The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Decade poll time.
You don't have to have participated in the year polls to vote in the decade poll.
Put your rank (1, 2, 3, etc) into the “rank” column of the excel sheet (below). If you have not heard a song or album, please leave the rank cell blank. Songs/albums you don't rank will be given the same score as the song/album in the middle of your list, so if you don't like a song/album do rank it so that it doesn't end up being bumped up in a way you didn't intend.
Send your completed 2000s poll worksheet to amf2000spoll@gmail.com by:-
Songs Deadline: January 20th 2018
Albums Deadline: January 27th 2018
More information & analysis to follow.
You don't have to have participated in the year polls to vote in the decade poll.
Put your rank (1, 2, 3, etc) into the “rank” column of the excel sheet (below). If you have not heard a song or album, please leave the rank cell blank. Songs/albums you don't rank will be given the same score as the song/album in the middle of your list, so if you don't like a song/album do rank it so that it doesn't end up being bumped up in a way you didn't intend.
Send your completed 2000s poll worksheet to amf2000spoll@gmail.com by:-
Songs Deadline: January 20th 2018
Albums Deadline: January 27th 2018
More information & analysis to follow.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
This is the formula being used:-
100*(1+30)/(position+30)
If you rank all 150 albums/songs, this is how the point will break down.
1 = 100 points
2 = 96.88 points
3 = 93.94 points
4 = 91.18 points
5 = 88.57 points
6 = 86.11 points
7 = 83.78 points
8 = 81.58 points
9 = 79.49 points
10 = 77.5 points
11 = 75.61 points
12 = 73.81 points
13 = 72.09 points
14 = 70.45 points
15 = 68.89 points
16 = 67.39 points
17 = 65.96 points
18 = 64.58 points
19 = 63.27 points
20 = 62 points
21 = 60.78 points
22 = 59.62 points
23 = 58.49 points
24 = 57.41 points
25 = 56.36 points
26 = 55.36 points
27 = 54.39 points
28 = 53.45 points
29 = 52.54 points
30 = 51.67 points
31 = 50.82 points
32 = 50 points
33 = 49.21 points
34 = 48.44 points
35 = 47.69 points
36 = 46.97 points
37 = 46.27 points
38 = 45.59 points
39 = 44.93 points
40 = 44.29 points
41 = 43.66 points
42 = 43.06 points
43 = 42.47 points
44 = 41.89 points
45 = 41.33 points
46 = 40.79 points
47 = 40.26 points
48 = 39.74 points
49 = 39.24 points
50 = 38.75 points
51 = 38.27 points
52 = 37.8 points
53 = 37.35 points
54 = 36.9 points
55 = 36.47 points
56 = 36.05 points
57 = 35.63 points
58 = 35.23 points
59 = 34.83 points
60 = 34.44 points
61 = 34.07 points
62 = 33.7 points
63 = 33.33 points
64 = 32.98 points
65 = 32.63 points
66 = 32.29 points
67 = 31.96 points
68 = 31.63 points
69 = 31.31 points
70 = 31 points
71 = 30.69 points
72 = 30.39 points
73 = 30.1 points
74 = 29.81 points
75 = 29.52 points
76 = 29.25 points
77 = 28.97 points
78 = 28.7 points
79 = 28.44 points
80 = 28.18 points
81 = 27.93 points
82 = 27.68 points
83 = 27.43 points
84 = 27.19 points
85 = 26.96 points
86 = 26.72 points
87 = 26.5 points
88 = 26.27 points
89 = 26.05 points
90 = 25.83 points
91 = 25.62 points
92 = 25.41 points
93 = 25.2 points
94 = 25 points
95 = 24.8 points
96 = 24.6 points
97 = 24.41 points
98 = 24.22 points
99 = 24.03 points
100 = 23.85 points
101 = 23.66 points
102 = 23.48 points
103 = 23.31 points
104 = 23.13 points
105 = 22.96 points
106 = 22.79 points
107 = 22.63 points
108 = 22.46 points
109 = 22.3 points
110 = 22.14 points
111 = 21.99 points
112 = 21.83 points
113 = 21.68 points
114 = 21.53 points
115 = 21.38 points
116 = 21.23 points
117 = 21.09 points
118 = 20.95 points
119 = 20.81 points
120 = 20.67 points
121 = 20.53 points
122 = 20.39 points
123 = 20.26 points
124 = 20.13 points
125 = 20 points
126 = 19.87 points
127 = 19.75 points
128 = 19.62 points
129 = 19.5 points
130 = 19.38 points
131 = 19.25 points
132 = 19.14 points
133 = 19.02 points
134 = 18.9 points
135 = 18.79 points
136 = 18.67 points
137 = 18.56 points
138 = 18.45 points
139 = 18.34 points
140 = 18.24 points
141 = 18.13 points
142 = 18.02 points
143 = 17.92 points
144 = 17.82 points
145 = 17.71 points
146 = 17.61 points
147 = 17.51 points
148 = 17.42 points
149 = 17.32 points
150 = 17.22 points
Rank each list from 1 to 150. If you haven't heard them all just rank from 1 to {however many you rank}. 1 being your favourite through to 150 being your least favourite.
