Page 3 of 3

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2018 9:46 am
by Honorio


Björk's "Post" (1995)

Ranking:
01 | Hyper-Ballad | 2,0 points
02 | Isobel | 3,2 points
03 | Army of Me | 4,1 points
04 | Enjoy | 5,1 points
05 | It's Oh So Quiet | 5,3 points
06 | I Miss You | 5,6 points
07 | Possibly Maybe | 5,7 points
08 | The Modern Things | 8,0 points
09 | Cover Me | 8,9 points
10 | You've Been Flirting Again | 8,9 points
11 | Headphones | 9,2 points

Link to the voting thread: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=6664

Number of voters: 14 (Mulholland, DaveC, luvulongTIM, bonnielaurel, jamieW, Listyguy, Honorio, ordinaryperson, talking, Nassim, Moonbeam, Romain, antonius, Elder)

Biggest fans (and highest position):
1 | Army of Me | Mulholland, Listyguy, ordinaryperson, Nassim, Romain | 2
2 | Hyper-Ballad | Mulholland, DaveC, jamieW, ordinaryperson, Nassim, Romain, Elder | 1
3 | The Modern Things | Nassim | 4
4 | It's Oh So Quiet | Listyguy, Honorio | 1
5 | Enjoy | talking | 1
6 | You've Been Flirting Again | Mulholland, Honorio | 6
7 | Isobel | bonnielaurel, Moonbeam, antonius | 1
8 | Possibly Maybe | antonius, Elder | 2
9 | I Miss You | luvulongTIM | 1
10 | Cover Me | jamieW | 3
11 | Headphones | talking | 2

Correlation with critics:
1 | Hyper-Ballad | 1
2 | Army of Me | 3
3 | It's Oh So Quiet | 5
4 | Isobel | 2
5 | Possibly Maybe | 7
Correlation coefficient: 0,722185381
Same song at the top but some changes, we put two non-acclaimed songs above "It's Oh So Quiet" and "Possibly Maybe."


Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2018 9:52 am
by Honorio
Some stats about participation:

130 voters participated on the game. Here you can see how many voters had every album and how many albums ranked every voter.

First the albums ranked according to the number of voters

Number of voters | Name of the album
48 | Revolver
41 | The Velvet Underground & Nico
40 | OK Computer
38 | Funeral
37 | Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
36 | The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars
35 | My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, Thriller
33 | Pet Sounds, The Beatles (White Album)
32 | London Calling
31 | Nevermind, The Queen Is Dead, Kid A, Doolittle
29 | Highway 61 Revisited
28 | What's Going On, In Rainbows
27 | Remain in Light
26 | Blonde on Blonde, Purple Rain
25 | Kind of Blue, Exile on Main St.
24 | Channel Orange, Automatic for the People, The Dark Side of the Moon
23 | Is This It, Born to Run, The Joshua Tree
22 | Grace, Sound of Silver, Marquee Moon, Led Zeppelin IV, Rubber Soul, Who's Next, Blackstar
21 | Sign 'O' the Times, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, Abbey Road, Innervisions, The Bends
20 | (What's the Story) Morning Glory? , Ten
19 | Blue Lines, Blood on the Tracks, The Stone Roses
18 | It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back, Never Mind the Bollocks Here's the Sex Pistols, Odelay, good kid m.A.A.d city, Closer, Illinois, Dummy, Astral Weeks, Beggars Banquet, Rumours
17 | Elephant, Loveless, Modern Vampires of the City, Let It Bleed
16 | Horses, Are You Experienced, The Doors, Hunky Dory
15 | Endtroducing....., Back to Black, Ramones, Daydream Nation, The College Dropout
14 | Let England Shake, Achtung Baby, Murmur, Post
13 | Elvis Presley, Rain Dogs, A Rush of Blood to the Head, Forever Changes, Graceland, Born in the U.S.A., Odessey and Oracle
12 | Appetite for Destruction, Untrue
11 | Stankonia, Here's Little Richard, To Pimp a Butterfly, Songs in the Key of Life, White Blood Cells, In Utero, Disintegration
10 | Songs for Swingin' Lovers!, The Blueprint, Electric Ladyland, Screamadelica, The Low End Theory, Whatever People Say I Am That's What I'm Not
9 | In the Wee Small Hours, Lost in the Dream, Time Out, Mingus Ah Um
8 | The Shape of Jazz to Come


