Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun Mar 25, 2018 9:46 am



Björk's "Post" (1995)

Ranking:
01 | Hyper-Ballad | 1,8 points
02 | Isobel | 3,1 points
03 | Army of Me | 3,9 points
04 | Enjoy | 4,9 points
05 | I Miss You | 5,1 points
06 | It's Oh So Quiet | 5,9 points
07 | Possibly Maybe | 6,5 points
08 | The Modern Things | 8,3 points
09 | Cover Me | 8,7 points | +2
10 | You've Been Flirting Again | 8,8 points
11 | Headphones | 9,0 points | -2

Link to the voting thread: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=6664

Number of voters: 11 (Mulholland, DaveC, luvulongTIM, bonnielaurel, jamieW, Listyguy, Honorio, ordinaryperson, talking, Nassim, Moonbeam)

Biggest fans (and highest position):
1 | Army of Me | Mulholland, Listyguy, ordinaryperson, Nassim | 2
2 | Hyper-Ballad | Mulholland, DaveC, jamieW, ordinaryperson, Nassim | 1
3 | The Modern Things | Nassim | 4
4 | It's Oh So Quiet | Listyguy, Honorio | 1
5 | Enjoy | talking | 1
6 | You've Been Flirting Again | Mulholland, Honorio | 6
7 | Isobel | bonnielaurel, Moonbeam | 1
8 | Possibly Maybe | DaveC | 3
9 | I Miss You | luvulongTIM | 1
10 | Cover Me | jamieW | 3
11 | Headphones | talking | 2

Correlation with critics:
1 | Hyper-Ballad | 1
2 | Army of Me | 3
3 | It's Oh So Quiet | 6
4 | Isobel | 2
5 | Possibly Maybe | 7
Correlation coefficient: 0,671931944
Same song at the top but some changes, we put two non-acclaimed songs above "It's Oh So Quiet" and "Possibly Maybe."


User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun Mar 25, 2018 9:52 am

Some stats about participation:

118 voters participated on the game. Here you can see how many voters had every album and how many albums ranked every voter.

Number of voters | Name of the album
44 | Revolver
37 | OK Computer
35 | The Velvet Underground & Nico, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
33 | The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars
32 | Thriller
31 | Funeral
30 | My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
29 | The Beatles (White Album)
28 | Nevermind
27 | London Calling
26 | What's Going On, Pet Sounds, Kid A, Doolittle
25 | The Queen Is Dead, Remain in Light, Highway 61 Revisited
23 | In Rainbows
22 | Exile on Main St., Blonde on Blonde, Purple Rain
21 | Kind of Blue, Born to Run
20 | Channel Orange, Automatic for the People, The Joshua Tree, The Dark Side of the Moon
19 | Is This It, Sign 'O' the Times, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, Grace, Sound of Silver, Abbey Road, Rubber Soul
18 | Marquee Moon, Led Zeppelin IV
17 | Who's Next, Innervisions, The Bends, Blackstar
16 | Blue Lines, Odelay, Loveless, The Stone Roses, (What's the Story) Morning Glory?
15 | It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back, good kid m.A.A.d city, Illinois, Dummy, Blood on the Tracks, Ten, Rumours
14 | Never Mind the Bollocks Here's the Sex Pistols, Horses
13 | Elephant, Astral Weeks, Modern Vampires of the City, Achtung Baby, The Doors, Let It Bleed
12 | Closer, Are You Experienced, Beggars Banquet
11 | Elvis Presley, Daydream Nation, The College Dropout, A Rush of Blood to the Head, Post
10 | Let England Shake, Endtroducing....., Back to Black, Odessey and Oracle
9 | Ramones, Murmur, Rain Dogs, Graceland, Born in the U.S.A. , In Utero
8 | Stankonia, Here's Little Richard, Songs in the Key of Life, Whatever People Say I Am That's What I'm Not, Disintegration
7 | In the Wee Small Hours, Songs for Swingin' Lovers!, The Blueprint, Electric Ladyland, Appetite for Destruction, Screamadelica, Time Out, Untrue, The Low End Theory, To Pimp a Butterfly, Forever Changes, White Blood Cells, Hunky Dory
6 | Lost in the Dream, Mingus Ah Um, The Shape of Jazz to Come