This system works well if there a handful of albums/songs you have never heard - as you would not necessarily dislike them, so giving them a middle-of-the pack ranking seems fairest.
If you rank only your 60 favourites, then the other 90 albums would be ranked as equivalent to your #30 and your #60 would be ranked last! Not a good outcome. So as a general rule, rank as many albums as you reasonably can. Especially as the way the formula works, the further down the rankings you go the less difference it makes; The points difference between #116 & #150 is less than the points difference between #1 & #2. So you don't need to worry about precision in your lower rankings; If you've only heard it once and you were not enthused, then ranking it somewhere in the bottom quarter is much better than not ranking it at all.
100*(1+30)/(position+30)
If you rank all 150 albums/songs, this is how the point will break down.
1 = 100 points
2 = 96.88 points
3 = 93.94 points
4 = 91.18 points
5 = 88.57 points
6 = 86.11 points
7 = 83.78 points
8 = 81.58 points
9 = 79.49 points
10 = 77.5 points
11 = 75.61 points
12 = 73.81 points
13 = 72.09 points
14 = 70.45 points
15 = 68.89 points
16 = 67.39 points
17 = 65.96 points
18 = 64.58 points
19 = 63.27 points
20 = 62 points
21 = 60.78 points
22 = 59.62 points
23 = 58.49 points
24 = 57.41 points
25 = 56.36 points
26 = 55.36 points
27 = 54.39 points
28 = 53.45 points
29 = 52.54 points
30 = 51.67 points
31 = 50.82 points
32 = 50 points
33 = 49.21 points
34 = 48.44 points
35 = 47.69 points
36 = 46.97 points
37 = 46.27 points
38 = 45.59 points
39 = 44.93 points
40 = 44.29 points
41 = 43.66 points
42 = 43.06 points
43 = 42.47 points
44 = 41.89 points
45 = 41.33 points
46 = 40.79 points
47 = 40.26 points
48 = 39.74 points
49 = 39.24 points
50 = 38.75 points
51 = 38.27 points
52 = 37.8 points
53 = 37.35 points
54 = 36.9 points
55 = 36.47 points
56 = 36.05 points
57 = 35.63 points
58 = 35.23 points
59 = 34.83 points
60 = 34.44 points
61 = 34.07 points
62 = 33.7 points
63 = 33.33 points
64 = 32.98 points
65 = 32.63 points
66 = 32.29 points
67 = 31.96 points
68 = 31.63 points
69 = 31.31 points
70 = 31 points
71 = 30.69 points
72 = 30.39 points
73 = 30.1 points
74 = 29.81 points
75 = 29.52 points
76 = 29.25 points
77 = 28.97 points
78 = 28.7 points
79 = 28.44 points
80 = 28.18 points
81 = 27.93 points
82 = 27.68 points
83 = 27.43 points
84 = 27.19 points
85 = 26.96 points
86 = 26.72 points
87 = 26.5 points
88 = 26.27 points
89 = 26.05 points
90 = 25.83 points
91 = 25.62 points
92 = 25.41 points
93 = 25.2 points
94 = 25 points
95 = 24.8 points
96 = 24.6 points
97 = 24.41 points
98 = 24.22 points
99 = 24.03 points
100 = 23.85 points
101 = 23.66 points
102 = 23.48 points
103 = 23.31 points
104 = 23.13 points
105 = 22.96 points
106 = 22.79 points
107 = 22.63 points
108 = 22.46 points
109 = 22.3 points
110 = 22.14 points
111 = 21.99 points
112 = 21.83 points
113 = 21.68 points
114 = 21.53 points
115 = 21.38 points
116 = 21.23 points
117 = 21.09 points
118 = 20.95 points
119 = 20.81 points
120 = 20.67 points
121 = 20.53 points
122 = 20.39 points
123 = 20.26 points
124 = 20.13 points
125 = 20 points
126 = 19.87 points
127 = 19.75 points
128 = 19.62 points
129 = 19.5 points
130 = 19.38 points
131 = 19.25 points
132 = 19.14 points
133 = 19.02 points
134 = 18.9 points
135 = 18.79 points
136 = 18.67 points
137 = 18.56 points
138 = 18.45 points
139 = 18.34 points
140 = 18.24 points
141 = 18.13 points
142 = 18.02 points
143 = 17.92 points
144 = 17.82 points
145 = 17.71 points
146 = 17.61 points
147 = 17.51 points
148 = 17.42 points
149 = 17.32 points
150 = 17.22 points
Rank each list from 1 to 150. If you haven't heard them all just rank from 1 to {however many you rank}. 1 being your favourite through to 150 being your least favourite.
