AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Mon Jul 27, 2020 2:44 pm

Hello everyone! I'm excited today to start rolling out the results of the 2010s end-of-decade poll! I received lists from 55 different voters mentioning across them a total of more than 2100 different albums.

Acroamor
Andyd1010
ArcadeFire
Arsalan
BleuPanda
Bonnielaurel
Brad
Bruno
Carlos74
Chambord
Chris K.
Cold Butterfly
CupOfDreams
Dan
DaveC
FrankLotion
Future Critic
Gillingham
Henry
Honorio
Jackson
Jirin
Jeff
Listyguy
M24
Maschine_Man
Matski
maverick470
Mileswide
Moonbeam
Myself
Nassim
Nick
Holden
Notbrianeno
Panam
Pepemallent
Phil
PlasticRam
prosecutorgodot
Rob
Rocky Raccoon
Romain
Rumpdoll
Safetycat
Schuttelbirne
SL3
Sonofsamiam
Styrofoam Boots
Toni
VanillaFire1000
votingbloc
Wezzo
Whuntva
Zombeels

I used the same formula Schuttelbirne used for the songs poll, that is: 100*((1+20)/(rank+20).

If you're curious about the placement of our EOY #1s, they're listed here:
2010 | Kanye West | My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
2011 | PJ Harvey | Let England Shake
2012 | Frank Ocean | Channel Orange
2013 | Vampire Weekend | Modern Vampires of the City
2014 | The War on Drugs | Lost in the Dream
2015 | Kendrick Lamar | To Pimp a Butterfly
2016 | David Bowie | ★
2017 | LCD Soundsystem | American Dream
2018 | Janelle Monáe | Dirty Computer
2019 | Weyes Blood | Titanic Rising

Like the songs poll, an album needed >100 points, or more than a number-one vote, in order to get included. That gave us a total rollout of 409 albums. Here are the honorable mentions, the albums with a solitary vote at number one:



Image
410. (tied) Heartless Bastards | Arrow
(100 Points | 1 Vote)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Zombeels (#1)

Image
410. (tied) Twenty One Pilots | Blurryface
(100 Points | 1 Vote)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: 290
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Arsalan (#1)

Image
410. (tied) Within Temptation | The Unforgiving
(100 Points | 1 Vote)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Myself (#1)

(Also, as a fun side detail, the next highest-rated album, just two-thirds of a point away from making the final rollout, was Viet Cong by Preoccupations AKA the Artist Formerly Known as Viet Cong.)
Last edited by acroamor on Tue Jul 28, 2020 12:04 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Mon Jul 27, 2020 3:46 pm

Image
409. Woods | Bend Beyond
(100.3846154 Points | 2 Votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #356
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: CupOfDreams (#15)

Image
408.The Magnetic Fields | 50 Song Memoir
(100.4545991 Points | 5 Votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #651
AMF EOY List: #68
Biggest Fan: Jirin (#48)

Image
407. Gregory Porter | Liquid Spirit
(100.5974253 Points | 4 Votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Bonnielaurel (#27)

Image
406. Spoon | Transference
(100.7444567 Points | 3 Votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #48
Biggest Fan: Brad (#14)

Image
405. Electric Guest | Mondo
(101.5734266 Points | 2 Votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #64
Biggest Fan: Romain (#19)

Image
404. Ty Segall | Manipulator
(101.6809797 Points | 4 Votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #359
AMF EOY List: #43
Biggest Fan: Brad (#23)

Image
403. NoName | Room 25
(101.997201 Points | 5 Votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked:
EOD Critics‘ List: #159
AMF EOY List: #20
Biggest Fan: FrankLotion (#33)

Image
402. Dean Blunt | The Redeemer
(102.1034483 Points | 2 Votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #317
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Jackson (#5)

Image
401. PJ Harvey | The Hope Six Demolition Project
(102.3774291 Points | 5 Votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #937
AMF EOY List: #22
Biggest Fan: DaveC (#57)
Last edited by acroamor on Tue Jul 28, 2020 12:52 am, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Mon Jul 27, 2020 6:02 pm

Image

400. Wild Beasts | Smother
(103.4994093 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #734
AMF EOY List: #37
Biggest Fan: pepemallent (#31)

Image

399. Muse | The 2nd Law
(103.6261682 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #687
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Arsalan (#5)

Image

398. Beck | Morning Phase
(103.6860019 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: "Blue Moon" (#397)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1201
AMF EOY List: #26
Biggest Fan: VanillaFire1000 (#37)

Image

397. Javiera Mena | Mena
(104.1923077 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: "Luz de piedra de luna" (#390)
EOD Critics‘ List: #143
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Moonbeam (#5)

Image

396. Kasabian | Velociraptor!
(104.2681848 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: whuntva (#26)

Image

395. The Pains of Being Pure at Heart | Belong
(104.4262295 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #15
Biggest Fan: votingbloc (#10)

Image

394. Caroline Rose | LONER
(104.5138889 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #84
Biggest Fan: Acroamor (#12)

Image

393. Jeff Rosenstock | POST-
(104.583749 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #619
AMF EOY List: #55
Biggest Fan: panam (#33)

Image

392. James Blake | Assume Form
(104.637894 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #24
Biggest Fan: BleuPanda (#50)

Image

391. Bjork | Biophilia
(104.7006652 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #43
Biggest Fan: Moonbeam (#15)

Image

390. Jenny Hval | The Practice of Love
(105.2414328 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1967
AMF EOY List: #43
Biggest Fan: Jackson (#21)

Image

389. Protomartyr | Relatives in Descent
(105.4944267 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1087
AMF EOY List: #49
Biggest Fan: CupOfDreams (#11)

Image

388. Temples | Sun Structures
(105.5309172 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1698
AMF EOY List: #54
Biggest Fan: Cold Butterfly (#39)

Image

387. Girls | Father, Son, Holy Ghost
(106.1756993 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: "Vomit" (#243)
EOD Critics‘ List: #182
AMF EOY List: #5
Biggest Fan: Brad (#19)

Image

386. Aldous Harding | Party
(106.2068966 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #306
AMF EOY List: #38
Biggest Fan: DaveC (#10)

Image

385. Young Thug | JEFFERY
(106.25 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #97
Biggest Fan: Jeff (#4)

Image

384. Andrew Bird | My Finest Work Yet
(106.4316056 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #75
Biggest Fan: Romain (#11)

Image

383. Mikal Cronin | MCII
(106.6494009 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Carlos74 (#27)

Image

382. Carly Rae Jepsen | Dedicated
(107.081195 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #38
Biggest Fan: Future Critic (#42)

Image

381. Julie Byrne | Not Even Happiness
(107.5334225 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #56
Biggest Fan: Acroamor (#13)
Last edited by acroamor on Tue Jul 28, 2020 12:09 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Arsalan
Wannabe
Posts: 124
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2020 9:18 am

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Arsalan » Mon Jul 27, 2020 6:12 pm

Unfortunately what happened to Linkin Park is now happening to Twenty One Pilots,They are making great records but still being ignored by critics.

User avatar
Rocky Raccoon
Different Class
Posts: 439
Joined: Fri Feb 24, 2012 12:30 am
Location: Seattle area
Contact:

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Rocky Raccoon » Mon Jul 27, 2020 6:57 pm

Glad to see this get rolling, but disappointed by NoName's low placement.

Nick
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2561
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2012 9:28 pm
Location: New York State

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Nick » Mon Jul 27, 2020 7:01 pm

Girls at #387 after placing #5 in their EOY poll hurts to see...

User avatar
Rob
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 3731
Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Rob » Mon Jul 27, 2020 7:26 pm

Only two votes for Aldous Harding's Party? I'd expected more. I wonder if Designer is going to show up.

Otherwise, happy to see 50 Song Memoir, Post- and Not Even Happiness here. I voted for the last two, but 50 Song Memoir was just under the cut-off point, sadly.

I never heard of the Caroline Rose album before, but the cover is amazing.