And the participants ranked according to the number of albums ranked

Voter | Number of albums ranked
antonius, bonnielaurel, Honorio, jamieW, ordinaryperson | 100
bootsy | 87
Listyguy | 63
Romain | 62
DaveC | 59
whuntva | 58
EmilienDelRey | 50
andyd1010 | 49
krendler, Nassim | 48
maverick470 | 46
Live in Phoenix | 45
SJner | 42
prosecutorgodot | 40
mileswide | 38
Toni | 37
Bruno | 33
Elder | 31
Henry | 26
Moonbeam, Rocky Raccoon | 23
BleuPanda, Maschine_Man, Ulysses | 22
Nick | 21
IllumiThottie, stone37 | 19
deadpacifist, fasbjd | 18
notbrianeno | 17
sonofsamiam | 16
GucciLittlePiggy | 14
chevisan, Matski | 13
Jackson, PlasticRam | 12
Akhenaten, babydoll, Dexter, Krurze, Pierre, talking | 11
luvulongTIM | 10
CupOfDreams, FrankLotion, Gillingham | 9
Chris K. | 8
Dan, DocBrown, luney6, madzong, slick, Sunwoo1213 | 7
Araluenian, Daniel, Jonathon, StevieFan13 | 6
dumbangel, Jap123, Mulholland, Wezzo, Zombeels | 5
Harold, jimm, Miguel, Rob, Safetycat, sixfeetaboveme, TimmyWing | 4
Illiniq, Kingoftonga, Hymie, jimmyj, Sweepstakes Ron | 3
acroamor, Blanco, Clerefor Sede, Cold Butterfly, Fred, Henrik, Jeff, JohnnyBGoode, JWinton, letmeintomyzone, nedfla, ratanx, sickboy83, Smithers-Jones, starchman46, tcaporale4, woodymac, Zorg | 2
Amoux, amnt1882, Brad, ChelseaD, Craig, Depeche Mode, Duncan Thaw, essieyessie, floflo79, Georgie, jbirt92, Jirin, John, jonatan, Kimijean, Knailsic, Luke JR68, LZ, mat.bez.lima, Michel, MookieBlaylock10, Neil, nicolas, Onno Pels, Rdwdbob, Red Ant, rumpdoll, Seanywack, smhoax, Styrofoam Boots, The_Claw, The Rug Rat, tieb, VanillaFire1000 | 1


The participation (as expected) declined with time, as you can see on the following graphic




The #1s ranked:

Here they are, the #1 songs ordered by consensus, the agreement on being the best song of their respective albums (the closer the #1 song gets to 1,00 points the more consensual is):

Position | Name | Points | Number of #1 votes:

01 | I've Got You Under My Skin | 1 | 10
02 | All Along the Watchtower | 1,2 | 9
03 | Gimme Shelter | 1,235294118 | 13
04 | One | 1,428571429 | 8
05 | Life on Mars? | 1,4375 | 14
06 | Take Five | 1,444444444 | 6
07 | Alone Again Or | 1,461538462 | 10
08 | Teen Age Riot | 1,466666667 | 10
09 | Sweet Child o' Mine | 1,5 | 8
10 | Tutti Frutti | 1,545454545 | 5

11 | Like a Rolling Stone | 1,551724138 | 19
12 | Once in a Lifetime | 1,555555556 | 20
13t | Hallelujah | 1,636363636 | 13
13t | Baba O'Riley | 1,636363636 | 13
15 | Better Git It in Your Soul | 1,666666667 | 7
16 | What's Going On | 1,678571429 | 16
17 | Billie Jean | 1,685714286 | 20
18 | Born to Run | 1,695652174 | 15
19 | Lazarus | 1,727272727 | 13
20 | Anarchy in the U.K. | 1,777777778 | 10
21 | Unfinished Sympathy | 1,789473684 | 14
22 | Pyramids | 1,791666667 | 16
23 | B.O.B. | 1,818181818 | 6
24 | Heart-Shaped Box | 1,818181818 | 3
25 | So What | 1,84 | 13

26 | Tangled Up in Blue | 1,842105263 | 9
27 | Smells Like Teen Spirit | 1,870967742 | 20
28 | Time | 1,875 | 12
29 | Seven Nation Army | 1,882352941 | 12
30 | I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor | 1,9 | 6
31 | Clocks | 1,923076923 | 5
32 | Radio Free Europe | 2 | 10
33 | In My Life | 2 | 9
34 | Hyper-Ballad | 2 | 7
35 | Red Eyes | 2 | 3
36 | God Only Knows | 2,090909091 | 16
37 | Sympathy for the Devil | 2,111111111 | 11
38 | Lonely Woman | 2,125 | 5
39 | Marquee Moon | 2,136363636 | 11
40 | Fake Plastic Trees | 2,19047619 | 11
41 | Wake Up | 2,210526316 | 17
42 | In the Wee Small Hours of the Morning | 2,222222222 | 6
43 | There Is a Light That Never Goes Out | 2,225806452 | 15
44 | A Day in the Life | 2,243243243 | 23
45 | Blitzkrieg Bop | 2,266666667 | 10
46 | Debaser | 2,290322581 | 11
47 | Black | 2,3 | 5
48 | When Doves Cry | 2,307692308 | 9
49 | All My Friends | 2,318181818 | 11
50 | London Calling | 2,322580645 | 18