This system works well if there a handful of albums/songs you have never heard - as you would not necessarily dislike them, so giving them a middle-of-the pack ranking seems fairest.
If you rank only your 60 favourites, then the other 90 albums would be ranked as equivalent to your #30 and your #60 would be ranked last! Not a good outcome. So as a general rule, rank as many albums as you reasonably can. Especially as the way the formula works, the further down the rankings you go the less difference it makes; The points difference between #116 & #150 is less than the points difference between #1 & #2. So you don't need to worry about precision in your lower rankings; If you've only heard it once and you were not enthused, then ranking it somewhere in the bottom quarter is much better than not ranking it at all.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
These are the highest AM ranked albums from the 2000s that failed to make our top 150 for the decade poll:-
AM 2000s rank | Artist | Album | Year | Rank in our year poll
59 | Broken Social Scene | You Forgot It in People | 2002 | 22
62 | Bloc Party | Silent Alarm | 2005 | 21
70 | The Postal Service | Give Up | 2003 | 22
77 | Bob Dylan | Modern Times | 2006 | 20
79 | Of Montreal | Hissing Fauna, Are You The Destroyer? | 2007 | 22
These are the highest ranked 2000s albums from our 2017 All-time albums poll that failed to make our top 150 for the decade poll:-
AMF 2017 All-time 2000s rank | Artist | Album | Year | Rank in our year poll
66 | Raekwon | Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt II | 2009 | 22
76 | Spoon | Kill the Moonlight | 2002 | 19
81 | Annie | Anniemal | 2004 | 46
86 | Coldplay | X&Y | 2005 | 19
96 | Joanna Newsom | The Milk-Eyed Mender | 2004 | 25
100 | Bloc Party | Silent Alarm | 2005 | 21
And from the last AMF 2000's poll (of 100 albums in 2011), these albums have failed to make our top 150 this time:-
AMF 2011 2000s poll rank | Artist | Album | Year | Rank in our year poll
65 | Spoon | Kill the Moonlight | 2002 | 19
76 | M83 | Saturdays=Youth | 2008 | 16
78 | Cut Copy | In Ghost Colours | 2008 | 35
80 | Deerhunter | Microcastle / Weird Era Continued | 2008 | 19
84 | The Postal Service | Give Up | 2003 | 22
87 | Girls | Album | 2009 | 92
92 | Altlers | Hospice | 2009 | 39
93 | The Shins | Oh, Inverted World | 2001 | 28
98 | The Dodos | Visiter | 2008 | 23
99 | Broken Social Scene | You Forgot It in People | 2002 | 22
These are the highest AM ranked songs from the 2000s that failed to make our top 150 for the decade poll:-
AM 2000s rank | Artist | Song | Year | Rank in our year poll
12 | MGMT | Kids | 2007 | 23
22 | The Rapture | House of Jealous Lovers | 2002 | 24
24 | Hot Chip | Over and Over | 2006 | 16
41 | Peter Bjorn and John | Young Folks | 2006 | 12
43 | The xx | Crystalised | 2009 | 15
45 | Justice | We Are Your Friends | 2006 | 220
49 | The Gossip | Standing in the Way of Control | 2006 | 18
These are the highest ranked 2000s songs from our 2015 All-time songs poll that failed to make our top 150 for the decade poll:-
AMF 2015 All-time 2000s rank | Artist | Song | Year | Rank in our year poll
37 | MGMT | Kids | 2007 | 23
58 | Wilco | I Am Trying to Break Your Heart | 2002 | 59
59 | Annie | Heartbeat | 2004 | 21
64 | Bloc Party | Banquet | 2004 | 143
72 | Radiohead | 15 Step | 2007 | 91
73 | Interpol | Obstacle 1 | 2002 | 55
74 | The Flaming Lips | Fight Test | 2002 | 25
75 | The Coral | Dreaming of You | 2002 | 59
And from the last AMF 2000's poll (of 100 songs in 2011), these songs have failed to make our top 150 this time:-