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Mon Jul 27, 2020 8:57 pm

Image

380. Yeasayer | Odd Blood
(107.8480811 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: "O.N.E." (#392)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #28
Biggest Fan: whuntva (#24)

Image

379. Chuck Person | Chuck Person's Eccojams Vol. 1
(108.0070134 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #246
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Jeff (#9)

Image

378. Bruce Springsteen | Wrecking Ball
(108.0291137 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #724
AMF EOY List: #49
Biggest Fan: Rob (#44)

Image

377. Boards of Canada | Tomorrow's Harvest
(108.231001 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #384
AMF EOY List: #38
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#27)

Image

376. Brand New | Science Fiction
(108.3756273 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #898
AMF EOY List: #24
Biggest Fan: Styrofoam Boots (#34)

Image

375. Denzel Curry | Imperial
(108.5775849 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #44
Biggest Fan: Jeff (#16)

Image

374. Rolling Blackouts Coastal Fever | Hope Downs
(109.4021739 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #19
Biggest Fan: Chambord (#26)

Image

373. Austra | Feel It Break
(110.1425297 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1537
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: DaveC (#17)

Image

372. Hurray for the Riff Raff | The Navigator
(110.930949 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: "Pa'lante" (#356)
EOD Critics‘ List: #677
AMF EOY List: #20
Biggest Fan: Rob (#25)

Image

371. Andy Stott | Passed Me By / We Stay Together
(111.0955056 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #44
Biggest Fan: Sonofsamiam (#20)

Image

370. Swans | The Glowing Man
(112.3959828 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #38
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#21)

Image

369. clipping. | Splendor and Misery
(112.5 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: whuntva (#4)

Image

368. Savages | Silence Yourself
(112.7521132 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #180
AMF EOY List: #23
Biggest Fan: BleuPanda (#49)

Image

367. Cults | Cults
(112.9975784 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #23
Biggest Fan: Phil (#21)

Image

366. El-P | Cancer 4 Cure
(113.3089561 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #20
Biggest Fan: Nassim (#3)

Image

365. Gang of Youths | Go Farther in Lightness
(113.6619784 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #814
AMF EOY List: #81
Biggest Fan: SL3 (#44)

Image

364. CeU | Tropix
(113.928226 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1027
AMF EOY List: #51
Biggest Fan: Toni (#7)

Image

363. Colin Stetson and Sarah Neufeld | Never Were the Way She Was
(114.0819624 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #33
Biggest Fan: Phil (#20)

Image

362. Alabama Shakes | Sound and Color
(114.5972369 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #319
AMF EOY List: #17
Biggest Fan: Acroamor (#6)

Image

361. Nils Frahm | All Melody
(114.6807758 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #34
Biggest Fan: Pepemallent (#33)

Image

360. Wolf Alice | Visions of a Life
(114.700498 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: "Don't Delete the Kisses" (#201)
EOD Critics‘ List: #784
AMF EOY List: #19
Biggest Fan: mileswide (#31)

Image

359. Actress | R.I.P.
(115.4466967 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #505
AMF EOY List: #34
Biggest Fan: Jackson (#7)

Image

358. Jenny Lewis | On the Line
(115.5577475 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1796
AMF EOY List: #37
Biggest Fan: Future Critic (#21)

Image

357. The Tallest Man on Earth | There's No Leaving Now
(115.6143078 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: "1904" (#413)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #31
Biggest Fan: Phil (#34)

Image

356. Alabama Shakes | Boys and Girls
(115.7660423 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: "Hold On" (#134)
EOD Critics‘ List: #346
AMF EOY List: #90
Biggest Fan: Carlos74 (#45)

Image

355. These New Puritans | Hidden
(115.8363934 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1574
AMF EOY List: #54
Biggest Fan: Schuttelbirne (#14)

Image

354. Meta Meta | MetaL MetaL
(115.8416816 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1539
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: panam (#20)

Image

353. Deerhunter | Why Hasn't Everything Already Disappeared?
(115.8461538 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #35
Biggest Fan: Holden (#6)

Image

352. Paramore | After Laughter
(116.5791448 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #351
AMF EOY List: #42
Biggest Fan: prosecutorgodot (#11)

Image

351. Julianna Barwick | Nepenthe
(116.8908581 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Acroamor (#3)
Last edited by acroamor on Tue Jul 28, 2020 12:26 am, edited 2 times in total.

Jackson
Full of Fire
Posts: 1261
Joined: Sun Feb 12, 2012 6:05 am
Location: Los Angeles

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Jackson » Mon Jul 27, 2020 9:58 pm

A few take-aways so far:

- I'm happy to be the top vote for The Redeemer and R.I.P. Those albums sound like nothing else this decade or any other. They're not for everyone, but if you're looking for something adventurous you should give them a try
- I voted for Andy Stott's Passed Me By and We Stay Together as one entry, and I think a few others did as well. How were those votes treated?
- There are quite a few indie albums from earlier in the decade that have faded over time, both with critics and on this list. I'm thinking of Girls, Cults, Wild Beasts, and The Pains of Being Pure at Heart from this section. Lots of these seem like they fit in better with the tastes of the previous decade
- I will never understand why Wolf Alice doesn't have more broad appeal. This is an accessible, ambitious album that is on par or better than many indie albums that will place hundreds of spots higher and it won the Mercury Prize; what is it doing down here (and even lower with the critics)?

Jackson
Full of Fire
Posts: 1261
Joined: Sun Feb 12, 2012 6:05 am
Location: Los Angeles

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Jackson » Mon Jul 27, 2020 9:59 pm

Rob wrote:
Mon Jul 27, 2020 7:26 pm
Only two votes for Aldous Harding's Party? I'd expected more. I wonder if Designer is going to show up.
I'd think so - I voted for Designer but not for Party, and thought that was the consensus pick, though it's always hard to tell given both albums are relatively recent.

panam
Full of Fire
Posts: 1066
Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2016 4:21 am

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by panam » Mon Jul 27, 2020 10:10 pm

Too many albums to check. I hope someone make a playlist.

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Tue Jul 28, 2020 12:26 am

Jackson wrote:
Mon Jul 27, 2020 9:58 pm
A few take-aways so far:

- I voted for Andy Stott's Passed Me By and We Stay Together as one entry, and I think a few others did as well. How were those votes treated?
So for that one, I actually didn't realize that two of the three votes were for the two releases compiled together because I was inputting them all under the results of the first vote, which was just for Passed Me By. I didn't realize this mostly because I've never listened to Andy Stott and wasn't familiar with the release formats at all.

I've run into similar problems with a few other releases getting listed in inconsistent formats - the Caretaker's Everywhere at the end of time, Brockhampton's Saturation trilogy, and Death Grips' double album The Powers That B - where they can be argued as separate parts or as one cohesive whole. In those cases, I've gone with the cohesive whole as the sole list item and collected all the votes for the parts or for the whole as being for the whole. The one exception would be cases where a voter listed multiple parts in the same list. I didn't feel as it would be fair for a voter to, in essence, get multiples votes for the same album. In those cases, I went with whatever the highest ranking of the parts was as applying to the whole. I hope this is a satisfactory compromise.

Nick
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2561
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2012 9:28 pm
Location: New York State

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Nick » Tue Jul 28, 2020 1:08 am

I'm glad you seem to be sticking with the 50 results per day that Schuttelbirne did for the songs rollout. That seemed to be the best compromise between going to fast and going too slow. I'm excited to see the rest!

Jackson
Full of Fire
Posts: 1261
Joined: Sun Feb 12, 2012 6:05 am
Location: Los Angeles

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Jackson » Tue Jul 28, 2020 5:56 am

acroamor wrote:
Tue Jul 28, 2020 12:26 am
Jackson wrote:
Mon Jul 27, 2020 9:58 pm
A few take-aways so far:

- I voted for Andy Stott's Passed Me By and We Stay Together as one entry, and I think a few others did as well. How were those votes treated?
So for that one, I actually didn't realize that two of the three votes were for the two releases compiled together because I was inputting them all under the results of the first vote, which was just for Passed Me By. I didn't realize this mostly because I've never listened to Andy Stott and wasn't familiar with the release formats at all.
The makes sense - I think this was the right approach! I hope this inspires you to introduce yourself to Stott's oeuvre, though I'd start with the 2012 album Luxury Problems (which I assume is higher up on the list) rather than these less accessible EPs.