And the participants ranked according to the number of albums ranked

Voter | Number of albums ranked
jamieW, ordinaryperson | 100
Honorio | 99
Listyguy | 63
DaveC | 58
whuntva | 57
bonnielaurel | 55
bootsy | 51
EmilienDelRey | 50
andyd1010 | 49
krendler, Nassim | 48
maverick470 | 46
Live in Phoenix, Romain | 45
prosecutorgodot | 40
Bruno | 33
Henry | 26
antonius, Moonbeam, Rocky Raccoon | 23
BleuPanda, Maschine_Man, Toni, Ulysses | 22
Nick | 21
stone37 | 19
deadpacifist | 18
IllumiThottie, notbrianeno, SJner | 17
sonofsamiam | 16
GucciLittlePiggy | 14
chevisan, Matski | 13
Jackson | 12
babydoll, Dexter, Pierre, PlasticRam | 11
luvulongTIM | 10
Gillingham | 9
Chris K., Krurze | 8
Dan, DocBrown, luney6, madzong, slick, Sunwoo1213, talking | 7
Araluenian, Daniel, Jonathon, StevieFan13 | 6
dumbangel, Mulholland, Zombeels | 5
Harold, Miguel, Rob, sixfeetaboveme, TimmyWing | 4
Kingoftonga, Hymie, jimmyj, Sweepstakes Ron | 3
acroamor, Blanco, Fred, Henrik, Jeff, JohnnyBGoode, JWinton, letmeintomyzone, nedfla, ratanx, sickboy83, Smithers-Jones, tcaporale4, Zorg | 2
Amoux, amnt1882, Brad, ChelseaD, Craig, Depeche Mode, Duncan Thaw, essieyessie, floflo79, FrankLotion, Georgie, Illiniq, jbirt92, Jirin, John, jonatan, Kimijean, Knailsic, Luke JR68, LZ, mat.bez.lima, Michel, MookieBlaylock10, Neil, nicolas, Onno Pels, Rdwdbob, Red Ant, rumpdoll, Seanywack, smhoax, Styrofoam Boots, The_Claw, The Rug Rat, tieb, VanillaFire1000, woodymac | 1

The participation (as expected) declined with time, as you can see on the following graphic

Image


The #1s ranked:

Here they are, the #1 songs ordered by consensus, the agreement on being the best song of their respective albums (the closer the #1 song gets to 1,00 points the more consensual is):

Position | Name | Points | Number of #1 votes:

01t | I've Got You Under My Skin | 1 | 7
01t | Sweet Child o' Mine | 1 | 7
01t | Life on Mars? | 1 | 7
04 | Radio Free Europe | 1,111111111 | 8
05 | All Along the Watchtower | 1,285714286 | 6
06 | Gimme Shelter | 1,307692308 | 9
07 | Teen Age Riot | 1,363636364 | 8
08 | One | 1,384615385 | 8
09 | Once in a Lifetime | 1,48 | 19
10t | B.O.B. | 1,5 | 5
10t | Take Five | 1,5 | 5

12 | Like a Rolling Stone | 1,56 | 17
13 | Tutti Frutti | 1,571428571 | 3
14 | Baba O'Riley | 1,588235294 | 10
15 | Seven Nation Army | 1,615384615 | 10
16 | So What | 1,619047619 | 13
17 | Billie Jean | 1,65625 | 19
18 | Born to Run | 1,666666667 | 14
19 | Hallelujah | 1,684210526 | 11
20 | Unfinished Sympathy | 1,6875 | 12
21 | What's Going On | 1,692307692 | 15
22 | Pyramids | 1,7 | 14
23 | Fake Plastic Trees | 1,705882353 | 11
24 | Clocks | 1,727272727 | 5
25 | Heart-Shaped Box | 1,777777778 | 3

26 | Anarchy in the U.K. | 1,785714286 | 8
27 | Hyper-Ballad | 1,818181818 | 5
28 | An Ocean in Between the Waves | 1,833333333 | 3
29 | All My Friends | 1,842105263 | 11
30 | In the Wee Small Hours of the Morning | 1,857142857 | 5
31t | Archangel | 1,857142857 | 4
31t | Alone Again Or | 1,857142857 | 4
33 | I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor | 1,875 | 5
34 | Lazarus | 1,882352941 | 9
35 | Building Steam with a Grain of Salt | 1,9 | 5
36 | God Only Knows | 1,923076923 | 13
37 | Smells Like Teen Spirit | 1,928571429 | 18
38 | Tangled Up in Blue | 1,933333333 | 7
39 | Time | 2 | 9
40 | Blitzkrieg Bop | 2 | 7
41 | Back to Black | 2 | 6
42 | Better Git It in Your Soul | 2 | 4
43 | Graceland | 2 | 3
44 | In My Life | 2,105263158 | 7
45 | Debaser | 2,115384615 | 10
46 | There Is a Light That Never Goes Out | 2,12 | 13
47 | Fell in Love with a Girl | 2,142857143 | 3
48 | Lonely Woman | 2,166666667 | 4
49 | Chicago | 2,2 | 7
50 | Jeremy | 2,2 | 6