AMF 2011 2000s poll rank | Artist | Song | Year | Rank in our year poll
40 | M83 | Kim & Jessie | 2008 | 26
41 | MGMT | Kids | 2007 | 23
42 | Annie | Heartbeat | 2004 | 21
61 | New Order | Crystal | 2001 | 25
65 | Kanye West | Gone | 2005 | 17
68 | Peter Bjorn and John | Young Folks | 2006 | 12
69 | LCD Soundsystem | Tribulations | 2005 | 19
72 | The xx | Crystalised | 2009 | 15
73 | Depeche Mode | Precious | 2005 | 123
75 | Deerhunter | Nothing Ever Happenned | 2008 | 30
AM 2000s rank | Artist | Album | Year | Rank in our year poll
59 | Broken Social Scene | You Forgot It in People | 2002 | 22
62 | Bloc Party | Silent Alarm | 2005 | 21
70 | The Postal Service | Give Up | 2003 | 22
77 | Bob Dylan | Modern Times | 2006 | 20
79 | Of Montreal | Hissing Fauna, Are You The Destroyer? | 2007 | 22
These are the highest ranked 2000s albums from our 2017 All-time albums poll that failed to make our top 150 for the decade poll:-
AMF 2017 All-time 2000s rank | Artist | Album | Year | Rank in our year poll
66 | Raekwon | Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt II | 2009 | 22
76 | Spoon | Kill the Moonlight | 2002 | 19
81 | Annie | Anniemal | 2004 | 46
86 | Coldplay | X&Y | 2005 | 19
96 | Joanna Newsom | The Milk-Eyed Mender | 2004 | 25
100 | Bloc Party | Silent Alarm | 2005 | 21
And from the last AMF 2000's poll (of 100 albums in 2011), these albums have failed to make our top 150 this time:-
AMF 2011 2000s poll rank | Artist | Album | Year | Rank in our year poll
65 | Spoon | Kill the Moonlight | 2002 | 19
76 | M83 | Saturdays=Youth | 2008 | 16
78 | Cut Copy | In Ghost Colours | 2008 | 35
80 | Deerhunter | Microcastle / Weird Era Continued | 2008 | 19
84 | The Postal Service | Give Up | 2003 | 22
87 | Girls | Album | 2009 | 92
92 | Altlers | Hospice | 2009 | 39
93 | The Shins | Oh, Inverted World | 2001 | 28
98 | The Dodos | Visiter | 2008 | 23
99 | Broken Social Scene | You Forgot It in People | 2002 | 22
These are the highest AM ranked songs from the 2000s that failed to make our top 150 for the decade poll:-
AM 2000s rank | Artist | Song | Year | Rank in our year poll
12 | MGMT | Kids | 2007 | 23
22 | The Rapture | House of Jealous Lovers | 2002 | 24
24 | Hot Chip | Over and Over | 2006 | 16
41 | Peter Bjorn and John | Young Folks | 2006 | 12
43 | The xx | Crystalised | 2009 | 15
45 | Justice | We Are Your Friends | 2006 | 220
49 | The Gossip | Standing in the Way of Control | 2006 | 18
These are the highest ranked 2000s songs from our 2015 All-time songs poll that failed to make our top 150 for the decade poll:-
AMF 2015 All-time 2000s rank | Artist | Song | Year | Rank in our year poll
37 | MGMT | Kids | 2007 | 23
58 | Wilco | I Am Trying to Break Your Heart | 2002 | 59
59 | Annie | Heartbeat | 2004 | 21
64 | Bloc Party | Banquet | 2004 | 143
72 | Radiohead | 15 Step | 2007 | 91
73 | Interpol | Obstacle 1 | 2002 | 55
74 | The Flaming Lips | Fight Test | 2002 | 25
75 | The Coral | Dreaming of You | 2002 | 59
And from the last AMF 2000's poll (of 100 songs in 2011), these songs have failed to make our top 150 this time:-
AMF 2011 2000s poll rank | Artist | Song | Year | Rank in our year poll
40 | M83 | Kim & Jessie | 2008 | 26
41 | MGMT | Kids | 2007 | 23
42 | Annie | Heartbeat | 2004 | 21
61 | New Order | Crystal | 2001 | 25
65 | Kanye West | Gone | 2005 | 17
68 | Peter Bjorn and John | Young Folks | 2006 | 12
69 | LCD Soundsystem | Tribulations | 2005 | 19
72 | The xx | Crystalised | 2009 | 15
73 | Depeche Mode | Precious | 2005 | 123
75 | Deerhunter | Nothing Ever Happenned | 2008 | 30
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Could I rank my list right here?