User avatar
Rob
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 3731
Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Rob » Tue Jul 28, 2020 9:05 am

Jackson wrote:
Mon Jul 27, 2020 9:59 pm
Rob wrote:
Mon Jul 27, 2020 7:26 pm
Only two votes for Aldous Harding's Party? I'd expected more. I wonder if Designer is going to show up.
I'd think so - I voted for Designer but not for Party, and thought that was the consensus pick, though it's always hard to tell given both albums are relatively recent.
In my head Party was the consensus pick, but perhaps that's just my own preference talking. I guess there isn't a real clear favorite among Harding's albums yet. I voted for both, though.

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Tue Jul 28, 2020 2:28 pm

Image

350. Agnes Obel | Aventine
(117.2741567 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1087
AMF EOY List: #35
Biggest Fan: Jirin (#33)

Image

349. Lana Del Rey | Lust for Life
(117.5119314 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: “Love” (#272)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #27
Biggest Fan: Chambord (#39)

Image

348. Arca | Arca
(118.2893153 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #59
AMF EOY List: #46
Biggest Fan: panam (#63)

Image

347. Bleachers | Strange Desire
(118.75 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Wezzo (#8)

Image

346. The Weeknd | Beauty Behind the Madness
(119.4105613 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: “Can’t Feel My Face” (#146)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1137
AMF EOY List: #59
Biggest Fan: PlasticRam (#20)

Image

345. Tim Hecker | Virgins
(119.9042082 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #349
AMF EOY List: #48
Biggest Fan: Bonnielaurel (#65)

Image

344. Cage the Elephant | Thank You, Happy Birthday
(120.2068966 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: whuntva (#5)

Image

343. Run the Jewels | Run the Jewels
(120.2098968 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #411
AMF EOY List: #22
Biggest Fan: Nassim (#21)

Image

342. Bonobo | Black Sands
(120.2596978 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Mileswide (#5)

Image

341. Taylor Swift | Speak Now
(120.3931204 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #546
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Future Critic (#13)

Image

340. Anna Meredith | FIBS
(121.012522 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #26
Biggest Fan: Rob (#17)

Image

339. Lady Lamb | After
(121.7657343 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #2012
AMF EOY List: #67
Biggest Fan: Rob (#19)

Image

338. Holly Herndon | Platform
(122.0334076 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #245
AMF EOY List: #34
Biggest Fan: Rob (#26)

Image

337. Perfume Genius | No Shape
(122.3276272 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: “Slip Away” (#177)
EOD Critics‘ List: #146
AMF EOY List: #22
Biggest Fan: FrankLotion (#84)

Image

336. The Afghan Whigs | Do to the Beast
(122.398182 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #18
Biggest Fan: Myself (#7)

Image

335. Thee Silver Mt. Zion Memorial Orchestra | Fuck Off Get Free We Pour Light on Everything
(122.4165098 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #23
Biggest Fan: Brad (#2)

Image

334. Charli XCX | Pop 2
(122.6124477 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #86
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Jackson (#29)

Image

333. Solange | When I Get Home
(122.7898585 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #301
AMF EOY List: #23
Biggest Fan: Cold Butterfly (#43)

Image

332. Original Broadway Cast | Hamilton
(122.9076434 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #164
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Maverick470 (#23)

Image

331. Fontaines D.C. | Dogrel
(123.4030934 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #295
AMF EOY List: #18
Biggest Fan: Schuttelbirne (#43)

User avatar
Rob
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 3731
Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Rob » Tue Jul 28, 2020 2:49 pm

Funny coincidence that I am the biggest fan on three consecutive albums here: #338, #339 & #340. All severely underrated of course, although Fibs is the only one I expected to do better.

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Tue Jul 28, 2020 4:19 pm

Image

330. Father John Misty | God's Favorite Customer
(123.5591806 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1940
AMF EOY List: #31
Biggest Fan: andyd1010 (#29)

Image

329. Chromeo | Business Casual
(123.75 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #77
Biggest Fan: Moonbeam (#10)

Image

328. Grouper | Ruins
(124.0629751 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #95
AMF EOY List: #30
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#24)

Image

327. Japanese Breakfast | Soft Sounds from Another Planet
(124.5552826 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #638
AMF EOY List: #45
Biggest Fan: VanillaFire1000 (#13)

Image

326. FKA Twigs | M3LL155X EP
(125.4848967 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #38
Biggest Fan: FrankLotion (#35)

Image

325. St. Vincent and David Byrne | Love This Giant
(125.7842577 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Safetycat (#33)

Image

324. Alt-J | This Is All Yours
(125.7983709 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #28
Biggest Fan: Romain (#17)

Image

323. Lady Gaga | Born This Way
(126.9034326 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “The Edge of Glory” (#274)
EOD Critics‘ List: #138
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Henry (#32)

Image

322. Prince | Originals
(128.0352858 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked:
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Moonbeam (#6) [color me shocked!]

Image

321. Christine and the Queens | Chris
(128.8741259 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #773
AMF EOY List: #32
Biggest Fan: Moonbeam (#46)

Image

320. Kendrick Lamar | untitled unmastered
(128.968254 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #23
Biggest Fan: Cold Butterfly (#8)

Image

319. Brian Fallon | Painkillers
(129.6064401 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Wezzo (#6)

Image

318. Foals | Holy Fire
(130.0822085 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “Inhaler” (#305)
EOD Critics‘ List: #360
AMF EOY List: #40
Biggest Fan: Arsalan (#13)

Image

317. The Gaslight Anthem | American Slang
(130.6666667 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1862
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Wezzo (#5)

Image

316. Ali Farka Toure and Toumani Diabete | Ali and Toumani
(130.7929079 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #60
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#30)

Image

315. Mid-Air Thief | Crumbling
(131.3760348 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Styrofoam Boots (#37)

Image

314. Belle and Sebastian | Write About Love
(131.4367884 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: “I Want the World to Stop” (#378)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #56
Biggest Fan: Chambord (#11)

Image

313. Leon Bridges | Coming Home
(131.5612404 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1745
AMF EOY List: #53
Biggest Fan: Bonnielaurel (#17)

Image

312. Goat | World Music
(131.8217525 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1573
AMF EOY List: #58
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#13)

Image

311. Ty Segall | Freedom's Goblin
(132.911557 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #47
Biggest Fan: Rob (#7)

Image

310. Unsuk Chin | 3 Concertos
(133.7311076 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Sonofsamiam (#6)

Image

309. Colin Stetson | Sorrow - A Reimagining of Gorecki's 3rd Symphony
(134.1897233 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #55
Biggest Fan: Rob (#13)

Image

308. Jai Paul | Leak 04-13 (Bait Ones)
(134.2836453 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: “Jasmine” (#293)
EOD Critics‘ List: #315
AMF EOY List: #36
Biggest Fan: Moonbeam (#14)

Image

307. Kelly Lee Owens | Kelly Lee Owens
(134.3194274 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1553
AMF EOY List: #21
Biggest Fan: Jackson (#17)

Image

306. Damon Albarn | Everyday Robots
(134.929085 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #309
AMF EOY List: #24
Biggest Fan: Rumpdoll AND Pepemallent (#45)

Image

305. The Kills | Blood Pressures
(135.8391608 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Romain (#2)

Image

304. Parquet Courts | Human Performance
(136.1825154 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #408
AMF EOY List: #33
Biggest Fan: Styrofoam Boots (#47)

Image

303. Death Grips | Exmilitary
(136.8255728 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Beware” (#383)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1087
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: prosecutorgodot (#16)

Image

302. Snail Mail | Lush
(137.4878521 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked:
EOD Critics‘ List: #174
AMF EOY List: #23
Biggest Fan: VanillaFire1000 (#12)

Image

301. Sampha |Process
(137.8008756 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: “(No One Knows Me) Like the Piano” (#209) and “Blood on Me” (#331)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1550
AMF EOY List: #13
Biggest Fan: Bruno (#23)

panam
Full of Fire
Posts: 1066
Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2016 4:21 am

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by panam » Tue Jul 28, 2020 4:32 pm

The variety on this list is impressive. Also is surprising to find many albums forgotten by the EOD Critics‘ List and
AMF EOY Lists.