51 | London Calling | 2,222222222 | 16
52 | Marquee Moon | 2,277777778 | 9
53 | Blue Suede Shoes | 2,272727273 | 4
54 | Wake Up | 2,290322581 | 12
55 | Where the Streets Have No Name | 2,3 | 8
56 | A Day in the Life | 2,314285714 | 21
57 | When Doves Cry | 2,318181818 | 8
58 | Stairway to Heaven | 2,333333333 | 8
59 | Sympathy for the Devil | 2,333333333 | 7
60 | Dancing in the Dark | 2,333333333 | 4
61 | The End | 2,384615385 | 6
62 | Purple Haze | 2,416666667 | 2
63 | Runaway | 2,5 | 16
64 | Bring the Noise | 2,533333333 | 4
65 | Devils Haircut | 2,5625 | 8
66 | Living for the City | 2,588235294 | 6
67 | The Chain | 2,6 | 6
68 | Gloria: In Excelsis Deo / Gloria (Version) | 2,642857143 | 5
69 | Glory Box | 2,666666667 | 4
70 | Heroin | 2,714285714 | 14
71 | Jesus. etc. | 2,789473684 | 7
72 | Scenario | 2,714285714 | 3
73 | The Words That Maketh Murder | 2,8 | 1
74 | Tumbling Dice | 2,818181818 | 6
75 | Paranoid Android | 2,837837838 | 14

76 | Visions of Johanna | 2,863636364 | 4
77 | Last Nite | 2,894736842 | 8
78 | Starman | 2,909090909 | 10
79 | Reckoner | 2,956521739 | 5
80t | Jesus Walks | 3 | 5
80t | Time of the Season | 3 | 5
82 | Swimming Pools (Drank) | 3 | 4
83 | Diane Young | 3 | 3
84 | Madame George | 3 | 1
85 | Here Comes the Sun | 3,052631579 | 6
86 | Only Shallow | 3,0625 | 6
87 | Everything in Its Right Place | 3,076923077 | 9
88 | Don't Look Back in Anger | 3,125 | 5
89 | Eleanor Rigby | 3,136363636 | 14
90 | Heart of the City (Ain't No Love) | 3,142857143 | 2
91 | Nightswimming | 3,15 | 7
92 | Decades | 3,166666667 | 5
93 | Sign 'O' the Times | 3,263157895 | 5
94 | While My Guitar Gently Weeps | 3,344827586 | 13
95 | Movin' On Up | 3,428571429 | 1
96 | Pictures of You | 3,5 | 2
97 | The Blacker the Berry | 3,714285714 | 4
98 | I Wanna Be Adored | 3,733333333 | 2
99 | Downtown Train | 4 | 4
100 | Sir Duke | 4 | 3


And now only selecting the upper half of the albums (the ones with more voters):

01 | Once in a Lifetime | 1,48 | 19
02 | Like a Rolling Stone | 1,56 | 17
03 | Baba O'Riley | 1,588235294 | 10
04 | So What | 1,619047619 | 13
05 | Billie Jean | 1,65625 | 19
06 | Born to Run | 1,666666667 | 14
07 | Hallelujah | 1,684210526 | 11
08 | Unfinished Sympathy | 1,6875 | 12
09 | What's Going On | 1,692307692 | 15
10 | Pyramids | 1,7 | 14

11 | Fake Plastic Trees | 1,705882353 | 11
12 | All My Friends | 1,842105263 | 11
13 | Lazarus | 1,882352941 | 9
14 | God Only Knows | 1,923076923 | 13
15 | Smells Like Teen Spirit | 1,928571429 | 18
16 | Tangled Up in Blue | 1,933333333 | 7
17 | Time | 2 | 9
18 | In My Life | 2,105263158 | 7
19 | Debaser | 2,115384615 | 10
20 | There Is a Light That Never Goes Out | 2,12 | 13
21 | Chicago | 2,2 | 7
22 | Jeremy | 2,2 | 6
23 | London Calling | 2,222222222 | 16
24 | Marquee Moon | 2,277777778 | 9
25 | Wake Up | 2,290322581 | 12

26 | Where the Streets Have No Name | 2,3 | 8
27 | A Day in the Life | 2,314285714 | 21
28 | When Doves Cry | 2,318181818 | 8
29 | Stairway to Heaven | 2,333333333 | 8
30 | Runaway | 2,5 | 16
31 | Bring the Noise | 2,533333333 | 4
32 | Devils Haircut | 2,5625 | 8
33 | Living for the City | 2,588235294 | 6
34 | The Chain | 2,6 | 6
35 | Glory Box | 2,666666667 | 4
36 | Heroin | 2,714285714 | 14
37 | Jesus. etc. | 2,789473684 | 7
38 | Tumbling Dice | 2,818181818 | 6
39 | Paranoid Android | 2,837837838 | 14
40 | Visions of Johanna | 2,863636364 | 4
41 | Last Nite | 2,894736842 | 8
42 | Starman | 2,909090909 | 10
43 | Reckoner | 2,956521739 | 5
44 | Swimming Pools (Drank) | 3 | 4
45 | Here Comes the Sun | 3,052631579 | 6
46 | Only Shallow | 3,0625 | 6
47 | Everything in Its Right Place | 3,076923077 | 9
48 | Don't Look Back in Anger | 3,125 | 5
49 | Eleanor Rigby | 3,136363636 | 14
50 | Nightswimming | 3,15 | 7


Correlation with critics

Comparing our lists with the critics' ones, on 29 albums we selected a different song as the best of the album. On the other side on 9 albums we selected the same songs on the same order.