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
No you can't, there's an adresse mail above for sending the list. And I'm sure using the excel template would hep DaveC a lot.panam wrote:Could I rank my list right here?
Here is a spotify playlist with 146 songs :
And the missings songs :
Alicia Keys and Jay-Z - Empire State of Mind
Shiina Ringo - Sōretsu (Funeral Procession)
Joanna Newsom - Emily
Kashiwa Daisuke - Stella
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Far from the song I'll miss the most, but I'm still stunned Kids ended up so low in its year poll !DaveC wrote: These are the highest AM ranked songs from the 2000s that failed to make our top 150 for the decade poll:-
AM 2000s rank | Artist | Song | Year | Rank in our year poll
12 | MGMT | Kids | 2007 | 23
These are the highest ranked 2000s songs from our 2015 All-time songs poll that failed to make our top 150 for the decade poll:-
AMF 2015 All-time 2000s rank | Artist | Song | Year | Rank in our year poll
37 | MGMT | Kids | 2007 | 23
And from the last AMF 2000's poll (of 100 songs in 2011), these songs have failed to make our top 150 this time:-
AMF 2011 2000s poll rank | Artist | Song | Year | Rank in our year poll
40 | M83 | Kim & Jessie | 2008 | 26
41 | MGMT | Kids | 2007 | 23
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Wow, That's great thanks for the playlist Nassim.
- Rob
- Die Mensch Maschine
- Posts: 7403
- Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
- Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Shiina Ringo's Funeral Procession is on Spotify in my region, but her name and the Japanese song title are spelled slightly different, and the song is simply named Funeral; it might be the reason you couldn't find it. I think it is the right one.Nassim wrote: Shiina Ringo - Sōretsu (Funeral Procession)
Does this work for you?:
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
It doesn't work for me Rob, but hopefully it will work for some.Rob wrote: Does this work for you?:
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Yes, I've added it !Rob wrote:Shiina Ringo's Funeral Procession is on Spotify in my region, but her name and the Japanese song title are spelled slightly different, and the song is simply named Funeral; it might be the reason you couldn't find it. I think it is the right one.Nassim wrote: Shiina Ringo - Sōretsu (Funeral Procession)
Does this work for you?:
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
And whuntva breaks all records with a same day ballot!!
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Four submissions received so far.
Comments will be published as part of the roll-out so do include them if you are inclined.
Comments will be published as part of the roll-out so do include them if you are inclined.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Didn't we use a difference formula at some point where the points difference would be lowest near the middle? Considering there is probably a bigger difference of opinion between 130 and 150 (probably an album you don't care much about and one you strongly dislike) than between 65 and 85 which should be both albums you kinda like.DaveC wrote:This is the formula being used:-
100*(1+30)/(position+30)
The points difference between #116 & #150 is less than the points difference between #1 & #2. So you don't need to worry about precision in your lower rankings; If you've only heard it once and you were not enthused, then ranking it somewhere in the bottom quarter is much better than not ranking it at all.