User avatar
Rob
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 3731
Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Rob » Tue Jul 28, 2020 9:40 pm

panam wrote:
Tue Jul 28, 2020 4:32 pm
The variety on this list is impressive. Also is surprising to find many albums forgotten by the EOD Critics‘ List and
AMF EOY Lists.
I was about to say the exact same thing. This list is one damn thing after another and there is no telling what will be next. By the time we get to the top 100 things will no doubt get more predictable, but that's why I always tend to like the bottom half of lists more.

The biggest surprise is that Colin Stetson's Sorrow actually made the cut. I thought I would be the only one who would vote for it! By coincidence, I also listened to it today. It was also good to see Ty Segall's Freedom's Goblin make it. I expected it, but it was not a given.

User avatar
Romain
Leader of the Pack
Posts: 4593
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 2:25 pm
Location: Lyon, France

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Romain » Wed Jul 29, 2020 5:59 am

Rob wrote:
Tue Jul 28, 2020 9:40 pm

The biggest surprise is that Colin Stetson's Sorrow actually made the cut. I thought I would be the only one who would vote for it! By coincidence, I also listened to it today. It was also good to see Ty Segall's Freedom's Goblin make it. I expected it, but it was not a given.
Both album are great... that's the reason :-)

For Ty Segall I tend to say that he's the best American artist of this decade...and this album is great. He deserves to be here.

And for the variety of the records, I agree, it's very nice to discover a lot of them and the next few weeks will be full of discoveries for me.

The biggest surprise is "Unsuk Chin | 3 Concertos" for me. With the huge number of works by classical artists, how three people came to vote for this particular record surprises me enormously.

Was there a show about this artist, a spotlight in a film or something like that?

I'm glad in any case that contemporary classical music doesn't turn everyone off :-)

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Wed Jul 29, 2020 1:20 pm

Image

300. Gurrumul | Djarimirri
(137.8255528 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #58
Biggest Fan: Sonofsamiam (#13)

Image

299. Kurt Vile | Wakin on a Pretty Daze
(137.9969153 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “Wakin on a Pretty Day” (#214)
EOD Critics‘ List: #239
AMF EOY List: #28
Biggest Fan: Listyguy (#35)

Image

298. Anna Calvi | Anna Calvi
(138.4210526 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #2162
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Romain (#10)

Image

297. Thundercat | Drunk
(139.5141392 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #235
AMF EOY List: #34
Biggest Fan: Panam (#8)

Image

296. Natalia Lafourcade | Musas Vol. 1
(140.615797 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: “Tu Si Sabes Quererme” (#300)
EOD Critics‘ List: #668
AMF EOY List: #36
Biggest Fan: Bonnielaurel (#14)

Image

295. Swans | My Father Will Guide Me a Rope to the Sky
(140.9567791 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #19
Biggest Fan: Jackson (#10)

Image

294. Jason Isbell | Southeastern
(141.8745821 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “Elephant” (#343)
EOD Critics‘ List: #256
AMF EOY List: #35
Biggest Fan: maverick470 (#43)

Image

293. American Football | American Football (LP3)
(143.7068966 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #44
Biggest Fan: Styrofoam Boots (#10)

Image

292. Spoon | They Want My Soul
(144.7091001 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “Do You” (#219)
EOD Critics‘ List: #374
AMF EOY List: #12
Biggest Fan: andyd1010 (#21)

Image

291. Ariel Pink | Before Today
(145.6102672 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: “Round and Round” (#110)
EOD Critics‘ List: #274
AMF EOY List: #14
Biggest Fan: CupOfDreams (#45)

Image

290. Bat for Lashes | The Haunted Man
(148.6222809 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Laura” (#166)
EOD Critics‘ List: #914
AMF EOY List: #37
Biggest Fan: Chambord (#15)

Image

289. Africa Express | …Presents In C Mali
(148.8304094 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: PlasticRam (#7)

Image

288. Frank Ocean | nostalgia, ultra
(149.668456 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Novacane” (#237)
EOD Critics‘ List: #292
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Nassim (#12)

Image

287. The Strokes | Angles
(149.9827586 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Under Cover of Darkness” (#286)
EOD Critics‘ List: #639
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Chambord (#10)

Image

286. Anna Meredith | Varmints
(150.2894798 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #36
Biggest Fan: Sonofsamiam (#23)

Image

285. Cardi B | Invasion of Privacy
(150.47515 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “Bodak Yellow” (#216) and “I Like It (ft. Bad Bunny)” (#427)
EOD Critics‘ List: #58
AMF EOY List: #53
Biggest Fan: Holden (#20)

Image

284. La Femme | Psycho Tropical Berlin
(152.4394079 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #169
AMF EOY List: #32
Biggest Fan: Nassim (#9)

Image

283. Childish Gambino | "Awaken, My Love!"
(153.2748049 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: “Redbone” (#180)
EOD Critics‘ List: #262
AMF EOY List: #39
Biggest Fan: Toni (#15)

Image

282. Coldplay | Mylo Xyloto
(153.7033174 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Paradise” (#433)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Arsalan (#7)

Image

281. Charli XCX | Sucker
(153.8046672 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Bonnielaurel (#9)
Last edited by acroamor on Wed Jul 29, 2020 6:29 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Wed Jul 29, 2020 1:47 pm

Image

280. Matana Roberts | Coin Coin Chapter Three: River Run Thee
(155.5555556 points | 2 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #563
AMF EOY List: #37
Biggest Fan: Jeff AND Sonofsamiam (#7) [our highest ranking album with just two votes!]

Image

279. MGMT | Little Dark Age
(156.4541356 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1013
AMF EOY List: #33
Biggest Fan: Styrofoam Boots (#2)

Image

278. Lucy Dacus | Historian
(156.7883734 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “Night Shift” (#239)
EOD Critics‘ List: #483
AMF EOY List: #16
Biggest Fan: SL3 (#20)

Image

277. Charli XCX | Charli
(157.1937762 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #42
AMF EOY List: #42
Biggest Fan: PlasticRam (#14)

Image

276. Tame Impala | Innerspeaker
(157.8286361 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: “Solitude Is Bliss” (#387)
EOD Critics‘ List: #259
AMF EOY List: #48
Biggest Fan: CupOfDreams (#27)

Image

275. Drive-By Truckers | American Band
(158.1537616 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: “What It Means” (#310)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #26
Biggest Fan: Rocky Raccoon (#8)

Image

274. Future Islands | Singles
(159.1311411 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “Seasons (Waiting on You)” (#20)
EOD Critics‘ List: #373
AMF EOY List: #22
Biggest Fan: Pepemallent (#14)

Image

273. Rosalia | Los Angeles
(159.3295455 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #968
AMF EOY List: #69
Biggest Fan: Panam (#2)

Image

272. Kate Tempest | Everybody Down
(160.5366726 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “The Beigeness” (#329)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1018
AMF EOY List: #72
Biggest Fans: Machine_Man (#6), Mileswide (#10)

Image

271. Courtney Barnett | Tell Me How You Really Feel
(161.5442148 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1733
AMF EOY List: #24
Biggest Fan: SL3 (#35)

Image

270. Childish Gambino | Camp
(162.0364346 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Wezzo (#9)

Image

269. First Aid Kit | Ruins
(162.6926973 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “Fireworks” (#254)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #36
Biggest Fan: Bonnielaurel (#3)

Image

268. Low | C'mon
(163.0057367 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: "Nothing But Heart" (#197), “Especially Me” (#346)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: DaveC (#3)

Image

267. Jlin | Black Origami
(163.1087581 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #162
AMF EOY List: #41
Biggest Fan: Jeff (#5)

Image

266. Sky Ferreira | Night Time, My Time
(163.3169908 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “I Blame Myself” (#280)
EOD Critics‘ List: #80
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Holden (#36)

Image

265. Kanye West and Kid Cudi | Kids See Ghosts
(164.1240575 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #243
AMF EOY List: #29
Biggest Fan: Prosecutorgodot (#21)

Image

264. Metronomy | The English Riviera
(165.5113292 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #223
AMF EOY List: #41
Biggest Fan: Romain (#16)