51 | Living for the City | 2,333333333 | 9
52 | Stairway to Heaven | 2,363636364 | 10
53 | Purple Haze | 2,375 | 3
54 | Blue Suede Shoes | 2,384615385 | 5
55 | Glory Box | 2,388888889 | 7
56 | Where the Streets Have No Name | 2,391304348 | 8
57 | Building Steam with a Grain of Salt | 2,4 | 7
58 | Back to Black | 2,4 | 6
59 | Ghost Hardware | 2,416666667 | 4
60 | Go Your Own Way | 2,444444444 | 10
61 | Bring the Noise | 2,5 | 6
62 | Chicago | 2,611111111 | 8
63 | The End | 2,625 | 6
64 | Fell in Love with a Girl | 2,636363636 | 3
65t | Where It's At | 2,666666667 | 8
65t | Jesus. etc. | 2,666666667 | 8
67 | Graceland | 2,692307692 | 3
68 | Heroin | 2,707317073 | 17
69 | Tumbling Dice | 2,72 | 6
70 | Runaway | 2,742857143 | 17
71 | Paranoid Android | 2,75 | 16
72 | Gloria: In Excelsis Deo / Gloria (Version) | 2,75 | 6
73 | Swimming Pools (Drank) | 2,777777778 | 6
74 | Scenario | 2,9 | 3
75 | Here Comes the Sun | 2,952380952 | 6

76 | Everything in Its Right Place | 3 | 10
77 | Nightswimming | 3 | 9
78 | Only Shallow | 3 | 6
79 | Unbelievers | 3 | 4
80 | Sign 'O' the Times | 3,047619048 | 7
81 | Starman | 3,055555556 | 10
82 | Sweet Thing | 3,055555556 | 6
83 | Time of the Season | 3,076923077 | 7
84 | Don't Look Back in Anger | 3,1 | 6
85 | Reckoner | 3,107142857 | 6
86 | Last Nite | 3,130434783 | 9
87 | The Words That Maketh Murder | 3,142857143 | 2
87 | Dancing in the Dark | 3,153846154 | 5
89 | Twenty Four Hours | 3,166666667 | 2
90 | Lovesong | 3,181818182 | 3
91 | Heart of the City (Ain't No Love) | 3,2 | 3
92 | Eleanor Rigby | 3,208333333 | 16
93 | Loaded | 3,3 | 2
94 | Visions of Johanna | 3,346153846 | 4
95 | Sir Duke | 3,363636364 | 4
96 | I Wanna Be Adored | 3,526315789 | 3
97 | Spaceship | 3,666666667 | 1
98 | Downtown Train | 3,692307692 | 6
99 | While My Guitar Gently Weeps | 3,757575758 | 14
100 | The Blacker the Berry | 4,545454545 | 4


And now only selecting the upper half of the albums (the ones with more voters):

01 | Like a Rolling Stone | 1,551724138 | 19
02 | Once in a Lifetime | 1,555555556 | 20
03t | Hallelujah | 1,636363636 | 13
03t | Baba O'Riley | 1,636363636 | 13
05 | What's Going On | 1,678571429 | 16
06 | Billie Jean | 1,685714286 | 20
07 | Born to Run | 1,695652174 | 15
08 | Lazarus | 1,727272727 | 13
09 | Anarchy in the U.K. | 1,777777778 | 10
10 | Unfinished Sympathy | 1,789473684 | 14

11 | Pyramids | 1,791666667 | 16
12 | So What | 1,84 | 13
13 | Tangled Up in Blue | 1,842105263 | 9
14 | Smells Like Teen Spirit | 1,870967742 | 20
15 | Time | 1,875 | 12
16 | In My Life | 2 | 9
17 | God Only Knows | 2,090909091 | 16
18 | Sympathy for the Devil | 2,111111111 | 11
19 | Marquee Moon | 2,136363636 | 11
20 | Fake Plastic Trees | 2,19047619 | 11
21 | Wake Up | 2,210526316 | 17
22 | There Is a Light That Never Goes Out | 2,225806452 | 15
23 | A Day in the Life | 2,243243243 | 23
24 | Debaser | 2,290322581 | 11
25 | Black | 2,3 | 5

26 | When Doves Cry | 2,307692308 | 9
27 | All My Friends | 2,318181818 | 11
28 | Living for the City | 2,333333333 | 9
29 | Stairway to Heaven | 2,363636364 | 10
30 | Glory Box | 2,388888889 | 7
31 | Where the Streets Have No Name | 2,391304348 | 8
32 | Go Your Own Way | 2,444444444 | 10
33 | Bring the Noise | 2,5 | 6
34 | Chicago | 2,611111111 | 8
35t | Where It's At | 2,666666667 | 8
35t| Jesus. etc. | 2,666666667 | 8
37 | Heroin | 2,707317073 | 17
38 | London Calling | 2,71875 | 18
39 | Tumbling Dice | 2,72 | 6
40 | Runaway | 2,742857143 | 17
41 | Paranoid Android | 2,75 | 16
42 | Swimming Pools (Drank) | 2,777777778 | 6
43 | Here Comes the Sun | 2,952380952 | 6
44 | Everything in Its Right Place | 3 | 10
45 | Nightswimming | 3 | 9
46 | Sign 'O' the Times | 3,047619048 | 7
47 | Starman | 3,055555556 | 10
48 | Sweet Thing | 3,055555556 | 6
49 | Don't Look Back in Anger | 3,1 | 6
50 | Reckoner | 3,107142857 | 6


Correlation with critics

Comparing our lists with the critics' ones, on 29 albums we selected a different song as the best of the album. On the other hand on 8 albums we selected the same songs on the same order.