Reducing the difference as you go makes lot of sense when you rank only albums or songs you like (for an all time poll for instance) but less when you rank a specific set of albums or songs.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I think your argument is a good one. This is the formula that was in use when I started hosting these polls. I don't want to start making up formulas randomly. Would anyone like to propose an alternative formula? I welcome discussion on this, but I won't change the formula unless there is a decent amount of support for it.Nassim wrote:Didn't we use a difference formula at some point where the points difference would be lowest near the middle? Considering there is probably a bigger difference of opinion between 130 and 150 (probably an album you don't care much about and one you strongly dislike) than between 65 and 85 which should be both albums you kinda like.DaveC wrote:This is the formula being used:-
100*(1+30)/(position+30)
The points difference between #116 & #150 is less than the points difference between #1 & #2. So you don't need to worry about precision in your lower rankings; If you've only heard it once and you were not enthused, then ranking it somewhere in the bottom quarter is much better than not ranking it at all.
Reducing the difference as you go makes lot of sense when you rank only albums or songs you like (for an all time poll for instance) but less when you rank a specific set of albums or songs.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I would advocate for win/loss formula similar to AM site personally but those are more complicated and less traceable.
I think difference should decrease as you go down because I think polarizing albums belong higher on the rankings than albums everyone agrees are 'pretty good'.
I think difference should decrease as you go down because I think polarizing albums belong higher on the rankings than albums everyone agrees are 'pretty good'.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I like Nassim's idea, I did a poll years ago where the high up rankings barely had a difference in points. Songs or albums say 12-15 would be the same amount of points whereas songs and albums 80-100 would have the same amount of points. The gap becomes wider the higher the placing.Jirin wrote:I would advocate for win/loss formula similar to AM site personally but those are more complicated and less traceable.
I think difference should decrease as you go down because I think polarizing albums belong higher on the rankings than albums everyone agrees are 'pretty good'.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I dunno, if we were ranking among every album people heard I'd agree that it should be more like a bell curve. These final rounds are pre-selected to be albums a lot of people like, so I think for most people the distribution is very skewed and the meaty part of the bell curve falls more in people's 20th percentile. If we do have difference biggest at top and bottom I think it should only be the very bottom.
And like I said, I think loved/hated albums belong way higher on the list than consensus 'pretty decent' albums.
Going through my rankings I'm shocked the New Pornographers went 0 for 3 in qualification. Used to be a popular band on this board, why has their popularity dropped off so dramatically?
And like I said, I think loved/hated albums belong way higher on the list than consensus 'pretty decent' albums.
Going through my rankings I'm shocked the New Pornographers went 0 for 3 in qualification. Used to be a popular band on this board, why has their popularity dropped off so dramatically?
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Ballots received so far from:-
BangJan
bonnielaurel
DaveC
Henry
JamieW
jirin (Albums only)
Listyguy (songs only)
maverick470
Nassim
sonofsamiam
whuntva
I'm going to be visiting relatives in Australia in the last 2 weeks of January, but I should be able to start the results rollout as planned - in about 9 days for the songs. If anyone needs the deadline to be pushed back, please let me know.
BangJan
bonnielaurel
DaveC
Henry
JamieW
jirin (Albums only)
Listyguy (songs only)
maverick470
Nassim
sonofsamiam
whuntva
I'm going to be visiting relatives in Australia in the last 2 weeks of January, but I should be able to start the results rollout as planned - in about 9 days for the songs. If anyone needs the deadline to be pushed back, please let me know.
- StevieFan13
- Die Mensch Maschine
- Posts: 7001
- Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2017 5:00 pm
- Location: New York, New York
- Contact:
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Gonna try to send in my results in the next few days - was planning on making comments for all of them and there are still a few I need to listen to.DaveC wrote:Ballots received so far from:-
BangJan
bonnielaurel
DaveC
Henry
JamieW
jirin (Albums only)
Listyguy (songs only)
maverick470
Nassim
sonofsamiam
whuntva
I'm going to be visiting relatives in Australia in the last 2 weeks of January, but I should be able to start the results rollout as planned - in about 9 days for the songs. If anyone needs the deadline to be pushed back, please let me know.
Music is a world within itself, with a language we all understand - Sir Duke (1976)
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
That is fine; I expect many votes to arrive around about the deadline and I'm more than happy for you to take time to add comments.StevieFan13 wrote:Gonna try to send in my results in the next few days - was planning on making comments for all of them and there are still a few I need to listen to.