Image

263. Jane Weaver | Modern Kosmology
(166.0469988 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #32
Biggest Fan: Jackson (#22)

Image

262. Black Midi | Schlangenheim
(166.5379888 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1473
AMF EOY List: #21
Biggest Fan: Chambord (#23)

Image

261. Spiritualized | Sweet Heart Sweet Light
(166.7986205 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Hey Jane” (#384)
EOD Critics‘ List: #824
AMF EOY List: #26
Biggest Fan: Carlos74 (#58)

Image

260. Big Thief | Capacity
(168.260717 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: “Shark Smile” (#263)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1967
AMF EOY List: #28
Biggest Fan: Toni (#8)

Image

259. Tyler, the Creator | IGOR
(169.9693765 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #117
AMF EOY List: #14
Biggest Fan: ArcadeFire (#23)

Image

258. Jon Hopkins | Singularity
(170.4052968 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #378
AMF EOY List: #27
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#35)

Image

257. The Black Keys | Turn Blue
(170.4203119 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “The Weight of Love” (#437)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #27
Biggest Fan: Arsalan (#9)

Image

256. Deafheaven | Ordinary Corrupt Human Love
(172.0881618 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #25
Biggest Fan: Brad (#11)

Image

255. Blanck Mass | World Eater
(173.5334803 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #37
Biggest Fan: Nassim (#17)

Image

254. Kanye West | The Life of Pablo
(174.1924369 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: “Ultralight Beam” (#50)
EOD Critics‘ List: #339
AMF EOY List: #16
Biggest Fan: Cold Butterfly (#32)

Image

253. Andy Stott | Faith in Strangers
(174.4472235 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “Faith in Strangers” (#417)
EOD Critics‘ List: #583
AMF EOY List: #19
Biggest Fan: Jackson (#19)

Image

252. Wilco | The Whole Love
(174.7974827 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #2007
AMF EOY List: #29
Biggest Fan: pepemallent (#42)

Image

251. Beach House | Depression Cherry
(175.743892 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: “Space Song” (#317)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #12
Biggest Fan: Styrofoam Boots (#21)
Last edited by acroamor on Wed Jul 29, 2020 3:41 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Rob
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 3731
Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Rob » Wed Jul 29, 2020 2:00 pm

The image for Psycho Tropical Berlin does not contain a clickable link (a great feature otherwise).

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Wed Jul 29, 2020 2:07 pm

Rob wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 2:00 pm
The image for Psycho Tropical Berlin does not contain a clickable link (a great feature otherwise).
So fun little story about that:

I've been using RYM for all of the images/clickthrough links, and generally it's been very useful. With this last set, there were three albums (Psycho Tropical Berlin, The Haunted Man, and Charli) that wouldn't allow their photos to be used for that, so I just used the Wikipedia photos instead. I thought it might have something to do with the hints of nudity, but the Sky Ferreira cover has probably the most overt nudity of any of them and it's fine.

Now, in the process of rapidly clicking through RYM to get these for the 162 albums so far, the RYM firewall automatically flagged me as a bot and banned my IP address from the site. I appealed it and explained the situation, but still haven't heard back from them. When they do lift the ban, I should be able to get back on track, but there's a slight chance it may disrupt tomorrow's rollout.

Gillingham
Full of Fire
Posts: 1048
Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2012 8:33 pm
Location: The Hague, The Netherlands

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Gillingham » Wed Jul 29, 2020 3:21 pm

268. Low | C'mon
(163.0057367 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Especially Me” (#346)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: DaveC (#3)
Nothing But Heart from that album also ranked, higher than Especially Me actually.

Would have expected more than just 3 votes for this album.

User avatar
Holden
Full of Fire
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 11:06 pm

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Holden » Wed Jul 29, 2020 3:41 pm

Surprised to see The Life of Pablo so low. Maybe the Kanye love doesn’t extend to albums as much as songs... (here’s hoping that Yeezus doesn’t end up in the top 10)
"The better a singer's voice, the harder it is to believe what they're saying."

User avatar
Sweepstakes Ron
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2246
Joined: Sat May 18, 2013 3:32 pm
Location: Here, There, and Everywhere

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Sweepstakes Ron » Wed Jul 29, 2020 4:00 pm

Holden wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 3:41 pm
Surprised to see The Life of Pablo so low. Maybe the Kanye love doesn’t extend to albums as much as songs... (here’s hoping that Yeezus doesn’t end up in the top 10)
It'd probably get a boost had I voted. So with that in mind, there's a chance Pablo will place well in the all-time poll.
Splish splash, I was raking in the cash

User avatar
Holden
Full of Fire
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 11:06 pm

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Holden » Wed Jul 29, 2020 4:05 pm

Sweepstakes Ron wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 4:00 pm
Holden wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 3:41 pm
Surprised to see The Life of Pablo so low. Maybe the Kanye love doesn’t extend to albums as much as songs... (here’s hoping that Yeezus doesn’t end up in the top 10)
It'd probably get a boost had I voted. So with that in mind, there's a chance Pablo will place well in the all-time poll.
In the context of an all-time poll, it is really interesting to think about. In a theoretical top 1000, it wouldn't warrant a position with its current position in this EOD list, yet I am positive it will be in the Top 1000 for the All-time list. Note: yes I am doing that poll, and I don't have that list in front of me right now so this is not a literal guarantee, just something I'm sure of.

I've never actually listened to it, so I can't judge its merits. (And it's not super high on my list of priorities either, I've somewhat tired of Kanye). One thing that I did always think was very interesting was its cover, though. I think it is a really fascinating set of images that bring to together Kanye's persona really well. How high on a theoretical decade list would you have placed it?
Last edited by Holden on Wed Jul 29, 2020 4:57 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"The better a singer's voice, the harder it is to believe what they're saying."

Jackson
Full of Fire
Posts: 1261
Joined: Sun Feb 12, 2012 6:05 am
Location: Los Angeles

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Jackson » Wed Jul 29, 2020 4:52 pm

Among Charli XCX albums, Charli and Sucker (!!) finishing ahead of Pop 2 is very surprising to me. I thought the critics' greater appreciation for Pop 2 in the EOD lists would have sent it higher.

Some significant, but not altogether surprising, drops from initial EOY placement by Spoon, Ariel Pink, Tyler, and Kanye.

I was happy to see Modern Kosmology, My Father Will Guide Me Up a Rope to the Sky, and Faith in Strangers in that last section!

Jlin's Black Origami is probably the weirdest album that will be in our top 300. I wonder if Dark Energy, which I greatly prefer, is still to come.

User avatar
Holden
Full of Fire
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 11:06 pm

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Holden » Wed Jul 29, 2020 4:58 pm

I've been the biggest fan three times so far and while I expected Deerhunter to place rather low (but unranked on Critics' lists? Come on!), a bit sad Cardi B and Sky Ferriera didn't get top 250.
"The better a singer's voice, the harder it is to believe what they're saying."

User avatar
Sweepstakes Ron
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2246
Joined: Sat May 18, 2013 3:32 pm
Location: Here, There, and Everywhere

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Sweepstakes Ron » Wed Jul 29, 2020 5:22 pm

Holden wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 4:05 pm
How high on a theoretical decade list would you have placed it?
Spoiler alert: #14
Splish splash, I was raking in the cash

User avatar
PlasticRam
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 2202
Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2013 12:51 am

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by PlasticRam » Wed Jul 29, 2020 6:47 pm

Holden wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 4:05 pm
I've never actually listened to it, so I can't judge its merits. (And it's not super high on my list of priorities either, I've somewhat tired of Kanye). One thing that I did always think was very interesting was its cover, though. I think it is a really fascinating set of images that bring to together Kanye's persona really well. How high on a theoretical decade list would you have placed it?
You've never listened to TLOP? I recommend. It placed high on P4K readers poll so the public likes it a fair amount.
I feel like that

User avatar
notbrianeno
Rust Never Sleeps
Posts: 913
Joined: Fri Sep 12, 2014 4:47 am

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by notbrianeno » Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:42 pm

I wonder if 7 made the list?? I know in many fan circles Depression Cherry is preferred but 7 gained more critical acclaim...
Current AOTY 2020: Sufjan Stevens | The Ascension
Current SOTY 2020: Tame Impala | "On Track"

User avatar
Holden
Full of Fire
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 11:06 pm

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Holden » Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:47 pm

notbrianeno wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:42 pm
I wonder if 7 made the list?? I know in many fan circles Depression Cherry is preferred but 7 gained more critical acclaim...
I had 7 at #15 so I don’t see how it couldn’t make the list unless very very few others had it. I bet I’m it’s biggest fan though, so who knows.
"The better a singer's voice, the harder it is to believe what they're saying."

