Sugar (POINTS: 95, VOTES: 9)
71. Guided By Voices - Sweating the Plague (POINTS: 95, VOTES: 9)
75. Bon Iver - I,I (POINTS: 94, VOTES: 9)
76. Todd Snider - The Cash Cabin Sessions, Vol. 3 (POINTS: 93, VOTES: 10)
76. Carly Rae Jepsen - Dedicated (POINTS: 93, VOTES: 8)
76. Telekinesis - Effluxion (POINTS: 93, VOTES: 7)
79. Drugdealer - Raw Honey (POINTS: 92, VOTES: 8)
79. billy woods + kenny segal - Hiding Places (POINTS: 92, VOTES: 7)
81. Mannequin Pussy - Patience (POINTS: 91, VOTES: 9)
82. John Coltrane - Blue World (POINTS: 90, VOTES: 10)
82. The Muffs - No Holiday (POINTS: 90, VOTES: 10)
82. Tanya Tucker - While I'm Livin' (POINTS: 90, VOTES: 8)
85. Pedro the Lion - Phoenix (POINTS: 88, VOTES: 11)
86. Helado Negro - This is How You Smile (POINTS: 85, VOTES: 9)
87. Fennesz - Agora (POINTS: 84, VOTES: 8)
88. Sault - 5 (POINTS: 83, VOTES: 8)
88. Strand of Oaks - Eraserland (POINTS: 83, VOTES: 8)
90. Priests - The Seduction of Kansas (POINTS: 81, VOTES: 8)
90. Leonard Cohen - Thanks for the Dance (POINTS: 81, VOTES: 7)
90. Fruit Bats - Gold Past Life (POINTS: 81, VOTES: 6)
93. Nilüfer Yanya - Miss Universe (POINTS: 80, VOTES: 9)
93. Reese McHenry - No Dados (POINTS: 80, VOTES: 9)
93. Bill Orcutt - Odds Against Tomorrow (POINTS: 80, VOTES: 8)
93. Solange - When I Get Home (POINTS: 80, VOTES: 7)
93. The Regrettes - How Do You Love (POINTS: 80, VOTES: 6)
98. Pip Blom - Boat (POINTS: 79, VOTES: 10)
99. Jaimie Branch - Fly Or Die II: Bird Dogs of Paradise (POINTS: 78, VOTES: 7)
100. Chemical Brothers - No Geography (POINTS: 76, VOTES: 8)
100. Sunn O))) - Life Metal (POINTS: 76, VOTES: 6)
102. Sacred Paws - Run Around the Sun (POINTS: 75, VOTES: 10)
102. Tyler Childers - Country Squire (POINTS: 75, VOTES: 6)
102. Andrew Bird - My Finest Work Yet (POINTS: 75, VOTES: 5)
105. Beck - Hyperspace (POINTS: 73, VOTES: 8)
105. Jay Som - Anak Ko (POINTS: 73, VOTES: 8)
105. Jessica Pratt - Quiet Signs (POINTS: 73, VOTES: 7)
105. The Delines - The Imperial (POINTS: 73, VOTES: 7)
105. Faye Webster - Atlanta Millionaires Club (POINTS: 73, VOTES: 6)
110. Joan Shelley - Like the River Loves the Sea (POINTS: 72, VOTES: 8)
110. Stella Donnelly - Beware of the Dogs (POINTS: 72, VOTES: 8)
110. Corridor - Junior (POINTS: 72, VOTES: 7)
110. Beyonce - Homecoming: The Live Album (POINTS: 72, VOTES: 6)
110. James Blake - Assume Form (POINTS: 72, VOTES: 5)
115. Hand Habits - Placeholder (POINTS: 70, VOTES: 8)
115. The Mountain Goats - In League With Dragons (POINTS: 70, VOTES: 7)
115. ISS - Alles 3rd Gut (POINTS: 70, VOTES: 6)
118. Chuck Cleaver - Send Aid (POINTS: 69, VOTES: 7)
119. Ezra Furman - 12 Nudes (POINTS: 68, VOTES: 8)
119. Joe Henry - The Gospel According to Water (POINTS: 68, VOTES: 6)
119. Thurston Moore Group - Spirit Counsel (POINTS: 68, VOTES: 6)
122. Black Marble - Bigger Than Life (POINTS: 67, VOTES: 7)
123. Control Top - Covert Contracts (POINTS: 66, VOTES: 7)
124. Thom Yorke - Anima (POINTS: 65, VOTES: 8)
124. Ty Segall - First Taste (POINTS: 65, VOTES: 7)
124. Khruangbin - Hasta El Cielo (Con Todo El Mundo In Dub) (POINTS: 65, VOTES: 4)
127. Bleached - Do You Think You've Had Enough? (POINTS: 64, VOTES: 5)
128. Martha - Love Keeps Kicking (POINTS: 63, VOTES: 6)
129. Richard Dawson - 2020 (POINTS: 62, VOTES: 6)
130. Jeffrey Lewis & the Voltage - Bad Wiring (POINTS: 61, VOTES: 7)
130. Julia Jacklin - Crushing (POINTS: 61, VOTES: 7)
130. DaBaby - Blank Blank (POINTS: 61, VOTES: 5)
130. White Reaper - You Deserve Love (POINTS: 61, VOTES: 5)
134. Sebadoh - Act Surprised (POINTS: 60, VOTES: 7)
134. Tropical Fuck Storm - Braindrops (POINTS: 60, VOTES: 7)
134. Comet Gain - Fireraisers Forever! (POINTS: 60, VOTES: 6)
134. Floating Points - Crush (POINTS: 60, VOTES: 6)
