Acclaimed Music Forums

Holden

Desafio - 8

Holden

Last day for submissions!

Holden

ALBUMS: CMAT - Crazymad, For Me Jake Shears - Last Man Dancing Lana Del Rey - Did You Know That There's a Tunnel Under Ocean Blvd Róisín Murphy - Hit Parade Janelle Monáe - The Age of Pleasure Jessie Ware - That! Feels Good! Damien Jurado - Motorcycle Madness Anohni and the Johnsons - My Back Was a...

Holden

VacantJoy wrote: ↑Sat Jan 27, 2024 10:54 pm are older EOYs included too in this Holden ? EOY 2022-2014 or older
if i find time i will try to give a look at 2023 when Grammys are posted
your work is appreciated thanks

I’ll update older spreadsheets if requested by Henrik and with a specific list of missing lists

Holden

Bump for five days left!

Holden

Setherex wrote: ↑Fri Jan 26, 2024 3:05 pm I lied, but I got there.

The Spotify playlist above is updated through the Top 366.

[/quote]

Thank you so much! Amazing work

Holden

Wall of Eyes becomes the first album of 2024 to top my daily listening spreadsheet before release. This is only possible for records that are both very high profile (needs to get more than 15 reviews on AOTY before release) and highly acclaimed.

Holden

Looking at the end date I've set for these spreadsheets, the next update for both songs and albums, is going to be the final one after the Grammys. It probably won't be the day of or after, it'll take me a little bit, but rest assured, it is coming. As I've stated before, I'm more than willing to, u...

Holden

Good guesses!! I looked through the nominees and the ones you got wrong are ones that generally surprised me (and many of AV Clubs “long shots” ended up actually making it)

Holden

Do they do reviews?

Holden

Rob wrote: ↑Sat Jan 20, 2024 6:38 pm Todd Rundgren - Initiation: 5
There is a lot of skill on display, but to what end? I find it mostly a lot of busywork.

Reading your daily song reviews always gives me joy, Rob. I find them evocative of the style of Christgau but overall more positive (a welcome touch).

Holden

This really feels like the year of long-running acts. Sufjan, PJ Harvey, blur, and ANOHNI all in the top 10 after being around for 20+ years. Slowdive, Fever Ray, and Yo La Tengo in the next block. Then we get bands like Depeche Mode, The Rolling Stones, and Everything But the Girl having unexpecte...

Holden

New Sources: Belgium: Indiestyle, Goûte mes Disques Canada: CBC Music (Natl) France: New Noise, BenzineMag Germany: Plattentests Ireland: The Irish Times (Intl + Natl) Italy: SentireAscoltare, Rockerilla, Rumore, Blow Up (Intl + Natl) Spain: Ruta 66 (Intl + Natl) Sweden: Sonic UK: Stereoboard, Mixma...

Holden

Update time! Sources have slowed down. If there aren't a lot of new sources posted, there might not be an update for a bit. Rest assured, I am still working on it and will eventually post a final update. New Sources Belgium: Goûte mes Disques, Dansende Beren (Natl) Colombia: Revista Shock (Natl) Ger...

Holden

Two weeks left!

Holden

I used up all my weekly similarweb checks - anyone have a ranking for this source?

Holden

A lot of those reviews are for concerts/singles, which I don't think add to the total.

Holden

This seems like a new source to me! Thanks

Holden

I don't believe this would be eligible based on this requirement: 4. A radio or TV channel is eligible if it is a "main station" of a country (typically a public broadcasting service with a focus on music). The staff team requirement needs to be fulfilled but not the number of reviews. I t...

Holden

Federico wrote: ↑Sat Jan 13, 2024 3:38 pm "The Needle Drop" is already posted by panam. Should be eligible, because tghe album list is also included.

TheNeedleDrop was included in the second most recent update.

Holden

Looking through some lists of upcoming movies, these stood out: Legitimately excited about these: Dune Part 2 Drive-Away Dolls Furiosa: A Mad Max Story A Quiet Place: Day One Deadpool 3 Maxxxine Five sequels and the new Coen movie. Not very creative but it’s what stood out Interested but pretty sure...

Holden

whuntva wrote: ↑Wed Jan 10, 2024 2:24 am
3) Primeval--"Concrete Menagerie"

Not gonna lie, thought I was the only one who ever actually watched that show!

Holden

panam wrote: ↑Sun Jan 07, 2024 10:39 pm It's a personal list

Thank you for pointing this out. It's been removed.

They did an eligible list last year, but I couldn't find it. Can anyone else?

Holden

VacantJoy wrote: ↑Sat Jan 06, 2024 9:36 pm Songs
https://3voor12.vpro.nl/artikelen/overz ... -2023.html

This seems to be a readers poll.

Holden

this is worldwide not from Poland and why its in the not eligible section? Is this a printed magazine? If not, they don’t do reviews or meet the Alexa requirement, so I moved it here. And that's the right decision. Thanks Holden I've just post it according to this https://www.acclaimedmusic.net/for...

Holden

VacantJoy wrote: ↑Sat Jan 06, 2024 10:24 am
panam wrote: ↑Thu Jan 04, 2024 12:07 pm https://beehy.pe/best-albums-of-2023/
this is worldwide not from Poland

and why its in the not eligible section?