User avatar
notbrianeno
Rust Never Sleeps
Posts: 913
Joined: Fri Sep 12, 2014 4:47 am

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by notbrianeno » Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:49 pm

Holden wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:47 pm
notbrianeno wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:42 pm
I wonder if 7 made the list?? I know in many fan circles Depression Cherry is preferred but 7 gained more critical acclaim...
I had 7 at #15 so I don’t see how it couldn’t make the list unless very very few others had it. I bet I’m it’s biggest fan though, so who knows.
I Had it about the same! Beach Heads unite <3
Current AOTY 2020: Sufjan Stevens | The Ascension
Current SOTY 2020: Tame Impala | "On Track"

User avatar
Holden
Full of Fire
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 11:06 pm

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Holden » Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:51 pm

notbrianeno wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:49 pm
Holden wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:47 pm
notbrianeno wrote:
Wed Jul 29, 2020 7:42 pm
I wonder if 7 made the list?? I know in many fan circles Depression Cherry is preferred but 7 gained more critical acclaim...
I had 7 at #15 so I don’t see how it couldn’t make the list unless very very few others had it. I bet I’m it’s biggest fan though, so who knows.
I Had it about the same! Beach Heads unite <3
Really a standout band from this decade that doesn’t get discussed enough. In my mind, two perfect albums (Teen Dream and 7) and Bloom is pretty amazing as well. I hope Teen Dream gets top 15, but I feel like higher is wishful thinking.
"The better a singer's voice, the harder it is to believe what they're saying."

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Thu Jul 30, 2020 3:17 pm

Image

250. The 1975 | A Brief Inquiry into Online Relationships
(176.3171309 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “Love It If We Made It” (#108)
EOD Critics‘ List: #200
AMF EOY List: #35
Biggest Fan: Henry (#7)

Image

249. Natalia Lafourcade | Musas Vol. 2
(177.7184898 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #447
AMF EOY List: #48
Biggest Fan: panam (#1)

Image

248. CHVRCHES | Every Open Eye
(178.3578057 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: “Leave a Trace” (#342)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #21
Biggest Fan: Votingbloc (#8)

Image

247. Anna Von Hausswolf | Dead Magic
(179.1150897 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “The Mysterious Vanishing of Electra” (#375)
EOD Critics‘ List: #667
AMF EOY List: #26
Biggest Fan: Myself (#8)

Image

246. Rihanna | Anti
(180.0315955 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: “Work” (#367)
EOD Critics‘ List: #30
AMF EOY List: #30
Biggest Fan: Carlos74 (#46)

Image

245. James Blake | Overgrown
(180.5391716 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “Retrograde” (#67)
EOD Critics‘ List: #183
AMF EOY List: #25
Biggest Fan: Phil (#27)

Image

244. Freddie Gibbs and Madlib | Pinata
(181.3487876 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #172
AMF EOY List: #25
Biggest Fan: Cold Butterfly (#12)

Image

243. Jay-Z and Kanye West | Watch the Throne
(182.1937089 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Niggas in Paris” (#47)
EOD Critics‘ List: #134
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: PlasticRam (#12)

Image

242. Grouper | A I A: Alien Observer
(183.0102784 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #238
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Jeff (#11)

Image

241. Real Estate | Days
(184.8107615 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #478
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: VanillaFire1000 (#1)

Image

240. Mac DeMarco | Salad Days
(184.9094768 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “Chamber of Reflection” (#337), “Passing Out Pieces” (#359)
EOD Critics‘ List: #155
AMF EOY List: #21
Biggest Fan: PlasticRam (#10)

Image

239. Titus Andronicus | The Monitor
(185.5733043 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: “A More Perfect Union” (#377)
EOD Critics‘ List: #111
AMF EOY List: #15
Biggest Fan: Acroamor (#7)

Image

238. Colin Stetson | New History Warfare, Volume 2: Judges
(185.8231707 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #397
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Jirin (#4)

Image

237. Adele | 25
(186.844887 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: “Hello” (#233)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1852
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Future Critic (#22)

Image

236. Ariel Pink | Pom Pom
(187.5531832 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #213
AMF EOY List: #37
Biggest Fan: Jeff (#17)

Image

235. Foxygen | We Are the 21st Century Ambassadors of Peace and Magic
(187.6458395 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “San Francisco” (#235)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1087
AMF EOY List: #15
Biggest Fan: Zombeels (#33)

Image

234. Arctic Monkeys | Tranquility Base Hotel and Casino
(188.7876263 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #392
AMF EOY List: #15
Biggest Fan: Maschine_Man (#21)

Image

233. Lana Del Rey | Honeymoon
(189.3472237 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #46
Biggest Fan: Brad (#33)

Image

232. Jenny Wilson | Exorcism
(189.3962848 points | 3 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “FOREVER IS A LONG TIME” (#252)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #56
Biggest Fan: Moonbeam (#1)

Image

231. Chelsea Wolfe | Abyss
(189.481352 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #553
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: CupOfDreams (#6)

User avatar
Holden
Full of Fire
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 11:06 pm

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Holden » Thu Jul 30, 2020 3:23 pm

I knew there was no way 1975 got into the Top 100!
"The better a singer's voice, the harder it is to believe what they're saying."

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Thu Jul 30, 2020 4:06 pm

Image

230. A.A.L. (Against All Logic) | 2012-2017
(191.170408 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #779
AMF EOY List: #22
Biggest Fan: Styrofoam Boots (#18)

Image

229. Sigur Ros | Kveikur
(192.81027 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “Brennistein” (#321)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #19
Biggest Fan: DaveC (#22)

Image

228. Kali Uchis | Isolation
(193.4010532 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #477
AMF EOY List: #21
Biggest Fan: Cold Butterfly (#13)

Image

227. Lizzo | Cuz I Love You
(194.7676085 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: “Juice” (#176), “Cuz I Love You” (#391)
EOD Critics‘ List: #272
AMF EOY List: #17
Biggest Fan: Maverick470 (#32)

Image

226. Blur | The Magic Whip
(195.1800474 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #2137
AMF EOY List: #13
Biggest Fan: Brad (#16)

Image

225. Owen Pallett | Heartland
(195.6044214 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #22
Biggest Fan: Pepemallent (#2)

Image

224. DJ Rashad | Double Cup
(195.6869031 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #73
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Jeff (#12)

Image

223. Dirty Projectors | Swing Lo Magellan
(196.7458896 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Gun Has No Trigger” (#341)
EOD Critics‘ List: #406
AMF EOY List: #14
Biggest Fan: Phil (#22)

Image

222. Andy Stott | Luxury Problems
(197.1763578 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #241
AMF EOY List: #18
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#7)

Image

221. Jon Hopkins | Immunity
(197.6927279 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #122
AMF EOY List: #21
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#8)

Image

220. Taylor Swift | Red
(198.3070228 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “All Too Well” (#119)
EOD Critics‘ List: #87
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: maverick470 (#6)

Image

219. Anderson .Paak | Malibu
(199.7327604 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: “Come Down” (#396)
EOD Critics‘ List: #77
AMF EOY List: #18
Biggest Fan: Mileswide (#23)

Image

218. Cloud Nothings | Attack on Memory
(201.6877197 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Wasted Days” (#291)
EOD Critics‘ List: #417
AMF EOY List: #28
Biggest Fan: Nassim (#7)

Image

217. Of Monsters and Men | My Head Is an Animal
(202.6506917 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Little Talks” (#161)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1201
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Votingbloc (#4)

Image

216. Jessie Ware | Devotion
(203.6575534 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Wildest Moments” (#259), “Running” (#408)
EOD Critics‘ List: #277
AMF EOY List: #25
Biggest Fan: DaveC (#46)

