Acclaimed Music Forums

Legiâo Urbana's "Faroeste Caboclo" is on Al Borde List and Rolling Stone List, it could be included

http://www.acclaimedmusic.net/forums/vi ... 70&p=13856 (appears as Faboclo)
http://www.acclaimedmusic.net/forums/vi ... f=3&t=3850

Paralamas's "Alagados" is on Rolling Stone List and on VH1 South American List (with spanish version "Inundados")

http://www.acclaimedmusic.net/forums/vi ... 50&p=55385
http://www.acclaimedmusic.net/forums/vi ... 44&p=15243

Akron/family artist page is a dead link

isn't it Ice Cold Ice instead of Ice Cold Eyes for Husker Du Song?

lagire wrote:isn't it Ice Cold Ice instead of Ice Cold Eyes for Husker Du Song?

I feel very strange that you make 3 different lists for 1,001 Songs You Must Hear Before You Die, and 10,001 You Must Download (2010)
one for 2010 , one for 2015 and one for french version.
It's lists which evolved with times. i only hope that you give in total for these 3 lists a same coefficient that a single list.
Otherwise, it's not fair.
Ok between the french & english version, there's many differences but the french book was conceived from the english one.
And i don't understand the 2 separate lists between 2010 & 2015, there's no so many changes.
At the end, there's songs which are well rated and don't deserve it.

Shania Twain's "Man! I Feel Like a Woman!" is from 1997, not 1999.
There should also be an exclamation mark after "Woman".

Listening to Haim got me here...

Help I'm Alive by Metric is from 2008. Although released in the US and Europe in January 2009, it was already released on 23 December in Canada.

Ríos, Miguel link is broken

Harvey and The Moonglows & The Moonglows are same artist

Sandé, Emeli link is broken

In the alphabetical ordering of artists ä should count as a, ö should count as o and ü should count as u. Just had trouble finding Justus Köhncke under "K" because he is at the very beginning

The song "1-2-3" by Len Barry is listed as "2003-01-02". I assume this is a matter of Excel changing it to a date.

The song "All Summer Long" by the Beach Boys is from 1964, not 1965.

Sanford/Townsend Band, The link is broken
Sanson, Véronique too

"Loud Places" by Jamie xx should have a Feat. Romy credit.

Henrik wrote:Old error topic if anyone wants to check: http://www.acclaimedmusic.net/forums/vi ... f=2&t=2877

Alright, I'll be first.
Bruce Springsteen's "I'm Goin' Down" is from 1984, not 1985.

Similarly, Streets of Philadelphia is from 1993, not 1994.

I’d like to get thoughts on this:

1. Merge The Isley Brothers’ ”That Lady” and ”Who’s That Lady” and file under 1964.
2. Merge The Isley Brothers’ ”That Lady” and ”Who’s That Lady” and file under 1973.
3. Assume that the listed including ”Who’s That Lady” actually referred to ”That Lady” (1973 version).
4. Keep the songs separate (as it is).

panam wrote:Peru has a pair of songs in Top 10000 but there's no songs page

No link

Idk if this is specific to the 2017 update but Bud Powell's The Amazing Bud Powell was released in 1952, not 1951.

Henrik wrote:I’d like to get thoughts on this:

1. Merge The Isley Brothers’ ”That Lady” and ”Who’s That Lady” and file under 1964.
2. Merge The Isley Brothers’ ”That Lady” and ”Who’s That Lady” and file under 1973.
3. Assume that the listed including ”Who’s That Lady” actually referred to ”That Lady” (1973 version).
4. Keep the songs separate (as it is).

I think you should keep them separate. The recordings are different in so many ways and we should assume that the critics were aware of the different versions.

Dead links for the artist pages of Los Autenticos Decadentes and Babasonicos

Henrik wrote:I’d like to get thoughts on this:

1. Merge The Isley Brothers’ ”That Lady” and ”Who’s That Lady” and file under 1964.
2. Merge The Isley Brothers’ ”That Lady” and ”Who’s That Lady” and file under 1973.
3. Assume that the listed including ”Who’s That Lady” actually referred to ”That Lady” (1973 version).
4. Keep the songs separate (as it is).

Keep 'em separate.

Euh, i think it's 2 differents versions, agree with Bootsy
Keep 'em separate.

I never posted here before even though i visit this site frequently.

And I know this've been discussed earlier but I think it's completly wrong that Radiohead - True Love Waits included in the 2001 list. That version is a live acoustic version and has nothing to do with the studio version in 2016. Maybe that's not an error but I think the decision to include it in the 2001 list should be reconsiderd.