Non-coincidence at the top:
1. Revolver
2. Funeral
3. Kid A
4. The Velvet Underground & Nico
5. Elvis Presley
6. Automatic for the People
7. The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars
8. The Joshua Tree
9. Closer
10. The Dark Side of the Moon
11. Astral Weeks
12. Endtroducing.....
13. Stankonia
14. Modern Vampires of the City
15. Abbey Road
16. The Stone Roses
17. The Blueprint
18. Back to Black
19. The Doors
20. (What's the Story) Morning Glory?
21. Untrue
22. Who's Next
23. The College Dropout
24. To Pimp a Butterfly
25. Mingus Ah Um
26. Ten
27. Born in the U.S.A.
28. In Utero
29. Disintegration

Exact correlation:
1. What's Going On
2. Songs for Swingin' Lovers!
3. Electric Ladyland
4. Time Out
5. Murmur
6. The Low End Theory
7. Graceland
8. The Shape of Jazz to Come

The Excel files

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Apr 01, 2018 8:47 am
by Honorio
Fantastic first week after the last!
8 albums updated thanks to bonnielaurel (6) and Mulholland (2)
- Automatic for the People
- Odelay
- Loveless
- Grace
- Let England Shake
- Back to Black
- Murmur
- The Bends
I've decided to keep this thread on the main subforum, at least while people still keep ranking.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2018 7:49 am
by Honorio
Only one album ranked this week, "Illinois."

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Apr 15, 2018 8:00 am
by Honorio
5 albums updated this week thanks to Nassim, prosecutorgodot, Mulholland and talking:
- The Shape of Jazz to Come
- Marquee Moon
- Thriller
- Disintegration
- Post
Now "Lost in the Dream" is alone at the bottom as the album less ranked.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Apr 22, 2018 7:51 am
by Honorio
4 albums ranked this week, all of them by bonnielaurel that is now at #7 of voters with more albums ranked and getting closer to the Top 5:
- Elvis Presley (with a change on the #1 song!)
- Remain in Light
- In the Wee Small Hours
- Lost in the Dream (that again is not alone at the bottom)

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Apr 22, 2018 12:58 pm
by bonnielaurel
Honorio, I see you only have ninety-eight albums ranked. Which two are missing?

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Apr 22, 2018 6:25 pm
by Honorio
"The Low End Theory" and "Ten." Sooner or later I'll get to rank them. During the following weeks hopefully.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Apr 29, 2018 7:14 am
by Honorio
Two albums ranked this week thanks to Nassim:
- Ten
- Post

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun May 06, 2018 8:04 am
by Honorio
Five albums updated thanks to 5 different voters, bonnielaurel, DaveC (that enters the Top 5), Nassim, SJner and myself:
- Here's Little Richard
- The Low End Theory
- Forever Changes
- In Utero
- Disintegration

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun May 13, 2018 8:03 am
by Honorio
Two new albums updated this week thanks to bonnielaurel and FrankLotion, a newcomer:
- Channel Orange
- Never Mind the Bollocks, Here's the Sex Pistols

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun May 20, 2018 8:11 am
by Honorio
Fantastic week with no less than 15 albums updated thanks to bonnilaurel and DaveC but mainly to Moonbeam who made the truly Herculean task of ranking 13 albums on a single day. Thank you very much Moonbeam and welcome back!
The albums updated were:
- Exile on Main St.
- The Queen Is Dead
- OK Computer
- The Velvet Underground & Nico
- Is This It
- Automatic for the People
- Illinois
- Marquee Moon
- The Doors
- Ramones
- Songs in the Key of Life
- Blackstar
- Hunky Dory
- Disintegration
- Post
As a result of the update "Sir Duke" is now last, the #1 song on the album with less total points.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun May 27, 2018 7:55 am
by Honorio
And another fantastic week with 8 albums updated thanks to bonnielaurel, fasbjd, SJner and me. But mainly thanks to Romain that was (almost) this week's Moonbeam and ranked 6 albums in a row. The albums updated were:
- Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
- Time Out
- Daydream Nation
- Ten
- Odessey and Oracle
- Hunky Dory
- Disintegration
- Post
And if last week we had a change on the last position this week we have a new song on the first position (of the #1s ranking). "Life on Mars?" is now first as the song at #1 on everyone's ballot on "Hunky Dory" with a total of 9.
And two changes on albums' #1s:
- "Black" is now the #1 song of "Ten" instead of "Jeremy."
- "Lovesong" is now the #1 song of "Disintegration" instead of "Pictures of You."