Image

215. Ariana Grande | thank u, next
(205.3722315 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: “thank u, next” (#120)
EOD Critics‘ List: #133
AMF EOY List: #30
Biggest Fan: Future Critic (#18)

Image

214. Hot Chip | One Life Stand
(205.3951664 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #28
Biggest Fan: Safetycat (#17)

Image

213. Fever Ray | Plunge
(205.4942273 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #120
AMF EOY List: #17
Biggest Fan: BleuPanda (#25)

Image

212. Oneohtrix Point Never | Replica
(205.5130918 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #70
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Matski (#41)

Image

211. Foo Fighters | Wasting Light
(205.8224414 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #131
AMF EOY List: #32
Biggest Fan: Arsalan (#18)

Image

210. Jack White | Blunderbuss
(205.9913497 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #525
AMF EOY List: #16
Biggest Fan: Rocky Raccoon (#25)

Image

209. Holly Herndon | PROTO
(208.6079594 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1600
AMF EOY List: #32
Biggest Fan: Jeff (#6)

Image

208. Foals | Total Life Forever
(208.8810096 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: “Spanish Sahara” (#185), “Blue Blood” (#323)
EOD Critics‘ List: #161
AMF EOY List: #77
Biggest Fan: Mileswide (#24)

Image

207. Pepe Deluxe | Queen of the Wave
(209.686772 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #56
Biggest Fans: Phil (#5), Zombeels (#6)

Image

206. Matana Roberts | Coin Coin Chapter One: Gens de couleur libres
(210.2797849 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #387
AMF EOY List: #26
Biggest Fan: Schuttelbirne (#2)

Image

205. Vince Staples | Summertime '06
(210.8300163 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #71
AMF EOY List: #22
Biggest Fan: Nassim (#24)

Image

204. Vince Staples | Big Fish Theory
(211.7890376 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #305
AMF EOY List: #25
Biggest Fan: Nassim (#20)

Image

203. The Caretaker | An empty bliss beyond this world
(211.9047207 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #125
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Acroamor (#15)

Image

202. Killer Mike | R.A.P. Music
(212.2347618 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Reagan” (#436)
EOD Critics‘ List: #409
AMF EOY List: #11
Biggest Fan: Rumpdoll (#10)

Image

201. First Aid Kit | Stay Gold
(214.1276493 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “My Silver Lining” (#144)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1201
AMF EOY List: #33
Biggest Fan: Jirin (#23)
Last edited by acroamor on Thu Jul 30, 2020 4:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
prosecutorgodot
Full of Fire
Posts: 1145
Joined: Tue Apr 14, 2015 5:53 am
Location: SF Bay Area, California

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by prosecutorgodot » Thu Jul 30, 2020 4:23 pm

What a coincidence - the Vince Staples albums are right next to each other.
Good showing for R.A.P. Music!
FYI - "no tears left to cry" appears on Sweetener, Ariana's 2018 album. It's not on thank u, next.

Nassim
Into the Groove
Posts: 1988
Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 2:35 pm
Location: Paris

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Nassim » Thu Jul 30, 2020 6:14 pm

That section hurts ! I had better hope for Luxury Problems, Immunity, Plunge and Attack in Memory but the coup de grâce is seeing those 2 Vince Staples albums so low! Summertime 06 is arguably the best non Kanye or Kendrick rap album of the decade, it's been my biggest grower in the past 5 years. And Big Fish Theory brillantly takes rap to new sound I would never have expected to not come from the UK

User avatar
Holden
Full of Fire
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 11:06 pm

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Holden » Thu Jul 30, 2020 7:22 pm

Big Fish Theory did better than I expected! Listened and appreciated it too late for it to make my list, which is unfortunate. Sad Replica didn’t do better.
"The better a singer's voice, the harder it is to believe what they're saying."

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Fri Jul 31, 2020 2:16 pm

Image

200. Aldous Harding | Designer
(215.9701413 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: “The Barrel” (#267)
EOD Critics‘ List: #674
AMF EOY List: #16
Biggest Fan: Brad (#27)

Image

199. John Talabot | FIN
(217.832414 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #257
AMF EOY List: #24
Biggest Fan: Myself (#10)

Image

198. Tyler, the Creator | Scum Fuck Flower Boy
(220.1166781 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #113
AMF EOY List: #16
Biggest Fan: Bruno (#8)

Image

197. Burial | Rival Dealer
(222.7074762 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “Come Down to Us” (#194)
EOD Critics‘ List: #184
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Mileswide (#29)

Image

196. Fucked Up | David Comes to Life
(222.9443268 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Queen of Hearts (#203)
EOD Critics‘ List: #192
AMF EOY List: #12
Biggest Fan: Jackson (#3)

Image

195. Hot Chip | In Our Heads
(223.9144492 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Flutes” (#287)
EOD Critics‘ List: #866
AMF EOY List: #53
Biggest Fan: Safetycat (#2)

Image

194. Aphex Twin | Syro
(224.0512408 points | 11 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #210
AMF EOY List: #13
Biggest Fan: FrankLotion (#29)

Image

193. Chance the Rapper | Coloring Book
(224.3546822 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #152
AMF EOY List: #19
Biggest Fan: M24 (#37)

Image

192. King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard | Nonagon Infinity
(225.2112556 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #116
AMF EOY List: #41
Biggest Fan: Whuntva (#17)

Image

191. Noname | Telefone
(225.7372499 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #357
AMF EOY List: #69
Biggest Fan: Notbrianeno (#13)

Image

190. Better Oblivion Community Center | Better Oblivion Community Center
(226.1363636 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #22
Biggest Fan: Mileswide (#8), Acroamor (#10)

Image

189. Alt-J | An Awesome Wave
(226.4517548 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Breezeblocks (#159)
EOD Critics‘ List: #64
AMF EOY List: #19
Biggest Fan: maverick470 (#25)

Image

188. Parquet Courts | Light Up Gold
(228.6659342 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Stoned and Starving” (#178
EOD Critics‘ List: #130
AMF EOY List: #26
Biggest Fan: CupOfDreams (#10)

Image

187. Phoebe Bridgers | Stranger in the Alps
(229.5330928 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #141
AMF EOY List: #60
Biggest Fan: Rob (#3), Acroamor (#4)

Image

186. The Comet Is Coming | Trust in the Lifeforce of the Deep Mystery
(233.5251568 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #1087
AMF EOY List: #19
Biggest Fan: Holden (#34)

Image

185. Florence + the Machine | How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful
(235.3618405 points | 4 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #736
AMF EOY List: #44
Biggest Fan: Maschine_Man (#2)

Image

184. Caribou | Our Love
(235.6559128 points | 96 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “Can’t Do Without You” (#111)
EOD Critics‘ List: #132
AMF EOY List: #14
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#11)

Image

183. Algiers | The Underside of Power
(237.2118344 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #275
AMF EOY List: #15
Biggest Fan: Rumpdoll (#11)

Image

182. Laura Marling | Semper Femina
(238.4545735 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #726
AMF EOY List: #10
Biggest Fan: Bonnielaurel (#7)

Image

181. Sharon Van Etten | Tramp
(241.459348 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Serpents” (#188)
EOD Critics‘ List: #517
AMF EOY List: #17
Biggest Fan: Gillingham (#22)

Jackson
Full of Fire
Posts: 1261
Joined: Sun Feb 12, 2012 6:05 am
Location: Los Angeles

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Jackson » Fri Jul 31, 2020 2:17 pm

Some notes from the 250-201 section:

- PROTO ended up 100+ spots ahead of Platform - I wouldn't have guessed that
- Lots of electronic classics in that section (Replica, Immunity, Double Cup, Luxury Problems) that I was happy to see, but hoping for better results from. There aren't many instrumental electronic albums left for the top 200
- An Empty Bliss Beyond this World is one of the more interesting placements. I had no idea that had so many big fans here
- R.A.P. Music is a straight up classic to me, I think it's as good as any of the Run the Jewels album (I had it and RTJ2 very close on my list)

User avatar
Holden
Full of Fire
Posts: 1308
Joined: Wed Nov 20, 2019 11:06 pm

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Holden » Fri Jul 31, 2020 2:20 pm

Woah! Alt-J was supposed to make Top 100, but can’t say I’m surprised...
Overall, great placing for The Comet Is Coming!
"The better a singer's voice, the harder it is to believe what they're saying."

