EOY 2018: Uproxx Music Critics Poll

Post Reply
Harold
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1937
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 3:56 pm

EOY 2018: Uproxx Music Critics Poll

Post by Harold » Thu Jan 10, 2019 2:30 pm

Creating a thread for this poll of almost 200 critics, an obvious attempt to create a successor the now-defunct Village Voice's iconic Pazz and Jop poll (although, as I posted on the sources thread, whatever's left of the Voice is trying to keep P&J going somehow - we'll see how that turns out). Can someone please transcribe at least the top 50? Thanks in advance.

https://uproxx.com/critic-polls/uproxx- ... 18-albums/

Harold
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1937
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 3:56 pm

Re: EOY 2018: Uproxx Music Critics Poll

Post by Harold » Thu Jan 10, 2019 3:02 pm

Eh, may as well make it the top 100. Thanks again!

Future Critic
Let's Get It On
Posts: 132
Joined: Wed Sep 19, 2012 4:04 am

Re: EOY 2018: Uproxx Music Critics Poll

Post by Future Critic » Thu Jan 10, 2019 3:48 pm

thank u, next won the music poll.

https://uproxx.com/critic-polls/uproxx- ... 018-songs/

I'm at work for the next 8 hours or so, but will transcribe it this evening if nobody offers to do it before then.

Jimoincolor
Are You Experienced?
Posts: 27
Joined: Fri Dec 02, 2016 9:50 am

Re: EOY 2018: Uproxx Music Critics Poll

Post by Jimoincolor » Thu Jan 10, 2019 3:56 pm

1
GOLDEN HOUR (ALBUM) / KACEY MUSGRAVES

2
DIRTY COMPUTER / JANELLE MONAE

3
BE THE COWBOY / MITSKI

4
DAYTONA / PUSHA T

5
INVASION OF PRIVACY / CARDI B

6
HISTORIAN / LUCY DACUS

7
SWEETENER (ALBUM) / ARIANA GRANDE

8
A BRIEF INQUIRY INTO ONLINE RELATIONSHIPS / THE 1975

9
BOYGENIUS / BOYGENIUS

10
ROOM 25 / NONAME

11
ASTROWORLD/ Travis Scott

12
LUSH

13
Bark Your Head Off, Dog

14
Honey (Album)

15
7

16
Nearer My God

17
Interstate Gospel

18
Double Negative

19
Black Panther OST

20
Clean

21
Wide Awake (Album)

22
Isolation

23
Heaven and Earth

24
Care For Me

25
Some Rap Songs

26
OIL OF EVERY PEARL’S UNINSIDES

27
Knock Knock

28
What A Time To Be Alive (Album)

29
Hell-On

30
Tranquility Base Hotel & Casino

31
Future Me Hates Me (Album)

32
In A Poem Unlimited

33
Gods Favorite Customer

34
The Tree of Forgiveness

35
Everything Is Love

36
Wolastoqiyik Lintuwakonawa

37
2012-2017

38
Your Queen Is A Reptile

39
Tell Me How You Really Feel

40
Whack World

41
Soil

42
Safe In The Hands Of Love

43
Chris

44
Age Of

45
To The Sunset

46
Girl Going Nowhere (Album)

47
Ordinary Corrupt Human Love

48
Post

49
Yolk In The Fur

50
Iridescence

51
OUR RAW HEART

52
FM!

53
REDEMPTION

54
HIVE MIND

55
KIDS SEE GHOSTS (ALBUM)

56
SINGULARITY

57
CON TODO EL MUNDO

58
CHAMPIONSHIPS (ALBUM)

59
RECORD

60
SWIMMING

61
THE FUTURE AND THE PAST

62
MUDBOY

63
VENTRILOQUISM

64
EPHORIZE

65
HOW TO SOCIALISE AND MAKE FRIENDS

66
BOTTLE IT IN

67
DYING STAR

68
DEVOTION

69
BY THE WAY, I FORGIVE YOU

70
COCOA SUGAR

71
MAGUS

72
BEYONDLESS

73
TWIN FANTASY

74
TA13OO

75
US

76
THE SCIENCES

77
LONER

78
IM ALL EARS

79
SPARKLE HARD

80
FREEDOM

81
LAVENDER

82
LP5000

83
HEAVEN

84
NEGRO SWAN

85
NEGATIVE CAPABILITY

86
EL MAL QUERER

87
AND NOTHING HURT

88
JOY AS AN ACT OF RESISTANCE

89
MITH

90
ERRORZONE

91
ONLY LOVE

92
WANDERER

93
SONGS OF PRAISE

94
VOICENOTES

95
LOVE IS DEAD

96
MAY YOUR KINDNESS REMAIN

97
DOSE YOUR DREAMS

98
WHAT PEOPLE CALL LOW SELF-ESTEEM IS REALLY JUST SEEING YOURSELF THE WAY THAT OTHER PEOPLE SEE YOU

99
STARFIRE

100
THE LOUDER I CALL, THE FASTER IT RUNS (ALBUM)


PS: didn't add the artists' names after the top 10 because the site omitted them. I can do it later, if you want