-
- Wannabe
- Posts: 124
- Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2012 10:13 am
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
So the deadline for songs today?
- StevieFan13
- Die Mensch Maschine
- Posts: 7001
- Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2017 5:00 pm
- Location: New York, New York
- Contact:
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Hope not - still need to get mine in.Depeche Mode wrote:So the deadline for songs today?
Music is a world within itself, with a language we all understand - Sir Duke (1976)
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
The deadline for songs is today, but I'll extend for a few days to give time for some more vote to come in. At this stage, I've received about 16 submissions for the songs poll; I'm hoping for a few more.
- Rob
- Die Mensch Maschine
- Posts: 7403
- Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:53 pm
- Location: Nijmegen, The Netherlands
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Handed in my song list just now. I wrote comments for all entries, but due to little time I had to write most of them this very day. I didn't have time to proofread so apologize in advance for any mistakes (and the odd uninspired entry).
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
You will get my list tomorrow, or so I hope
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
19 song ballots received so far from:-
andyd1010
BangJan
BleuPanda
bonnielaurel
Brad
Dan
DaveC
Depeche Mode
Henry
JamieW
Listyguy
maverick470
Nassim
phil
prosecutorgodot
Rob
sonofsamiam
Toni
whuntva
I'll wait for rumpdoll and anyone else who would like to get a ballot in before rolling out the song results.
Right now neither our #1 nor #2 songs have a single #1 vote.
andyd1010
BangJan
BleuPanda
bonnielaurel
Brad
Dan
DaveC
Depeche Mode
Henry
JamieW
Listyguy
maverick470
Nassim
phil
prosecutorgodot
Rob
sonofsamiam
Toni
whuntva
I'll wait for rumpdoll and anyone else who would like to get a ballot in before rolling out the song results.
Right now neither our #1 nor #2 songs have a single #1 vote.
- StevieFan13
- Die Mensch Maschine
- Posts: 7001
- Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2017 5:00 pm
- Location: New York, New York
- Contact:
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I will send in my votes by tomorrow
Music is a world within itself, with a language we all understand - Sir Duke (1976)
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Sorry, I forgot you StevieFan13. I'm away from home in very hot Perth looking after Grandchildren, so I'm a bit unfocussed at the moment.StevieFan13 wrote:I will send in my votes by tomorrow
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I hope it is not too late for the Songs Poll... I finally had an opportunity to get it done today and just e-mailed it over.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Up to 23 song ballots now, with
Neil
rumpdoll
slick
StevieFan13
Just waiting for a final clarification from StevieFan13. Still time for any last minute submissions. Probably starting the rollout in about 16 hours.
Neil
rumpdoll
slick
StevieFan13
Just waiting for a final clarification from StevieFan13. Still time for any last minute submissions. Probably starting the rollout in about 16 hours.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Submitted my list for the songs poll. Hope it's not too much trouble. Thanks!
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Received thanks. No problem.Dexter wrote:Submitted my list for the songs poll. Hope it's not too much trouble. Thanks!
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Dave, how hard of a deadline is the album deadline? I'll send you my list whenever you need it (but I will keep going until I've heard them all if not given a stopping point )
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I'm rather distracted and busy at the moment (I even got side-tracked in the middle of typing this). So the songs rollout will take a while. The albums will slip by at least a week, but I'll let know when I'm getting close.Listyguy wrote:Dave, how hard of a deadline is the album deadline? I'll send you my list whenever you need it (but I will keep going until I've heard them all if not given a stopping point )
-
- Rust Never Sleeps
- Posts: 759
- Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2012 9:50 pm
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Keep me informed of the soft deadline, too! I have a list I can submit, but I'll keep listening and editing if I have extra time...
It's becoming my December/January tradition to spend those months listening to whatever decade AM is currently on...
It's becoming my December/January tradition to spend those months listening to whatever decade AM is currently on...
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Also...does anyone have any suggestions for listening to The Black Album that don't involve paying for it or using Tidal?