Is this a printed magazine? If not, they don’t do reviews or meet the Alexa requirement, so I moved it here.

Holden

Federico wrote: ↑Fri Jan 05, 2024 3:32 pm Holden, the list of "The Quietus" was already posted before the last update. Maybe you forgot to include?

Missed it! Thanks for letting me know

Holden

VacantJoy wrote: ↑Tue Jan 02, 2024 5:18 pm Songs
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4RVks ... kIWIc5TgyG

Where did you find this? I want to make sure it's a consensus list

Holden

Unfortunately doesn't hit the metrics. Thanks anyways!

Holden

Romain wrote: ↑Tue Jan 02, 2024 5:34 pm
Holden wrote: ↑Tue Jan 02, 2024 5:14 pm They hit the Alexa ranking threshold! Thanks
Ho... thank you, I'm an happy man now.
Where can I find Alexa for computers?

I had to add the Similarweb chrome extension!

Holden

They hit the Alexa ranking threshold! Thanks

Holden

whuntva wrote: ↑Tue Jan 02, 2024 4:30 am Is "Run Away to Mars" eligible?

Single was released 2021, but it WAS on a full album released in 2023. Would be an easy Top 10 if it were.

As long as it didn’t reach top 100 in any previous lists.

Holden

Holden

Just a quick note about a handful of the publications on your album list: Both Clash and The Skinny can be taken off it, as you have already added them in a previous update . While searching out the list for the French publication New Noise , I came across an American music publication with the sam...

Holden

Since it’s officially the new year, thought I’d put this back at the top!

Holden

New Update! Happy new year. Argentina: Rolling Stone (Argentina) (Intl + Natl) Belgium: Dansende Beren, Indiestyle Germany: 1Live Italy: Rolling Stone (Italy) (Intl + Natl) Spain: Crazy Minds UK: Dazed, Live4ever USA: Atwood Magazine, Consequence of Sound, Entertainment Weekly, Flood Magazine, Spetr...

Holden

New Update! Argentina: Rolling Stone (Argentina) (Intl + Natl) Belgium: Indiestyle (Natl) Colombia: Radionica France: MagicRPM Germany: Radio 1, 1live Italy: Rolling Stone (Italy) (Intl + Natl) Ireland: XS Noise Mexico: Warp Netherlands: Het Parool Spain: Mondo Sonoro (Natl) UK: Live4Ever USA: Passi...

Holden

Not enough reviews. Thanks anyways!

Holden

Looks like, despite not using this last year (and maybe in the last few years?), it looks like we used BBC back in the early 2000s. Or was that just BBC Radio 6 Music? Anyone have any insight on this eligibility.

Holden

Pierre wrote: ↑Sat Dec 30, 2023 8:51 pm I hope I'm not being a source of too much trouble with this. I didn't expect the website to be in the eligibility zone at all

No worries! Just want to include all the lists we can!

Holden

Alright, so, unfortunately, looking at this source, it seems like it is not eligible due to being below the 1 million threshold on similar web. Is this a printed magazine?

Holden

Alright. After looking at the similarweb extension, it seems Sea of Tranquility IS within the top 1 million (unfortunately, fastnbulbous is not). So I looked into reviews, and I'm a bit skeptical that they meet the criteria that reviews need to be "Substantive" Henrik, here is a link to th...

Holden

Alright, I’ve looked at Semrush (I couldn’t get Similarweb to work) and it seems that this falls out of the top 1,000,000, so it is ineligible.

Holden

Thanks for at least considering. A little background, while I don't have a paid staff, I do have a half dozen contributors. I started in 1995, just before Pitchfork. Coincidentally, Ryan moved from Mpls to Chicago shortly after and was just down the street from me for a while. While he did a great ...

Holden

Thanks for at least considering. A little background, while I don't have a paid staff, I do have a half dozen contributors. I started in 1995, just before Pitchfork. Coincidentally, Ryan moved from Mpls to Chicago shortly after and was just down the street from me for a while. While he did a great ...

Holden

Arde Bogotá - Los Perros Bunbury - Alaska Shinova - Berlín MERINO - Ajedrez Ivan Ferreiro - En el alambre Xoel López - Fort Da Niña Polaca - Los días malos Valeria Castro - la raíz Mikel Erentxun - Tren a Marte Zahara - ESTO NO ES UNA CANCIÓN POLÍTICA Coque Malla - ¿Volverá? Sidonie - No salgo más L...

Holden

Pierre wrote: ↑Sat Dec 30, 2023 4:35 pm Hello Holden!

Nah, it's not eligible (I don't think so at least), it's a website only. Actually it's not a new source, I've posted Sea of Tranquility lists before

Sounds good Pierre! Even if it’s not eligible, seems to be pretty interesting!

Holden

Federico wrote: ↑Fri Dec 29, 2023 11:29 am Notice: This list doesn't really contain any song from the albums lists. Holden, I think, in this case it makes sense to include the list with the best songs from the albums also. Maybe you can treat both lists as one with 151 songs.

Okay, that makes sense. I'll do that

Holden

Seems to be a new source. Is it eligible?

Holden

Final sheet!

Search found 3792 matches