Acclaimed Music Forums

Otisredding

The Beatles
Sly & The Family Stone
Curtis Mayfield
Simon & Garfunkel
The Kinks
Depeche Mode
New Order
James Brown

Otisredding

Henrik wrote:Otis, could you please point me to an album review on the Scanner FM website. Thanks!

This is the link to the reviews. The truth is that it is not easy to find.

http://www.scannerfm.com/category/top/

Otisredding

Led Zeppelin
John Coltrane
AC/DC
Miles Davis
Bob Marley
Steely Dan
Ramones
The Clash

Otisredding

Three of the most important musicians of the 21st century have lost the match: PJ, Sufjan and Kanye

Otisredding

The Rolling Stones
Portishead
Massive Attack
Creedence Clearwater Revival
The Doors
The White Stripes
Bjork
Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds

Otisredding

David Bowie
Kanye West
Queen)
PJ Harvey
Arcade Fire
Chuck Berry (84)
Lou Reed
Elvis Presley

Otisredding

Prince
Madonna
Elvis Costello
Michael Jackson
The Police
Joy Division
Peter Gabriel
The Cure

Otisredding

R.E.M.
Blur
The Beastie Boys
The Smiths
Violent Femmes
Pixies
Public Enemy
Johnny Cash

Otisredding

The Who
Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers
Pearl Jam
Marvin Gaye
Stevie Wonder
Otis Redding
John Lennon
Bruce Springsteen

Otisredding

Bob Dylan
Van Morrison
Pink Floyd
Neil Young
Leonard Cohen
The Velvet Underground
Talking Heads
Radiohead

Otisredding

1 The Kinks
2 New Order
3 James Brown
4 My Bloody Valentine
5 Sly & The Family Stone
6 Cocteau Twins
7 Yo La Tengo
8 Curtis Mayfield
9 The Beatles
10 Pet Shop Boys

Otisredding

Harold. What happened to me is that I had a problem and I could not finish the list.

You can delete your message, if you will, of course.

Otisredding

MCCh 2012 (05) March, 31

6 new entries

And new webs used: Rave (Australia); DIY (UK); Blurt (USA); Bowlegs (USA). Eliminated, for now, these sites because they do not reach 50% of the average number of reviews: Humo, Mondosonoro, Cokemachineglow, Spin and Tiny Mix Tapes

Otisredding

The best albums of 2012 (update March, 31) The final numbers is the average rating and number of reviews in brackets (over 28) New Entry or Re Entry 30 - Cate Le Bon: CYRK - 72,8 (8) grooveshark [imgsize 80x80:3aq2dx0s]http://www.am1700radio.com/images/CateLeBon_CYRK.jpg 29 - Michael Kiwanuka: Home...

Otisredding

1 The Clash
2 Television
3 Ramones
4 Led Zeppelin
5 Miles Davis
6 Buzzcocks
7 The Specials
8 John Coltrane
9 Sex Pistols
10 Bob Marley

Otisredding

Henrik wrote:
slick wrote:The final artist to advance sneaked in with 60 points on the final vote...
59 - Kraftwerk

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

Otisredding

1 The Rolling Stones
2 Kraftwerk
3 Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds
4 Massive Attack
5 Bjork
6 De La Soul
7 Jimi Hendrix
8 Portishead
9 The White Stripes
10 The Streets

Otisredding

1 The Smiths
2 Public Enemy
3 Pixies
4 Sonic Youth
5 Johnny Cash
6 Pulp
7 R.E.M.
8 The Beastie Boys
9 Patsy Cline
10 Grandmaster Flash

Otisredding

1 Bob Dylan
2 Leonard Cohen
3 Van Morrison
4 Talking Heads
5 Tom Waits
6 Neil Young
7 The Velvet Underground
8 Roxy Music
9 Pink Floyd
10 Lauren Hill

Otisredding

Thank you, Stephan

Oor not eligible because it does not publish reviews in web

HUMO is already included in MCCH, but this year has decreased much revision numbers: it is possible to remove HUMO from the spreadsheet

Otisredding

MCCh 2012 (04) March, 15

7 new entries: new music from San Jose, Transylvania?, Freehold, Raleigh, Los Angeles, Chicago and New York and new number one

And new webs used: Music-story (France), Magic RPM (France), and Gaffa (Sweden)

Otisredding

The best albums of 2012 (update March, 15) The final numbers is the average rating and number of reviews in brackets (over 29) New Entry 25 - Xiu Xiu: Always - 73,2 (15) grooveshark spotify [imgsize 85x85:c8rj85r2]http://bellaunion.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Unknown-3.jpeg 24 - Chairlift: Somet...

Otisredding

Thank you very much, Henrik.

Now I get. If I have a problem I will tell you

Otisredding

Henrik wrote:OK. How do you count the number of reviews per year?

With patience

If you want tell me what are the major webs and I will check the requirements

Otisredding

I think it's best to meet the general criteria of MCCH:

1) Sites that perform more than 400 reviews of albums in the year
2) that the reviews are scored

I remember that you also thought that this was the best

Otisredding

Henrik. I have not decided which of the sites included in Kritiker used to MCCH. You could tell me which has more than 400 reviews or so.

Gaffa? SvD? Aftonbladet?

Otisredding

The Swedes are all here: http://kritiker.se/

Otisredding

It's a great website. It seems that in Sweden everyone is putting letters, numbers, bees, fir, crosses, horses, etc.. on reviews of the albums. I have to do that I in Spain. option a) I could eliminate Nojesguiden scores and use of Kritiker. option b) Keep Nojesguiden and include other publication o...