134. The Twilight Sad - It Won't Be Like This All the Time (POINTS: 60, VOTES: 6)
134. The Who - WHO (POINTS: 60, VOTES: 5)
140. Orville Peck - Pony (POINTS: 59, VOTES: 7)
140. Jake Xerxes Fussell - Out of Sight (POINTS: 59, VOTES: 6)
142. King Gizzard & the Lizard Wizard - Infest the Rats' Nest (POINTS: 58, VOTES: 6)
142. Honey Radar - Ruby Puff of Dust (POINTS: 58, VOTES: 5)
142. Robyn Hitchcock & Andy Partridge - Planet England EP (POINTS: 58, VOTES: 5)
145. Denzell Curry - ZUU (POINTS: 57, VOTES: 7)
145. Boy Harsher - Careful (POINTS: 57, VOTES: 5)
145. The Murder Capital - When I Have Fears (POINTS: 57, VOTES: 5)
148. Kate Tempest - The Book of Traps & Lessons (POINTS: 56, VOTES: 4)
149. Mick Trouble - Here's the Mick Trouble LP (POINTS: 55, VOTES: 6)
149. Spray Paint - Into The Country (POINTS: 55, VOTES: 6)
149. Hiss Golden Messenger - Terms of Surrender (POINTS: 55, VOTES: 5)
149. Mikal Cronin - Seeker (POINTS: 55, VOTES: 5)
149. The Minus Five - Stroke Manor (POINTS: 55, VOTES: 5)
154. Black Keys - Let's Rock (POINTS: 54, VOTES: 7)
154. Apex Manor - Heartbreak City (POINTS: 54, VOTES: 5)
156. Garcia Peoples - One Step Behind (POINTS: 53, VOTES: 6)
156. Oso Oso - Basking in the Glow (POINTS: 53, VOTES: 6)
156. The Jeanines - s/t (POINTS: 53, VOTES: 6)
159. Sleaford Mods - Eton Alive (POINTS: 52, VOTES: 6)
159. Uranium Club - The Cosmo Cleaners (POINTS: 52, VOTES: 5)
159. James Brandon Lewis - An UnRuly Manifesto (POINTS: 52, VOTES: 4)
162. Clairo - Immunity (POINTS: 51, VOTES: 6)
162. Redd Kross - Beyond the Door (POINTS: 51, VOTES: 6)
162. Prince - Originals (POINTS: 51, VOTES: 5)
162. Sir Babygirl - Crush on Me (POINTS: 51, VOTES: 5)
166. Black Pumas - s/t (POINTS: 50, VOTES: 5)
166. Hot Chip - A Bath Full of Ectasy (POINTS: 50, VOTES: 5)
166. The Dream Syndicate - These Times (POINTS: 50, VOTES: 5)
166. Dumb - Club Nites (POINTS: 50, VOTES: 4)
166. Tindersticks - No Treasure But Hope (POINTS: 50, VOTES: 3)
171. Molly Sarle - Karaoke Angel (POINTS: 49, VOTES: 4)
172. Amyl and the Sniffers - s/t (POINTS: 48, VOTES: 5)
172. Black Belt Eagle Scout - At the Party With My Brown Friends (POINTS: 48, VOTES: 5)
172. Karen O and Dangermouse - Lux Prima (POINTS: 48, VOTES: 5)
172. L'Epee - Diabolique (POINTS: 48, VOTES: 4)
176. Sudan Archives - Athena (POINTS: 47, VOTES: 6)
176. Altin Gün - Gece (POINTS: 47, VOTES: 5)
176. Great Grandpa - Four of Arrows (POINTS: 47, VOTES: 5)
179. Tool - Fear Inoculum (POINTS: 46, VOTES: 5)
179. The Leisure Society - Arrivals and Departures (POINTS: 46, VOTES: 3)
181. Gong Gong Gong - Phantom Rhythm (POINTS: 45, VOTES: 6)
181. Chastity Belt - s/t (POINTS: 45, VOTES: 5)
181. Eddy Current Suppression Ring - All in Good Time (POINTS: 45, VOTES: 5)
181. Young Guv - Guv I (POINTS: 45, VOTES: 5)
181. Foxhall Stacks - The Coming Collapse (POINTS: 45, VOTES: 4)
181. Lee "Scratch" Perry - Rainford (POINTS: 45, VOTES: 4)
181. Bangzz - Fresh Cut (POINTS: 45, VOTES: 3)
181. Pixies - Beneath the Eyrie (POINTS: 45, VOTES: 3)
181. Jesca Hoop - Stonechild (POINTS: 45, VOTES: 2)
190. David Kilgour & the Heavy Eights - Bobbie's a Girl (POINTS: 44, VOTES: 6)
190. Hatchie - Keepsake (POINTS: 44, VOTES: 5)
192. Lightning Dust - Spectre (POINTS: 43, VOTES: 5)
192. William Tyler - Goes West (POINTS: 43, VOTES: 5)
192. Damien Jurado - In the Shape of a Storm (POINTS: 43, VOTES: 4)
192. Kanye West - Jesus Is King (POINTS: 43, VOTES: 4)
192. Robert Forster - Inferno (POINTS: 43, VOTES: 4)
197. J.S. Ondara - Tales of America (POINTS: 42, VOTES: 4)
197. Loamlands - Lez Dance (POINTS: 42, VOTES: 4)
197. Meat Puppets - Dusty Notes (POINTS: 42, VOTES: 4)
197. The Cowboys - The Bottom of a Rotten Flower (POINTS: 42, VOTES: 3)