Jackson
Full of Fire
Posts: 1261
Joined: Sun Feb 12, 2012 6:05 am
Location: Los Angeles

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Jackson » Fri Jul 31, 2020 2:22 pm

Jackson wrote:
Fri Jul 31, 2020 2:17 pm
There aren't many instrumental electronic albums left for the top 200
I hit post right before the 200-181 section got posted. Forgot about Fin, Syro, and Rival Dealer and happy to see all of those! I like a lot in that last section with good showings for David Comes to Life, Trust in the Lifeforce..., and The Underside of Power.

User avatar
Rob
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 3731
Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Rob » Fri Jul 31, 2020 2:51 pm

Very good placements for Designer, Better Oblivion Community Center, Proto and Nonagon Infinity, all I expected to be lower (or not even placing at all)! Stranger in the Alps I expected higher, but I guess I keep overestimating how much people like that album here.

User avatar
acroamor
Full of Fire
Posts: 1104
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2012 3:16 pm
Location: Atlanta, GA

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by acroamor » Fri Jul 31, 2020 3:01 pm

Image

180. The Decemberists | The King Is Dead
(243.4686188 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #645
AMF EOY List: #24
Biggest Fan: Safetycat (#21)

Image

179. Chance the Rapper | Acid Rap
(246.7863966 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #67
AMF EOY List: #20
Biggest Fan: nassim (#4)

Image

178. MGMT | Congratulations
(247.789917 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: “Siberian Breaks” (#376), “Congratulations” (#426)
EOD Critics‘ List: #211
AMF EOY List: #23
Biggest Fan: Chambord (#4), Brad (#7)

Image

177. Sons of Kemet | Your Queen Is a Reptile
(247.8642626 points | 5 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “My Queen Is Harriet Tubman” (#431)
EOD Critics‘ List: #199
AMF EOY List: #28
Biggest Fan: Mileswide (#4)

Image

176. Perfume Genius | Too Bright
(250.8236103 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “Queen” (#42)
EOD Critics‘ List: #296
AMF EOY List: #8
Biggest Fan: Jirin (#19)

Image

175. Laura Marling | I Speak Because I Can
(253.481316 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2010
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #92
Biggest Fan: Rob (#1)

Image

174. Ondatropica | Ondatropica
(258.6441488 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2012
Songs Ranked: “Tiene Sabor Tiene Sazon” (#429)
EOD Critics‘ List: #304
AMF EOY List: #21
Biggest Fan: panam (#3)

Image

173. Michael Kiwanuka | KIWANUKA
(267.6135427 points | 12 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #12
Biggest Fan: Rumpdoll (#36)

Image

172. Drake | Take Care
(268.8782094 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Marvin’s Room” (#255)
EOD Critics‘ List: #42
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Cold Butterfly (#7), notbrianeno (#9)

Image

171. Pusha T | Daytona
(269.5839473 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #97
AMF EOY List: #13
Biggest Fan: Jeff (#15)

Image

170. Robyn | Honey
(270.0899523 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “Honey” (#232)
EOD Critics‘ List: #233
AMF EOY List: #9
Biggest Fan: Toni (#9)

Image

169. Flying Lotus | You're Dead!
(271.9896585 points | 11 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “Never Catch Me (ft. Kendrick Lamar)” (#157)
EOD Critics‘ List: #618
AMF EOY List: #11
Biggest Fan: FrankLotion (#23)

Image

168. Rosalia | El mal querer
(272.7814016 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “Malamente” (#131)
EOD Critics‘ List: #49
AMF EOY List: #12
Biggest Fan: panam (#16)

Image

167. Julia Holter | Aviary
(273.4762582 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “I Shall Love 2” (#230)
EOD Critics‘ List: #693
AMF EOY List: #11
Biggest Fan: CupOfDreams (#12)

Image

166. Sturgill Simpson | Metamodern Sounds in Country Music
(275.2785722 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2014
Songs Ranked: “Turtles All the Way Down” (#357)
EOD Critics‘ List: #224
AMF EOY List: #68
Biggest Fan: maverick470 (#7)

Image

165. Lykke Li | Wounded Rhymes
(277.4344778 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “I Follow Rivers” (#207)
EOD Critics‘ List: #370
AMF EOY List: #17
Biggest Fan: Dan (#2)

Image

164. Nicolas Jaar | Space Is Only Noise
(277.5431716 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #163
AMF EOY List: #25
Biggest Fan: Jirin (#18)

Image

163. Disclosure | Settle
(278.71563 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “Latch” (#149), “White Noise” (#195)
EOD Critics‘ List: #91
AMF EOY List: #17
Biggest Fan: Nick (#13)

Image

162. The Beach Boys | The SMiLE Sessions
(280.4816771 points | 7 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Rob (#5)

Image

161. Gang Gang Dance | Eye Contact
(282.217537 points | 6 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Glass Jar” (#301)
EOD Critics‘ List: unranked
AMF EOY List: #14
Biggest Fan: Jirin (#3)

Image

160. Mbongwana Star | From Kinshasa
(286.9020924 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #966
AMF EOY List: #15
Biggest Fan: Mileswide (#1)

Image

159. Weyes Blood | Front Row Seat to Earth
(288.6705665 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: “Used to Be” (#370), “Do You Need My Love” (#400)
EOD Critics‘ List: #302
AMF EOY List: #25
Biggest Fan: Brad (#9)

Image

158. Sturgill Simpson | A Sailor's Guide to Earth
(289.9704346 points | 11 votes)
Year: 2016
Songs Ranked: none
EOD Critics‘ List: #465
AMF EOY List: #21
Biggest Fan: Schuttelbirne (#21)

Image

157. CHVRCHES | The Bones of What You Believe
(291.2513328 points | 11 votes)
Year: 2013
Songs Ranked: “The Mother We Share” (#105)
EOD Critics‘ List: #194
AMF EOY List: #14
Biggest Fan: VanillaFire1000 (#18)

Image

156. Big Thief | U.F.O.F.
(293.9127972 points | 12 votes)
Year: 2019
Songs Ranked: “UFOF” (#212)
EOD Critics‘ List: #129
AMF EOY List: #9
Biggest Fan: Chris K. (#25)

Image

155. Florence + the Machine | Ceremonials
(296.0723173 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Shake It Out” (#162), “What the Water Gave Me” (#382)
EOD Critics‘ List: #228
AMF EOY List: unranked
Biggest Fan: Safetycat (#9)

Image

154. SZA | CTRL
(297.0937352 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2017
Songs Ranked: “Drew Barrymore” (#241)
EOD Critics‘ List: #41
AMF EOY List: #18
Biggest Fan: Toni (#6)

Image

153. SOPHIE | Oil of Every Pearl's Un-Insides
(299.1608616 points | 8 votes)
Year: 2018
Songs Ranked: “Immaterial” (#303)
EOD Critics‘ List: #76
AMF EOY List: #17
Biggest Fan: PlasticRam (#9)

Image

152. Susanne Sundfor | Ten Love Songs
(299.8386682 points | 9 votes)
Year: 2015
Songs Ranked: “Kamikaze” (#245), “Accelerate” (#409)
EOD Critics‘ List: #1079
AMF EOY List: #32
Biggest Fan: Phil (#4)

Image

151. tUnE-yArDs | w h o k i l l
(300.7514554 points | 10 votes)
Year: 2011
Songs Ranked: “Bizness” (#261)
EOD Critics‘ List: #265
AMF EOY List: #13
Biggest Fan: Acroamor (#5)

User avatar
Rob
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 3731
Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands

Re: AMF Favorite Albums of the 2010s - RESULTS

Post by Rob » Fri Jul 31, 2020 3:36 pm

And there goes my #1, about where I expected her.

Surprised to see that The Smile Sessions got absolutely no support from the critics on the EOD lists. They really don't go for archival releases I guess.

Post Reply