Acclaimed Music Forums

Harold

Hopefully as more reviews for it roll in that Low album will enter the top ten. My AOTY I'm sure it will go way up in the next update. Keep in mind that it was just released this past Friday, so the fact that it's actually made this chart already is impressive in and of itself. (The same thing occu...

Harold

Michael's sister at #8 alone invalidates this list. yikes So where should it be? It's a great album. Are you saying it shouldn't be on the list at all or further down? Based on his previous posts, he's not a fan of anyone in particular named Jackson (Samuel L., maybe). Given that and the "yike...

Harold

Well, it's different - substantially so - from our PF rankings. So, good on them, for a change.

Harold

Thanks, Otisredding! Wow, three new entries in the top 10. Glad to see IDLES debut so high - that album is a knockout. To go directly from the sarcastic humor of "Love Song" ("I fucking love you / I really love you/ Look at this card I bought! / It says 'I love you' ") to the alm...

Harold

Otisredding, is there going to be a Mega-Critic update today?

Harold

Are you sure it's really them? I'm not a Gipsy Kings expert but it doesn't strike me like the right voices or that the instrumentation fits their taste. Wouldn't be the first time a song goes around the internet with the wrong credits ! Yes, there several different videos of it, plus there are site...

Harold

Are you sure it's really them? I'm not a Gipsy Kings expert but it doesn't strike me like the right voices or that the instrumentation fits their taste. Wouldn't be the first time a song goes around the internet with the wrong credits ! Infamously, there's a YouTube video attributing "Don't Wo...

Harold

This one is pretty significant: Steve Lacy, the jazz saxophonist whose 1959 album Reflections: Steve Lacy Plays Thelonious Monk is in the top 3000, is NOT the same person as Steve Lacy, the hip-hop producer and member of The Internet who appears on the Songs list as a featured artist on Tyler, The C...

Harold

One of our own called them out in the comments section - thanks, Nassim.

Harold

I don't have a list to post, but I just wanted to say that, my God, the idea that Madonna is 60 is making me feel very old, even though I'm younger than her...

Harold

I've mentioned this album before in this forum, but it's always mystified me that while Aimee Mann's first and third solo albums have always gotten the attention they deserve (including both being in the AM top 3000), her equally brilliant second album I'm With Stupid (1996) seems all but forgotten....

Harold

We knew it was coming, but it doesn't make the news any less devastating. R.I.P. to a true legend.

Harold

Interesting that Brand New is No. 1 on this list. Did critics know about Jesse Lacey's transgressions back in 2006? I know that's what kept their last album off AM after great initial reviews. I've always liked their music, and Deja Entendu (127 on the list) is one of my favorite albums. What's int...

Harold

Could i ask for 101-200？I'm currently trying to discover good music that i haven't heard of.Either way thank you very much I'll do #101-185. Below that we start getting albums that only appear on either BEA's or RYM's top 5000. Note that the re-recording of Twin Fantasy , a 2018 release, is #115; p...

Harold

When I expand that list to 200, The Power and the Glory and In a Glass House are included. Are UGK‘s Ridin' Dirty , Game Theory's two albums and Captain Beyond's debut in it too？Just Curious Ridin' Dirty is. The Captain Beyond album is in the top 5000 on both sites, but doesn't make this top 200.

Harold

Gentle Giant remain completely absent from AM. Their first seven albums are highly rated by non-critics. "Octopus" ranks at 54 on Harold's (very interesting) list, but the other six can't be far away from the top. When I expand that list to 200, The Power and the Glory and In a Glass Hous...

Harold

I realize this thread is about rockers of the 60s, but let's take a moment to marvel at the fact that three members of the inaugural class of the R&R Hall of Fame are still alive: Little Richard - 85 Jerry Lee Lewis - 82 Don Everly - 81 Lewis is actually performing at Riot Fest here in Chicago n...

Harold

Since this thread now exists as a repository for great albums not on AM, it seems like a good place for this exercise, which I've been doing for a while now. After the AM update was posted, I combined it with the then-current top 5000 albums lists from Best Ever Albums and Rate Your Music using a re...

Harold

[*] Penguin Eggs by Nic Jones This one is bubbling under, and if you look at the AM "History" tab you'll see that it inched into the top 3000 on a couple of occasions, most recently in 2010. Very much in full agreement on the two Game Theory albums. (Both are in the top 10,000 on both Bes...

Harold

FrankLotion wrote:I know Run the Jewels 3 had a Christmas release date so it was doomed to be forgotten in lists but it definitely deserves a spot on AM!

RTJ3 certainly does deserve a spot on AM. In fact, it has one. It's #2510 on the all-time album list, listed as a 2016 release.

Harold

Is it correct that Nina Simone's Pastel Blues doesn't have enough critic recommendations to be bubbling under? It placed high in the Pitchfork 60s albums list. Henrik had said numerous times that he wasn't going to be adding any pre-2017 albums to the lists in this update (with the single obvious e...

Harold

- Joni Mitchell's cover of "Both Sides Now" (Judy Collins) Shouldn't that be the other way around, since Joni wrote the song? I do think Collins' familiar hit version was released first; the version on Ladies of the Canyon , I think, was the first time Mitchell recorded it herself (same w...

Harold

The top 113 are in the exact order as the 113 Beatles songs in the top 10,000 from the November 2017 update. This is truly one of the most bizarre things I've ever seen, a brazen act of thievery that needs to be called out. I wonder how often other lists from AM have been "repurposed" like...

Harold

filmman wrote:Wait, I had no idea that this had already been updated. I didn't see any announcement
Since when?
Thank you very much.

Updated one week ago:
http://acclaimedmusic.net/forums/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=6834

Harold

Thanks, Henrik! A perfect end to the weekend. Looking forward to exploring.

