Acclaimed Music Forums

Sweepstakes Ron

I was already considering opting out of the next all-time albums poll (mainly due to a general lack of album-listening from me as of late), but this Kanye shit is giving me even more reason to. It's not as if I have any sort of compunction about putting his music on my list at all, but the idea of w...

Sweepstakes Ron

Given that there seems to be a different number of songs under each letter, it may be fair to just treat this as a regular "one song per artist" all-time list, once they've gone through the whole alphabet.

They really chose that song to represent the Beatles, huh.

Sweepstakes Ron

People on a Discord server I'm in have been actively celebrating his death, on account of the whole "married his 13 year old cousin" thing. It's a strange sort of whiplash compared to here and RYM.

Sweepstakes Ron

So it looks like Pitchfork aren't the only ones hyping up "Fantasy".

Sweepstakes Ron

Although, relating to this, Nick should be chuffed to know that his Cardi B rant is still fondly(?) remembered on r/indieheads 5 years later.

Sweepstakes Ron

At the very least, it’s possible ITAOTS and the rest that were left out here will be better represented on the albums list, even if they end up lacing below multiple Mariah albums and Britney’s debut or something. We’ll just have to see. I won’t argue that the whole thing doesn’t feel a least a litt...

Sweepstakes Ron

Damn, "Show Me Love" in here too? It's like they read my mind and picked the exact 90s songs I thought were missing from AM for too long, what the hell.

Sweepstakes Ron

I give this list my reluctant stamp of approval due to the inclusion of both "Feels Good" and "My Boo".

Sweepstakes Ron

Henry wrote: ↑Tue Sep 06, 2022 2:56 pm I thought 4153 was Gal Costa's "Baby."

Perhaps the OMC song is actually rated as 4724.

That's because this thread is from 6 years ago

Sweepstakes Ron

At the end, I wasn't sure if it's eligible. I was thinking doing the transcription (with a little time). Edit: It's not necessary transcription. It's in there https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ONEHC1m1Now80Yvxb3B8-VDwStTQkqKBdr5XtJFkLrI/edit#gid=1882063169 Is it? I’m checking from my phone an...

Sweepstakes Ron

For me, the main offending part of this case is the lists being unchanging throughout the years, which is something I hadn't noticed until Bleu recently pointed it out. Most of the other stuff in combination with that makes the situation too suspicious to not at least try to take action towards, but...

Sweepstakes Ron

Gillingham wrote: ↑Fri Aug 26, 2022 10:35 am Is it's Luiza's or Ron's pick?

Don't look at me, I'm just as shocked by the existence of this as everyone else here.

Sweepstakes Ron

Single person blog, don't see any reviews either.

Sweepstakes Ron

Single person blog that mostly seems to be about movies anyways, not eligible.

Sweepstakes Ron

Seems to be a single person list, but still mentions "we" in the article. Probably doesn't meet review criteria, in any case

Sweepstakes Ron

Seems to be a single-author list, I don't think this site does reviews anyhow.

Sweepstakes Ron

Not an actual list, just a tally of review scores

Sweepstakes Ron

Vacantjoy wrote: ↑Fri Jul 01, 2022 8:30 ameligible?

We've used their lists for EOY before, so yes

Sweepstakes Ron

Looks eligible to me

Sweepstakes Ron

I'm not seeing any reviews in their music section, and it's yet another list that's credited to one author but says "we" in the intro. Leaning towards ineligible.

Sweepstakes Ron

I'm not seeing any reviews, but this one may need to be double checked.

Sweepstakes Ron

Yeah, this doesn't seem eligible, but I really, REALLY wish it was. Oh well, at least this site will give me plenty of nice, long lists to check out.

Sweepstakes Ron

By all accounts, this seems eligible. There's just the separate issue of what exactly counts as a "Chicago album".

Sweepstakes Ron

List has only two authors, and the sites doesn't seem to do enough reviews. Shame, we could really use a list like this.

Sweepstakes Ron

Seems to just be a single writer, and the blog doesn't have enough music focus to be eligible anyway.

Sweepstakes Ron

Single writer, no proper reviews that I can find, ineligible.

Sweepstakes Ron

I can't find any reviews for this source, and it also might be a single-critic list, but I may need to double check.

Sweepstakes Ron

Ineligible due to audience votes

Sweepstakes Ron

I believe I declared a few years ago for EOY that this source is ineligible.

Sweepstakes Ron

Not a critic list

Sweepstakes Ron

Can't find a lot of info about the site, but it seems to be ineligible.

Sweepstakes Ron

A single person's blog, and the site ranking doesn't seem to be high enough to merit inclusion.

Sweepstakes Ron

This is a site for a party venue... I don't think this is eligible at all.

Sweepstakes Ron

Yeah, this should definitely be eligible. I add their EOY songs lists every year.

Sweepstakes Ron

Unfortunately, I don't think the site is popular enough or does enough reviews...

Sweepstakes Ron

This is just sheet music, I don't think it counts

Sweepstakes Ron

Not included are instrumental albums, compilations, mixtapes (otherwise classic mixtapes like Joey Bada$$’s 1999 (2012), Isaiah Rashad’s Cilvia Demo (2014), Chance The Rapper’s Acid Rap (2013), Mick Jenkins’ The Waters (2014), Big K.R.I.T.’s K.R.I.T. Wuz Here (2010) and Return Of 4eva (2011), No Na...

Sweepstakes Ron

I'd assume this isn't eligible, but I suppose rules for lists from podcasts haven't been clearly defined.

Sweepstakes Ron

This is just a link to Rolling Stone's list (Robinson co-wrote "On the Level" by Leonard Cohen).

Sweepstakes Ron

Just one person's personal blog (and doesn't even seem to have any reviews as of recent) so definitely not eligible.

Sweepstakes Ron

Hey wait a minute, I've seen this one before www.acclaimedmusic.net/forums/viewtopic ... 22&p=72199

Sweepstakes Ron

Sweepstakes Ron

Sweepstakes Ron

Sweepstakes Ron

Sweepstakes Ron

At last, the final update has arrived! Thank you all for your patience. For next year, I really do think we should have a serious discussion about how I can get this done sooner, or if someone else should take over. New Sources: USA & Canada: Slant, HipHopDX (Hip Hop), HipHopDX (R&B), XXL, N...

Sweepstakes Ron

Sweepstakes Ron

Would it be possible to create an online version of the program, where we would all have access to the same list? Perhaps it would be possible to set it up with a check-in/check-out function, and limit the number of votes to say 10 per day and person. That would be really cool, wouldn't it? All the...

Sweepstakes Ron

Sweepstakes Ron

Search found 2730 matches