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun May 27, 2018 1:34 pm
by bonnielaurel
And finally Honorio joins the 100 club.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun May 27, 2018 7:18 pm
by Honorio
Yes, bonnie! Now I belong to the select 100 Club in the splendid company of jamieW and ordinaryperson. But this is not an exclusive club, everyone's invited! You only need to rank the remaining albums. If someone is interested to join us I could send him/her by PM the albums you need to rank…

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Mon May 28, 2018 7:47 am
by Romain
Honorio wrote:Yes, bonnie! Now I belong to the select 100 Club in the splendid company of jamieW and ordinaryperson. But this is not an exclusive club, everyone's invited! You only need to rank the remaining albums. If someone is interested to join us I could send him/her by PM the albums you need to rank…
With pleasure dear Honorio, it will be helpfull. :greetings-waveyellow:

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jun 03, 2018 7:26 am
by Honorio
And a third fantastic week in a row with 11 albums ranked thanks to bonnielaurel (2), fasbjd (3), talking (3), Romain (3) and SJner (1). The albums updated were:
- It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back
- Kid A
- Doolittle
- Endtroducing.....
- Here's Little Richard
- Appetite for Destruction
- Who's Next
- The Bends
- Forever Changes
- Songs in the Key of Life
- Disintegration

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jun 10, 2018 7:55 am
by Honorio
And a fourth very good week with 9 albums updated thanks to bonnielaurel (5), fasbjd (6) and SJner (1). The albums updated were:
- My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
- Exile on Main St.
- Kid A
- Thriller
- Ramones
- Who's Next
- To Pimp a Butterfly
- The Bends
- Forever Changes
Two changes on the stats:
- Now bonnielaurel is tied at the 4th position with Listyguy as the voter with more albums ranked.
- Now "The Blacker the Berry" is tied with "Downtown Train" on the last position as the #1 song on the album with less total points.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jun 17, 2018 6:32 am
by Honorio
And another excellent week with 11 albums updated thanks to bonnielaurel (5), fasbjd (5) and SJner (1). The albums updated were:
- My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
- Blue Lines
- Never Mind the Bollocks Here's the Sex Pistols
- Remain in Light
- Elephant
- Horses
- Modern Vampires of the City
- Electric Ladyland
- The Doors
- Let It Bleed
- Beggars Banquet
Changes:
- Now bonnielaurel is #4 without ties.
- "Like a Rolling Stone" is now over "Once in a Lifetime" as the #1 with more points on the Top 50 albums.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Mon Jun 25, 2018 5:38 pm
by Honorio
A long week (with almost two extra days, I was out on the weekend) with 13 albums updated (almost equaling the "Moonbeam week") thanks to bonnielaurel (8), Romain (4) and SJner (1). The albums updated were:
- Blonde on Blonde
- good kid, m.A.A.d city
- In Rainbows
- Closer
- Are You Experienced
- Stankonia
- The Stone Roses
- The Blueprint
- Screamadelica
- Untrue
- The College Dropout
- White Blood Cells
- Rumours

With no less than three changes of #1s:
- "Loaded" replaced "Moving on Up" on "Screamadelica," now we agreed with the critics.
- "Spaceship" replaced "Jesus Walks" on "The College Dropout," being the only case on the whole game of a non acclaimed song getting the hot spot.
- "Go Your Own Way" replaced "The Chain" on "Rumours," agreeing with the critics.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jul 01, 2018 11:18 am
by Honorio
9 albums updated this week thanks to antonius (5) and bonnielaurel (4):
- Nevermind
- Never Mind the Bollocks Here's the Sex Pistols
- Are You Experienced
- The Dark Side of the Moon
- Endtroducing.....
- Abbey Road
- Ramones
- Blackstar
- Rumours

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2018 10:46 am
by Honorio
9 albums updated this week thanks to bonnielaurel (6), Romain (2) and SJner (1). Hey, bonnielaurel, you're going up like a rocket straight to the 100 Club! Only 14 albums left!
The albums updated this week were:
- Funeral
- Channel Orange
- Sound of Silver
- Astral Weeks
- Blood on the Tracks
- Stankonia
- Marquee Moon
- Daydream Nation
- Blackstar

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jul 15, 2018 9:01 am
by Honorio
11 albums updated this week thanks to bonnielaurel (10!) and DaveC (1). Hey, bonnielaurel, only four albums remaining to get into the 100 Club!
The albums updated this week were:
- Pet Sounds
- The Queen Is Dead
- London Calling
- Is This It
- Sign 'O' the Times
- In Rainbows
- Let England Shake
- Doolittle
- Endtroducing.....
- (What's the Story) Morning Glory?
- The Low End Theory
With a change on a #1, "Check the Rhime" replaces "Scenario" at the top of "The Low End Theory."