Future Critic
Let's Get It On
Posts: 132
Joined: Wed Sep 19, 2012 4:04 am

Re: EOY 2018: Uproxx Music Critics Poll

Post by Future Critic » Thu Jan 10, 2019 7:00 pm

Songs:

1. thank u, next | Ariana Grande
2. This is America | Childish Gambino
3. Nobody | Mistki
4. Make Me Feel | Janelle Monae
4. Night Shift | Lucy Dacus
6. SICKO MODE | Travis Scott
7. I Like It | Carli B
8. Love It If We Made It | The 1975
9. Nice for What | Drake
10. Slow Burn | Kacey Musgraves
11. King's Dead | Kendrick Lamar
12. The Middle | Zedd and Maren Morris
12. No Tears Left to Cry | Ariana Grande
14. High Horse | Kacey Musgraves
14. Me & My Dog | boygenius
16. Apeshit | The Cartesr
17. Honey | Robyn
18. Pristine | Snail Mail
19. All the Stars | Kendrick Lamar
20. If You Know You Know | Pusha T
21. Boo'd Up | Ella Mai
22. Space Cowboy | Kacey Musgraves
23. Mo Bamba | Sheck Wes
24. Your Dog | Soccer Mommy
25. Venice Bitch | Lana Del Rey
26. Heat Wave | Snail Mail
26. Geyser | Mitski
28. Missing U | Robyn
28. PYNK | Janelle Monae
28. Shallow | Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga
31. How Simple | Hop Along
31. In My Feelings | Drake
33. Bad Luck | Neko Case
34. The Story of Adidon | Pusha T
35. Powerflide | Rae Sremmurd
36. Salt in the Wound | boygenius
37. Drip Too Hard | Lil Baby
38. The Games We Play | Pusha T
38. Shoota | Playboi Carti
40. Short Court Style | Natalie Prass
40. Mr. Tillman | Father John Misty
40. Two Slow Dancers | Mitski
43. Mariners Apartment Complex | Lana Del Rey
44. Talking Straight | Black Coastal Fever
44. Bodys | Car Seat Headrest
46. Golden Hour | Kacey Musgraves
46. When I'm With Him | Empress Of
48. Malamente (Cap. 1: Augurio) | Rosalia
48. God's Plan | Drake
48. Summer's End | John Prine
48. Freebird II | Parquet Courts
48. My My My! | Troye Sivan
48. Womp Womp | Valee
48. Last Lion of Albion | Neko Case
48. Stir Fry | Migos
56. In My Blood | Shawn Mendes
56. High | Young Thug
56. Sad! |XXXTentacion
59. Cool | Soccer Mommy
59. Star Treatment | Arctic Monkeys
69. Slapstick | Foxing
62. Noid | Yves Tumor
62. Boys | Finesse (remix) | Bruno Mars
62. Boys | Lizzo
62. New Light | John Mayer
62. Never Be the Same | Camila Cabello
62. Best Years of My Life | Pistol Annies
68. Party for One | Carly Rae Jepsen
68. I Woke Up in a F&cked-Up America | Lonnie Holley
68. It Makes You Forget | Peggy Gou
68. Moon River | Frank Ocean
68. Doesn't Matter | Christine and the Queens
73. Django Jane | Janelle Monae
73. Colossus | IDLES
73. Bassackwards | Kurt Vile
73. Graffiti | Chvrches
77. Not Abel | Hop Along
77. Girlfriend | Christine and the Queens
77. Is it Cold in the Water | Sophie
77. Give Yourself a Try | The 1975
77. Fallingwater | Maggie Rogers
77. Lucid Dreams | Juice Wrld
77. Mona Lisa | Lil Wayne
77. Bad Bad News | Leon Bridges
85. Hot Pink | Let's Eat Grandma
85. Be Careful | Cardi B
85. Babylon | Oneohtrix Point Never
88. Music Is Worth Living For | Andrew W.K.
88. Self Care | Mac Miller
88. Jewelry | Blood Orange
88. Gonna Love Me | Teyana Tylor
88. A$AP Forever | A$AP Rocky
93. Overtime | Jessie Ware
93. Nont For Sale | Sudan Archives
93. Humility | Gorillaz
93. Lemon Glow | Beach House
93. Four Out of Five | Arctic Monkeys
93. R.E.M. | Ariana Grande
93. Sticky | Ravyn Lenae
100. Worthless Animal | Deafheaven
100. Nameless, Faceless | Courtney Barnett
100. Queen | Tracey Thorn
100. The Opener | Camp Cope
100. One Kiss | Calvin Harris
100. Ponyboy | Sophie
100. Breathin | Ariana Grande
100. Work It | Marie Davidson

cheekyjh2
Superunknown
Posts: 7
Joined: Mon Dec 26, 2016 3:24 pm

Re: EOY 2018: Uproxx Music Critics Poll

Post by cheekyjh2 » Thu Jan 10, 2019 8:16 pm

Looks like Pazz & Jop is alive (?)
https://www.guerrillacandy.com/2018/12/ ... op-ballot/
The 2018 Pazz & Jop is a bit unique compared to years past since the Village Voice ceased publication in 2018. There was speculation that Pazz & Jop would end, but apparently that didn’t happen because I received a ballot in my inbox yesterday.

Like in past years I am sharing my ballot.

Post Reply