Otisredding

lagire wrote:i forgot "music story" which is as allmusic but for france

music-estory meets the requirements

Thank you very much, lagire, MCCH is better now because we have France.

Someone from Holland, Ireland, Poland, Ukraine ... you know any music website with reviews ...

Otisredding

here is a list of web critics from france: - rock and folk - magicrpm Merci beaucoup, lagire Rock and folk. published only 25 reviews a month. Ineligible Magicrpm. I will read more. At first I think it's a quality publication. And publishes an extensive critique of discs France will be represented ...

Otisredding

And in March 1, 2008? 01. Vampire Weekend ´Vampire Weekend´ 02. Black Mountain ´In The Future´ 03. Hot Chip ´Made In The Dark´ 04. Drive-By Truckers ´Brighter Than Creation´S Dark´ 05. Magnetic Fields ´Distortion´ 06. Cat Power ´Jukebox´ 07. Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds ´Dig, Lazarus, Dig!!!´ 08. L...

Otisredding

And in March 1, 2009? 001. Animal Collective ´Merriweather Post Pavillion´ 002. Antony & The Johnsons ´The Crying Light´ 003. M. Ward ´Hold Time´ 004. Andrew Bird ´Noble Beast´ 005. Morrissey ´Years Of Refusal´ 006. The Phantom Band ´Checkmate Savage´ 007. Dan Auerbach ´Keep It Hid´ 008. Titus A...

Otisredding

And in March 1, 2010? 001. Beach House ´Teen Dream´ 002. Four Tet ´There Is Love In You´ 003. Yeasayer ´Odd Blood´ 004. Ali Farka Touré & Toumani Diabaté ´Ali And Toumani´ 005. Pantha Du Prince ´Black Noise´ 006. Vampire Weekend ´Contra´ 007. Hot Chip ´One Life Stand´ 008. These New Puritans ´Hi...

Otisredding

What the top 20 on March 1, 2011, in Mega Critic Chart? 001. PJ Harvey 'Let England Shake' 002. James Blake 'James Blake' 003. Iron & Wine 'Kiss Each Other Clean' 004. Radiohead 'The King Of Limbs' 005. Destroyer 'Kaputt' 006. Mogwai 'Hardcore Will Never Die, But You Will' 007. Wire 'Red barked ...

Otisredding

lagire wrote:otis,
why don't you post more than 20 albums?

2012 has started very recently.

The list will be progressively getting bigger.

Albums from the list, now 20, are the records that remain in the top 100 at year end, approximately.

Otisredding

Moonbeam wrote:Any recommendations?

MCCh 2012 (03) February, 29

Otisredding

Henrik wrote:the source should have provided music reviews or ratings through the past year.

Jenasaispop: Yes, in web
Playground: Yes, in web
Muzikalia: Yes, in web
Scanner FM: Yes, in web
MondoSonoro: Yes, in web and paper
Rock De Lux: Yes, in paper
Tentaciones: Yes, in web
Go Mag: Yes, in web and paper

Otisredding

MCCh 2012 (03) February, 29

9 new entries. New music from Melbourne, London (2), Nashville, Nottingham, Seattle (2), Vancouver and Barcelona.

Otisredding

The best albums of 2012 (update February, 29) The final numbers is the average rating and number of reviews in brackets (over 26) 20 - The Twilight Sad: No One Can Ever Know - 73,6 (10) grooveshark [imgsize 90x90:16skth43]http://c438342.r42.cf2.rackcdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/twilightsadnoon...

Otisredding

Henrik, if there is no objection, I would do two updates per month: day 15 and 30/31 of each month.

Otisredding

MCCh 2012 (02) February, 15

Otisredding

The best albums of 2012 (update February, 15) The final numbers is the average rating and number of reviews in brackets (over 26) 15 - Laura Gibson: La Grande – 71,0 (13) grooveshark spotify [imgsize 100x100:335inywt]http://static.motor.de/bilder/e92d25996a55f392c12ddb3788dec6df.jpg 14 - Errors: Ha...

Otisredding

This is becoming more fun.

I am thinking of establishing a Mega Critic Chart with AM'ers scores, but still I do not know exactly what we could do.

Otisredding

MCCh 2012 (01) January, 31

Otisredding

The best albums of 2012 (update January, 31) The final numbers is the average rating and number of reviews in brackets (over 26) 10 - Diagrams: Back Light - 66,1 (8) grooveshark spotify [imgsize 100x100:qll2jkd3]http://www.pias.com/fr/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Diagrams_Black-Light.jpg 09...

Otisredding

The best albums of 2012 The ratings come from a formula that includes a) average of ratings from different sources and b) numbers of magazines that rated the album. The magazines I used for the ratings were: USA: Allmusic; AV Club; BeatsPerMinute; Cokemachineglow; Consequence Of Sound; Pitchforkmed...

Otisredding

Go-Mag: This year GO-MAG has no list of the best songs
Heineken has done nothing lists

Otisredding

It's okay. I have spent some times but it's a fun job.

Otisredding

¿?

I do not understand. I was doing this work. This is what I said to Henrik ...

So I leave work. Ok?

Otisredding

Ok

I also published the list of 100 songs of 2011. If you consider what you could link to the home page (as of 2010)

http://pub37.bravenet.com/forum/static/show.php?usernum=3172289350&frmid=10&msgid=1203056&cmd=show

Search found 1400 matches