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2018 9:29 am
by Honorio
Only 3 albums updated this week (plus a delayed update on "White Blood Cells") but enough to have bonnielaurel in the 100 Club! Welcome!!!
The albums updated were:
- The Velvet Underground & Nico
- The Beatles (White Album)
- Marquee Moon

Moreover we have some minor changes on the correlations with the critics due to the last update. The changes appear on the following albums:
- In Rainbows
- Astral Weeks
- Born in the USA
- Whatever People Say I Am ,That's What I'm Not
- Odessey and Oracle

And after that I think that from now on I will update the results, depending of what happens first, either a) the first Sunday of every month or b) the first Sunday after an update of more than 10 albums.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jul 22, 2018 1:08 pm
by bonnielaurel
Thanks, Honorio for keeping track of the rankings. I'm glad I got through them all.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Aug 26, 2018 5:27 pm
by Honorio
First Sunday after more than 10 albums ranked so here I go...
14 albums updated this month thanks to antonius (9!), SJner (3), Romain and woodymac. Impressive catch-up, antonius! Hey, antonius, it's a long way to the top if you wanna rock'n'roll but we are waiting here (if you want to).
The albums updated were:
- Revolver
- Kind of Blue
- The Velvet Underground & Nico
- Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
- Blonde on Blonde
- Highway 61 Revisited
- Doolittle
- Purple Rain
- Modern Vampires of the City
- Mingus Ah Um
- Rain Dogs
- Graceland
- Born in the U.S.A.
- Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not
As a result of the update, two changes:
- "Unbelievers" takes up the #1 position on "Modern Vampires of the City"
- Tom Waits' "Downtown Train" regains the dubious honour of being the #1 song with less total points.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Sep 02, 2018 11:01 am
by Honorio
Wow, impressive turnout this week! If on the last update we needed 5 weeks to have 14 albums updated on the following 7 days we had no less than 18 albums updated (3 of them twice), a new record after the official "end" of the game, thanks to CupOfDreams (8), antonius (5), Elder (5), FrankLotion (2) and SJner (2). The albums updated were:
- What's Going On
- Kind of Blue (2)
- The Queen Is Dead
- London Calling
- Born to Run
- The Joshua Tree
- Closer
- Songs for Swingin' Lovers!
- Doolittle
- Dummy (2)
- Marquee Moon
- Led Zeppelin IV
- Back to Black
- Ramones (2)
- Untrue
- Murmur
- Mingus Ah Um
- A Rush of Blood to the Head
We had a change on a #1 song, "Twenty Four Hours" replaced "Decades" at the top of "Closer" being the first case (of two, the other is "Spaceship" on "The College Dropout") of a non-acclaimed song getting the top spot.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Sep 16, 2018 6:34 am
by Honorio
16 albums updated in two weeks thanks to Elder (9), antonius (4), SJner (2) and FrankLotion. The albums updated were:
- Funeral
- My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
- The Queen Is Dead
- OK Computer
- The Velvet Underground & Nico
- Channel Orange
- Odelay
- Loveless
- The Beatles (White Album)
- Grace
- The Dark Side of the Moon
- Astral Weeks
- Endtroducing.....
- Achtung Baby
- Innervisions
- The Shape of Jazz to Come
And we had a change on a number 1, we replaced "Madame George" by a "Sweet Thing" at the top of "Astral Weeks."
And "Lost in the Dream" regains its position as the album with less rankings with only 6.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Oct 07, 2018 8:07 am
by Honorio
The first Sunday of October and more than 10 albums updated. The two criteria met today so here I go… 12 albums updated in 3 weeks thanks to antonius (4), FrankLotion (4), Elder (3) and SJner (2). The albums updated were:
- Pet Sounds
- Elvis Presley
- Automatic for the People (2)
- In the Wee Small Hours
- Horses
- Grace
- Illinois
- The Dark Side of the Moon
- Screamadelica
- Lost in the Dream
- Rubber Soul
- In Utero
And a change of a number one, "Under the Pressure" overtook "An Ocean in Between the Waves" in "Lost in the Dream."

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2018 11:27 am
by Honorio
16 albums updated in 3 weeks thanks to antonius (6), bootsy (4), Krurze (3), Elder (2), fasbjd, FrankLotion and SJner. Hey, antonius, you are already among the Top 10 voters! The albums updated were:
- Funeral
- Pet Sounds
- Channel Orange
- Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
- Remain in Light
- Elephant
- The Stone Roses
- Electric Ladyland
- Back to Black
- Time Out
- The Doors (2)
- The College Dropout
- Ten
- Odessey and Oracle
- Hunky Dory (2)
- Post

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2018 10:34 am
by Honorio
14 albums updated in only one week thanks to Akhenaten (4), Toni (4), antonius (3), bootsy (2) and Elder, with antonius and bootsy almost getting to the Top 5 of voters. The albums updated were:
- Nevermind
- Funeral
- London Calling
- Thriller
- good kid, m.A.A.d city
- The Beatles (White Album)
- Sound of Silver
- Appetite for Destruction
- Murmur
- Innervisions
- Songs in the Key of Life
- Blackstar
- Hunky Dory
- Disintegration