Scott, Travis link is broken, but isn't it twice with Scott, Travi$ Link?

Serú Girán link is broken

Il était une fois link is broken
Henrik, i think many of french and latin link are broken

lagire wrote:Il était une fois link is broken
Henrik, i think many of french and latin link are broken

Yes, I have forgotten to remove the accents for the links.

There are two pages for J.J. Johnson.

http://www.acclaimedmusic.net/artist/J. ... ohnson.htm
http://www.acclaimedmusic.net/artist/J.J.%20Johnson.htm

lagire wrote:Euh, i think it's 2 differents versions, agree with Bootsy
Keep 'em separate.

More than that, the 2 songs are mentionned in the same list
Q (UK) - The 1010 Songs You Must Own (2004)

Uwe Schutte (Germany) - Basis-Diskothek Rock und Pop (2011)

His name should be Uwe Schütte

The following list from 2003 has got a typo MUZIK The 50 Most Influential And Not Inflental !!!!!

Jack Jutson & Jack J are same artist
https://rateyourmusic.com/artist/jack_jutson

Sorry if these have been mentioned/discussed before, I’m new here...

1. The full title of the Buzzcocks’ “Ever Fallen in Love (With Someone You Shouldn't've)” should be listed - this was the title of the single release. The rear of the original LP sleeve lists it just us “Ever Fallen in Love” with no question mark, but the vinyl itself lists the full single title with a question mark inside the end bracket

2. Shouldn’t “Stan” by Eminem Feat. Dido show on Dido’s page in the same way that “Crazy in Love” shows on Jay-Z’s page and “Happy” on Pharrell Williams’

3. Personal pedantry I know, but perhaps the Bowie song from 2016 is represented by the symbol ★ rather than a word. Perhaps it could be “★ [Blackstar]”

4. More pedantry: I’d list “96 Tears” as being by ? And the Mysterians rather than Question Mark and the Mysterians

5. I think it’s a bit daft not to have the full spelling of “F*** tha Police” by N.W.A. as that’s just a censorship thing

6. Similarly, I think the case for listing Sam & Dave’s “Hold On, I’m Comin’” using the single title is weak: I think it should match their 1966 album title rather than using the single one that is listed which was designed to sound less risqué (and I’m really not sure it does!)

jamesnorman83 wrote: 2. Shouldn’t “Stan” by Eminem Feat. Dido show on Dido’s page in the same way that “Crazy in Love” shows on Jay-Z’s page and “Happy” on Pharrell Williams’

Yes, but Pharrell is the main artist on Happy.

The spelling of Mory Kanté's Yé Ké Yé Ké veries from place to place, but the original single named it lke this, so I think that should be used. RateYourMusic does to to. Currently it is named Ye Ke Ye ke on AM.

jamesnorman83 wrote:2. Shouldn’t “Stan” by Eminem Feat. Dido show on Dido’s page in the same way that “Crazy in Love” shows on Jay-Z’s page

This has been discussed before. It was decided that "Stan" should not be shown on Dido's page since it's a sample. Dido's vocals were not recorded for this song.

Other than that, I think I agree with everything. Thanks!

Steve Gunn Artist is under S letter, shoudn't it be under G ?

Fair do’s on Stan, makes sense.

Artist page for Void, Sterling and Paris Brightledge is a dead link.

Viet Cong and Preoccupations should probably be combined under one artist entry.

Peter Bjorn and John’s ”Young Folks” features Victoria Bergsman.

Marlene Kuntz should be uner letter M not K, it's a group

On the top 3000 albums list, #2854, Version Galore, is identified as being by "I Roy"; it should be U-Roy. The artist link does go to U-Roy's page (I-Roy has his own page).

The cedilla is missing in the first word of Plastic Bertrand’s “Ça Plane Pour Moi”

Again this may have been discussed before but I don't see how 'Round Midnight by Thelonious Monk can be from 1946 - he didn't record it until late 1947! According to RYM the Blue Note single (543) was released (as 'Round About Midnight) in 1948, though Discogs says 1947. Also the apostrophe is missing at the beginning in the way it currently shows on this site.

Magazine's track "The Light Pours Out of Me" is missing the 'the', and Björk's "Jóga" is missing the accent on the 'o'.

"All Summer Long" by the Beach Boys should be listed in 1964, when the album was released (in July).

The genre link to "turntable music" actually leads to the page for "power electronics".

"Blues for Ceausescu" by the The Fatima Mansions is spelt incorrectly as "Blues for Ceaucesco".

Clap Your Hands Say Yeah's "The Skin of My Yellow Country Teeth" is listed as "The Skin of My Country Yellow Teeth."