201. Cherry Glazerr - Stuffed and Ready (POINTS: 41, VOTES: 6)
201. 100 gecs - 1000 gecs (POINTS: 41, VOTES: 5)
201. Titus Andronicus - An Obelisk (POINTS: 41, VOTES: 5)
201. Khalid - Free Spirit (POINTS: 41, VOTES: 3)
201. Madonna - Madame X (POINTS: 41, VOTES: 3)
206. Dark Blue - Victory is Rated (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 5)
206. American Football - LP3 (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 4)
206. Blanck Mass - Animated Violence Mild (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 4)
206. Caroline Shaw/Attacca Quartet - Orange (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 4)
206. Kevin Morby - Oh My God (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 4)
206. Parsnip - When the Tree Bears Fruit (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 4)
206. Rhiannon Giddens & Francesco Turrisi - There Is No Other (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 4)
206. Stef Chura - Midnight (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 4)
206. SUSS - High Line (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 4)
206. Y La Bamba - Mujeres (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 4)
206. Christian Fitness - You Are the Ambulance (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 3)
206. Durand Jones & the Indications - American Love Call (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 3)
206. The Hecks - My Star (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 3)
206. Get Up Kids - Problems (POINTS: 40, VOTES: 2)
220. Battles - Juice B Crypts (POINTS: 39, VOTES: 5)
220. FACS - Lifelike (POINTS: 39, VOTES: 4)
220. Lloyd Cole - Guesswork (POINTS: 39, VOTES: 4)
223. Vanishing Twin - The Age of Immunology (POINTS: 38, VOTES: 4)
223. Chris Brokaw - End of the Night (POINTS: 38, VOTES: 3)
225. DIÄT - Positive Disintegration (POINTS: 37, VOTES: 5)
225. Malibu Ken - s/t (POINTS: 37, VOTES: 4)
225. NOTS - 3 (POINTS: 37, VOTES: 4)
225. Chelsea Wolfe - Birth of Violence (POINTS: 37, VOTES: 3)
229. Brutus - Nest (POINTS: 36, VOTES: 5)
229. Cass McCombs - Tip of the Sphere (POINTS: 36, VOTES: 4)
229. Full of Hell - Weeping Choir (POINTS: 36, VOTES: 4)
229. Holly Herndon - PROTO (POINTS: 36, VOTES: 4)
229. Lower Dens - The Competition (POINTS: 36, VOTES: 4)
234. Kneeling in Piss - Tour de Force (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 4)
234. Leyla McCalla - The Capitalist Blues (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 4)
234. Local Natives - Violet Street (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 4)
234. Modern Nature - How To Live (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 4)
234. The Hold Steady - Thrashing Through the Passion (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 4)
234. Cage the Elephant - Social Cues (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 3)
234. Claypool Lennon Delerium - South of Reality (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 3)
234. Crumb - Jinx (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 3)
234. Temples - Hot Motion (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 3)
234. Tycho - Weather (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 3)
234. Various Artists - Kankyo Ongaku: Japanese Ambient, Environmental, etc. (POINTS: 35, VOTES: 3)
245. Mavis Staples - Live in London (POINTS: 34, VOTES: 4)
245. Drahla - Useless Coordinates (POINTS: 34, VOTES: 3)
245. Girl Band - The Talkies (POINTS: 34, VOTES: 3)
245. Lingua Ignota - Caligula (POINTS: 34, VOTES: 3)
245. Mark Lomax II - 400: An African Epic (POINTS: 34, VOTES: 2)
250. Gospelbeach - Let It Burn (POINTS: 33, VOTES: 4)
250. Lightning Bolt - Sonic Citadel (POINTS: 33, VOTES: 4