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Nov 18, 2018 11:39 am
by Honorio
19 albums updated in two weeks thanks to Akhenaten (6), bootsy (5), antonius (4), Elder (4) and PlasticRam. The albums updated were:
- It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back
- Funeral
- Kid A
- Is This It
- Never Mind the Bollocks Here's the Sex Pistols
- In Rainbows
- Illinois
- Let England Shake
- Songs for Swingin' Lovers!
- Purple Rain (2)
- Here's Little Richard
- The Stone Roses
- Who's Next
- The Low End Theory
- To Pimp a Butterfly
- Rain Dogs
- Graceland
- Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not
- Post

And we had change on a #1, "Scenario" regained the top position on "The Low End Theory," displacing "Check the Rhime."

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2018 10:50 am
by Honorio
13 albums updated in two weeks thanks to Elder (3), Toni (3), antonius (2), bootsy (2), SJner (2), Akhenaten and Illiniq. Now we have antonius and bootsy on #5 and #6 positions of the voters with more albums ranked. The albums updated were:
- OK Computer
- The Velvet Underground & Nico (2)
- Astral Weeks
- Modern Vampires of the City
- Appetite for Destruction
- Back to Black
- Lost in the Dream
- To Pimp a Butterfly
- The Bends
- Forever Changes
- Graceland
- Born in the U.S.A.
- Odessey and Oracle

After the update "The Blacker the Berry" goes to the bottom of the #1s as the #1 with less total points.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2019 11:31 am
by Honorio
14 albums updated in five weeks thanks to antonius (5), bootsy (3), Jap123 (3), CupOfDreams, SJner and Toni. The albums updated were:
- What's Going On
- Exile on Main St.
- Blonde on Blonde
- Highway 61 Revisited
- Sound of Silver
- Stankonia
- The Blueprint
- (What's the Story) Morning Glory?
- Untrue
- Who's Next
- Let It Bleed
- Rain Dogs
- White Blood Cells
- Beggars Banquet

After the update there are two changes of #1, "Wonderwall" get tied on top with "Don't Look Back in Anger" (but with more #1 votes) on "(What's the Story) Morning Glory" and "Dead Leaves and the Dirty Ground" replaces "Fell in Love with a a Girl" at the top of "White Blood Cells."
From now on I will update the results the first Sunday of every month.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Feb 03, 2019 10:41 am
by Honorio
7 albums updated in four weeks thanks to antonius (3), Jap123 (2), SJner and Toni. The albums updated were:
- London Calling
- Doolittle
- Blood on the Tracks
- Daydream Nation
- Let It Bleed
- Beggars Banquet
- Rumours

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Feb 03, 2019 10:31 pm
by Jap123
Sorry if this is a stupid question or one which has been clearly answered somewhere but are there any plans to expand the number of albums in Rank the Tracks or is it likely to stay as it is for the time being?

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Mon Feb 04, 2019 4:57 pm
by Honorio
Oh, no, Jap123, I'm sorry but I don't want to include more albums, especially right now when the participation has declined so much. On the second post on this same page you can see how the participation declined after the first half. Then people suggested some albums to rank but none of the albums included following these suggestions increased the participation significantly (see this thread). After 75 albums I even did a poll and we used the remaining spots with the albums from our last albums poll instead albums from the official AM list, with a barely detectable increase on the participation. So I'm really sorry but no...

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Mar 03, 2019 10:43 am
by Honorio
9 albums updated in four weeks thanks to Elder (3), antonius (2), IllumiThottie (2), SJner (2) and bootsy. The albums updated were:
- The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars
- Highway 61 Revisited
- Closer (2)
- Grace
- Lost in the Dream
- Daydream Nation
- Rubber Soul
- Mingus Ah Um
- Blackstar

As a result of the update we had a change on a #1, with "Red Eyes" replacing "Under the Pressure" at the top of "Lost in the Dream." With this album we initially had an inverse correlation with the critics (with even the first case of a negative correlation) we finally ended with the same Top 3.

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Apr 07, 2019 8:37 am
by Honorio
9 albums updated in five weeks thanks to antonius (4), Cold Butterfly (2), starchman46 (2), Illiniq, SJner and whuntva. The albums updated were:
- My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
- Pet Sounds
- The Queen Is Dead (2)
- Highway 61 Revisited
- Are You Experienced
- Endtroducing.....
- Screamadelica
- To Pimp a Butterfly
- Forever Changes
- Ten

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun May 05, 2019 8:52 am
by Honorio
The best month on 2019. 21 albums updated in four weeks thanks mainly to bootsy (13) but also to antonius (4), Clerefor Sede (2), Elder, Safetycat and SJner. Hey, bootsy, you're getting closer to have all the albums ranked!
The albums updated were:
- Pet Sounds
- Exile on Main St.
- Channel Orange
- Elephant
- good kid, m.A.A.d city
- The Joshua Tree
- The Beatles (White Album)
- Closer
- Are You Experienced
- Abbey Road
- Electric Ladyland
- Led Zeppelin IV
- The College Dropout
- Let It Bleed
- Innervisions
- Rain Dogs
- Forever Changes
- Beggars Banquet (2)
- Born in the U.S.A.
- In Utero
- Hunky Dory

As a result of the update we have a change on a #1, "Jesus Walks" regains the #1 position on "The College Dropout," displacing "Spaceship."