Harold

Or maybe it's a tip of the hat to "Gold Digger." 18 years, 18 years - do one of these lists 'bout every 18 years...

Harold

Very interesting list, but I have to wonder - why now? Why make this list at the 18-year mark, which seems really arbitrary? The only thing I can think of is that with the times being as perilous and crazy as they are, maybe RS is worried that we won't be around to do lists like this at the 20- or 2...

Harold

letmeintomyzone wrote:How far will Melodrama make on the updated in general?

Is the 251-260 range is likely?

Well, there's only one person who can answer that...

Harold

In the wake of Henrik's announcement that the (final?) site update will probably be coming in July, I was going to bump my predictions about the 2017 albums likely to make the AM top 3000 to the top of the forum - only to realize that I hadn't actually posted any predictions yet. So, here goes! Foru...

Harold

Great news!

Harold

Kids See Ghosts barely in the top 50 and no Kanye even among the bubbling unders!!! You expected it to be? Well, I know that YE has been bashed by many critics, but I have mostly followed RYM recently, where it actually almost has the same rating as TLOP. And KSG might be in RYM’s top 5 of 2018 in ...

Harold

Kids See Ghosts barely in the top 50 and no Kanye even among the bubbling unders!!! You expected it to be? I'm a little surprised at how low Kids See Ghosts is, too - I'm expecting it to climb higher next time (although I could be wrong). Not at all surprised that YE is nowhere to be found here, th...

Harold

As of this writing, you seem to have moved Daytona to #3 but without changing its rank or rating (#10, 80.3) from its debut last time - please fix this.

Harold

- I need to know in what year Mr. Sheffield files "...Baby One More Time" under. It was released in 1998 as a single and the debut came in 1999, but that is still a 1998 track, no? That production is still stunning and modern until this day. From Sheffield's intro: "On the other hand...

Harold

No time to digest the list right now, but what an awesome choice for #1. Love, love, LOVE that song. "Hear the voices in my head/I swear to God it sounds like they're snoring/But if you're bored then you're boring/The agony and the irony, they're killing me/WHOAAA!!!" God bless you, Sheffi...

Harold

Pitchfork's review is out. 7.1 (even though the review is pretty negative). After reading the review I had to do a double-take at the rating to make sure it wasn't actually 1.7. It sure as hell isn't a positive review. The 7.1 looks like a "no-lower-than-this-for-our-favorite" editorial e...

Harold

That Spiderland re-creation is AMAZING! It looks and sounds like a fantastic time was had by all!

Harold

panam wrote:Pazz & Jop didn't exist in 1971 hehehe.

Maybe not under that name, but there was a Village Voice poll in 1971, the very first one. It was revived in 1974 under the Pazz & Jop title.

Harold

https://www.stereogum.com/1995502/premature-evaluation-arctic-monkeys-tranquility-base-hotel-casino/franchises/premature-evaluation/ They don't seem to like it, but I'm interested in hearing it: the new album by recent Acclaimed Music Hall of Famers Arctic Monkeys is out! StevieFan, can you please ...

Harold

Scott Hutchison, the lead singer and songwriter of the Scottish band Frightened Rabbit, has been found dead after being reported missing earlier this week. He disappeared after posting a couple of disturbing tweets that read like farewell messages; Hutchison had battled depression his entire life an...

Harold

Jirin wrote:I wonder how many days until someone makes a mashup of Pynk with Aerosmith’s Pink.

Or Boris's.

Harold

I haven't had time yet to read this essay with the in-depth focus it deserves, but thanks for posting it. Del Rey is a fascinating artist, one whose music takes a while to unpack - the reason, maybe, why there's usually been such a disconnect between the tepid initial reviews of her albums and their...

Harold

Yes, this is a huge deal - not quite as earth-shattering as Dylan being awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature a couple of years ago, but considering that nothing even remotely approaching pop music has ever won in this category it's highly significant. (And it's not even for Lamar's best album.)

Harold

In the past they've always used their hate for each other to make great art, what has changed lately? Right. We're talking about a band that followed up its biggest album ever - one of THE biggest albums ever - with an album that was allegedly titled by one member after another member's pet name fo...

Harold

Also, you're aware that Cardi B's album is actually turning out to be one of the most critically acclaimed albums of 2018 so far, right? (84 on Metacritic with 21 reviews, top 10 of current albums on Any Decent Music, top 30 on AOTY.)

Harold

Holy crap. News broke this afternoon that Lindsey Buckingham has been fired from Fleetwood Mac, ostensibly over "a disagreement over the band's upcoming tour," according to Rolling Stone's confirmation of the firing: https://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/fleetwood-mac-fires-lindsey-bucki...

Harold

I'm shocked Kacey Musgraves didn't crack the top 53. It has a 90 on metacritic and is ranked fifth for the year on Any Decent Music - even above the number two album here. I'm assuming its reviews came out a little bit late for this update. I'd certainly expect it to debut pretty high in the next u...

Harold

Now Only is illustrated with the cover of the Camp Cope album. Also, shouldn't the Black Panther album technically be credited to Various Artists, not to Kendrick Lamar? Very interesting changes this time around. I knew Hot Snakes would debut high but wasn't expecting #1. Did Jeff Rosenstock's rank...

Harold

DaveC wrote:No Phil Ochs

I'm sure it wouldn't interest anybody outside of a small circle of friends.

Harold

I thought the King Krule album was borderline unlistenable and had no business being in near the critics' top ten, so count me among those who are happy to see it so low in this poll. Completely agree. He can't sing for his life and the music is at best atonal, at worst off key. Horrible album. The...

Search found 1781 matches