Non-coincidence at the top:
1. Revolver
2. Funeral
3. Kid A
4. The Velvet Underground & Nico
5. Elvis Presley
6. Automatic for the People
7. The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars
8. Odelay
9. The Joshua Tree
10. Closer
11. The Dark Side of the Moon
12. Endtroducing.....
13. Stankonia
14. Modern Vampires of the City
15. Abbey Road
16. The Stone Roses
17. The Blueprint
18. Screamadelica
19. Back to Black
20. Lost in the Dream
21. The Doors
22. (What's the Story) Morning Glory?
23. Who's Next
24. To Pimp a Butterfly
25. Mingus Ah Um
26. Ten
27. Rumours
28. Born in the U.S.A.
29. Disintegration

Exact correlation:
1. What's Going On
2. Songs for Swingin' Lovers!
3. Here's Little Richard
4. Time Out
5. Untrue
6. Murmur
7. The Low End Theory
8. White Blood Cells
9. The Shape of Jazz to Come


Excel files
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun Apr 01, 2018 8:47 am

Fantastic first week after the last!
8 albums updated thanks to bonnielaurel (6) and Mulholland (2)
- Automatic for the People
- Odelay
- Loveless
- Grace
- Let England Shake
- Back to Black
- Murmur
- The Bends
I've decided to keep this thread on the main subforum, at least while people still keep ranking.

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun Apr 08, 2018 7:49 am

Only one album ranked this week, "Illinois."

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun Apr 15, 2018 8:00 am

5 albums updated this week thanks to Nassim, prosecutorgodot, Mulholland and talking:
- The Shape of Jazz to Come
- Marquee Moon
- Thriller
- Disintegration
- Post
Now "Lost in the Dream" is alone at the bottom as the album less ranked.

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun Apr 22, 2018 7:51 am

4 albums ranked this week, all of them by bonnielaurel that is now at #7 of voters with more albums ranked and getting closer to the Top 5:
- Elvis Presley (with a change on the #1 song!)
- Remain in Light
- In the Wee Small Hours
- Lost in the Dream (that again is not alone at the bottom)

User avatar
bonnielaurel
Rust Never Sleeps
Posts: 889
Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2013 2:48 pm

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby bonnielaurel » Sun Apr 22, 2018 12:58 pm

Honorio, I see you only have ninety-eight albums ranked. Which two are missing?
They give awards for that music? I thought just ear plugs. (Woody Allen in Annie Hall)

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun Apr 22, 2018 6:25 pm

"The Low End Theory" and "Ten." Sooner or later I'll get to rank them. During the following weeks hopefully.

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun Apr 29, 2018 7:14 am

Two albums ranked this week thanks to Nassim:
- Ten
- Post

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun May 06, 2018 8:04 am

Five albums updated thanks to 5 different voters, bonnielaurel, DaveC (that enters the Top 5), Nassim, SJner and myself:
- Here's Little Richard
- The Low End Theory
- Forever Changes
- In Utero
- Disintegration

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun May 13, 2018 8:03 am

Two new albums updated this week thanks to bonnielaurel and FrankLotion, a newcomer:
- Channel Orange
- Never Mind the Bollocks, Here's the Sex Pistols

User avatar
Honorio
Die Mensch Maschine
Posts: 1939
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2012 7:38 am
Location: L'Eliana, Valencia, Spain

Re: Rank the Tracks Results (Open 24/7)

Postby Honorio » Sun May 20, 2018 8:11 am

Fantastic week with no less than 15 albums updated thanks to bonnilaurel and DaveC but mainly to Moonbeam who made the truly Herculean task of ranking 13 albums on a single day. Thank you very much Moonbeam and welcome back!
The albums updated were:
- Exile on Main St.
- The Queen Is Dead
- OK Computer
- The Velvet Underground & Nico
- Is This It
- Automatic for the People
- Illinois
- Marquee Moon
- The Doors
- Ramones
- Songs in the Key of Life
- Blackstar
- Hunky Dory
- Disintegration
- Post
As a result of the update "Sir Duke" is now last, the #1 song on the album with less total points.


Return to “Music, music, music...”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 10 guests