Future Critic
Let's Get It On
Posts: 175
Joined: Wed Sep 19, 2012 4:04 am

Re: EOY 2019 - Pazz & Jop Rip-Off

Post by Future Critic » Thu Jan 09, 2020 3:31 pm

It's really too bad these replacements completely ignore the song side of things. Of course the albums have always gotten more attention, but the songs piece is just as important in my opinion.

User avatar
Henrik
Site Admin
Posts: 5421
Joined: Sun Feb 05, 2012 10:09 am
Location: Älvsjö, Stockholm, Sweden
Contact:

Re: EOY 2019 - Pazz & Jop Rip-Off

Post by Henrik » Thu Jan 09, 2020 4:33 pm

I think this is eligible, right?
Everyone you meet fights a battle you know nothing about. Be kind. Always.

panam
Full of Fire
Posts: 1035
Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2016 4:21 am

Re: EOY 2019 - Pazz & Jop Rip-Off

Post by panam » Thu Jan 09, 2020 9:36 pm

Henrik wrote:
Thu Jan 09, 2020 4:33 pm
I think this is eligible, right?
More obscure than last pazz & jop results but equally eligible.

User avatar
Cold Butterfly
Different Class
Posts: 470
Joined: Sun Dec 09, 2018 2:28 am
Location: Washington D.C. area

Re: EOY 2019 - Pazz & Jop Rip-Off

Post by Cold Butterfly » Thu Jan 09, 2020 10:52 pm

Isn't Pazz & Jop still around though? There was a poll last year, although the Village Voice had already been shut down for a while by then.

Edit: It says the poll was discontinued, but I don't recall hearing anything about that

Harold
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2120
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 3:56 pm

Re: EOY 2019 - Pazz & Jop Rip-Off

Post by Harold » Mon Jan 13, 2020 9:16 pm

I'll include the top 100 (101).

Post Reply