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jun 02, 2019 6:37 am
by Honorio
15 albums updated in four weeks thanks to antonius (6), bootsy (6), mileswide (2), Safetycat (2) and Toni. The albums updated were:
- Revolver
- Funeral (2)
- Pet Sounds
- Is This It
- The Joshua Tree
- In Rainbows
- Illinois
- Songs for Swingin' Lovers!
- Purple Rain
- Appetite for Destruction
- Ramones
- Rubber Soul
- Murmur (2)
- The Bends
- Songs in the Key of Life

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2019 10:01 am
by Honorio
14 albums updated in five weeks thanks to antonius (6), Wezzo (5), Safetycat, SJner and talking. The albums updated were:
- Nevermind
- My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
- OK Computer
- Kid A
- Automatic for the People
- Born to Run
- In Rainbows
- Let England Shake
- Led Zeppelin IV
- Untrue
- Murmur
- The Low End Theory
- White Blood Cells
- Born in the U.S.A.
As a result of the update we have a change on a #1, "Fell in Love with a Girl" regains the top position on "White Blood Cells."

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jul 28, 2019 10:52 am
by Honorio
Wow, what a month for Rank the Tracks! mileswide entered like a tornado, firmly decided to ruin my holidays (only joking, I'm delighted to see Rank the Tracks going up again ) and we had 36 albums in only three weeks. In fact I usually update the results the first Sunday of the month but: a) tomorrow I'm leaving for a holiday trip and b) I'm afraid mileswide could rank 20 more albums in a week (joking again).
So, 36 albums updated in only three weeks thanks to mileswide (34), antonius (4) and Toni (2). And antonius joined the 100Club being the fifth user that ranked each and every one of the 100 albums. Even if mileswide almost won him in less than a month (joking again).
The albums updated were:
- Revolver
- Kind of Blue
- Pet Sounds
- The Queen Is Dead
- London Calling
- Thriller
- Blue Lines
- Is This It
- Elvis Presley
- Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
- Never Mind the Bollocks Here's the Sex Pistols
- Sign 'O' the Times
- Automatic for the People
- Blonde on Blonde
- Odelay
- Elephant
- In the Wee Small Hours
- Closer
- Dummy
- Astral Weeks (2)
- Blood on the Tracks
- Marquee Moon
- The Stone Roses
- The Blueprint
- Led Zeppelin IV
- Back to Black
- Ramones
- (What's the Story) Morning Glory? (2)
- The College Dropout
- Innervisions
- A Rush of Blood to the Head
- Ten
- Blackstar
- The Shape of Jazz to Come
- Beggars Banquet
- Hunky Dory (2)

As a result of the update we had three changes on number ones:
- "Where It's At" regained the top position on "Odelay" displacing "Devils Haircut."
- "Don't Look back in Anger" displaced "Wonderwall" that fell to the third position.
- And "Spaceship" displaced again "Jesus Walks" on "The College Dropout."
Moreover lots of changes on the comparative positions on the #1 of every album (see here) since mileswide knocked down every #1 almost invariably (please don't take it as a complain, I was joking again, I'm perfectly fine with whatever option you choose). The most significant change was "Life on Mars?" that lost its throne to "I've Got You Under My Skin."

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Jul 28, 2019 2:01 pm
by mileswide
Ouch! I don't know if I can feel my ears burning or my face blushing :mrgreen:

I am admittedly trying to listen to or re-visit as many of the 100 as I can before next year's all-time poll but I'll latch on to the Moderately Acclaimed thread and similar at least until you're back on terra firma!

And about the change in order, what can I say, there's a contrarian streak in me, delighting in kicking over musical statues- particularly glad in my role in sending Where It's At to the top of Odelay's ranks :happy-partydance:

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Posted: Sun Sep 01, 2019 11:34 am
by Honorio
The calm after the storm. Last update we had 36 albums in 3 weeks, this time only 9 albums in 5 weeks thanks to jimm (4), Toni (3) and mileswide (2). The albums updated were:
- Revolver
- Blue Lines
- Let England Shake
- Blood on the Tracks
- Modern Vampires of the City
- Back to Black
- Untrue
- Graceland
- Hunky Dory
As a result of the update we had a change at the top of "Untrue," we chased a "Ghost" instead an "Archangel."