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
This is the site I turn to as a last resort. (It's become something of a forum favorite, since others have recommended it as well.)Listyguy wrote:Also...does anyone have any suggestions for listening to The Black Album that don't involve paying for it or using Tidal?
https://mp3music.ru/jay-z/the-black-album
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Great, thanks!jamieW wrote:This is the site I turn to as a last resort. (It's become something of a forum favorite, since others have recommended it as well.)Listyguy wrote:Also...does anyone have any suggestions for listening to The Black Album that don't involve paying for it or using Tidal?
https://mp3music.ru/jay-z/the-black-album
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
17 album ballots received so far:-
BangJan
bonnielaurel
Brad
ChrisK
DaveC
Gillingham
Henry
JamieW
Jirin
Listyguy
luvulongTIM
maverick470
Nassim
rumpdoll
sonofsamiam
spiritualized
whuntva
Confidently expecting ballots from: phil, Toni, kingoftonga.
Participated in songs poll, but maybe not participating in the albums poll: andyd1010, BleuPanda, Dan, Depeche Mode, Dexter, Neil, slick, StevieFan13.
So I'll close off the albums poll submissions in 48 hours from now, unless someone specifically asks for an extension.
BangJan
bonnielaurel
Brad
ChrisK
DaveC
Gillingham
Henry
JamieW
Jirin
Listyguy
luvulongTIM
maverick470
Nassim
rumpdoll
sonofsamiam
spiritualized
whuntva
Confidently expecting ballots from: phil, Toni, kingoftonga.
Participated in songs poll, but maybe not participating in the albums poll: andyd1010, BleuPanda, Dan, Depeche Mode, Dexter, Neil, slick, StevieFan13.
So I'll close off the albums poll submissions in 48 hours from now, unless someone specifically asks for an extension.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I'm going to participate in the album poll...just hopefully I remember to submit it in time!
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Me too!BleuPanda wrote:I'm going to participate in the album poll...just hopefully I remember to submit it in time!
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Submitted mine (with the correct file this time!)DaveC wrote: Confidently expecting ballots from: phil, Toni, kingoftonga.
- StevieFan13
- Die Mensch Maschine
- Posts: 7001
- Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2017 5:00 pm
- Location: New York, New York
- Contact:
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I haven’t listened to a lot of the albums but I’ll see what I can do
Music is a world within itself, with a language we all understand - Sir Duke (1976)
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I'm going to ask for an extension; I can't work on it today, and I'm busy on Sunday mornings, but I'll have the entire afternoon and evening tomorrow to finalize it. Instead of ending at 2 PM CST tomorrow, can it end at midnightish?
-
- Rust Never Sleeps
- Posts: 759
- Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2012 9:50 pm
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
You'll have my list within the next 24 hours.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
No problem. So long as I know I'm expecting a list from you I will wait.BleuPanda wrote:I'm going to ask for an extension; I can't work on it today, and I'm busy on Sunday mornings, but I'll have the entire afternoon and evening tomorrow to finalize it. Instead of ending at 2 PM CST tomorrow, can it end at midnightish?
I have received lists from phil & LiveinPhoenix. I won't close the poll until I receive lists (or replies) from Toni, kingoftonga, andyd1010, BleuPanda, and StevieFan13. Take the time you need.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
I will send a list too, DaveC! Currently it has around 115 albums, but I had planned to listen and relisten to some more albums until the end of songs results rollout. That said, probably I'll be done with it in the next days, already.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
22 album ballots received now:-
BangJan
BleuPanda
bonnielaurel
Brad
ChrisK
DaveC
Depeche Mode
Gillingham
Henry
JamieW
Jirin
kingoftonga
Listyguy
LiveinPhoenix
luvulongTIM
maverick470
Nassim
phil
rumpdoll
sonofsamiam
spiritualized
whuntva
Expecting lists from: Toni, andyd1010, and StevieFan13. This is your 24 hour call.
BangJan
BleuPanda
bonnielaurel
Brad
ChrisK
DaveC
Depeche Mode
Gillingham
Henry
JamieW
Jirin
kingoftonga
Listyguy
LiveinPhoenix
luvulongTIM
maverick470
Nassim
phil
rumpdoll
sonofsamiam
spiritualized
whuntva
Expecting lists from: Toni, andyd1010, and StevieFan13. This is your 24 hour call.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
So, who guessed the top 3 correctly? Well nobody.
Re: The Best Albums & Songs of the 2000s
Woops
Last edited by DaveC on Thu Feb 08, 2018 4:21 am, edited 1 time in total.