Acclaimed Music Forums

Harold

Genius is not in any way, shape, or form a critics' site. It's best known as a repository (an amazing one) for lyric transcription and interpretations. It does not run album reviews at all, let alone the 10 a month that Henrik deemed the minimum (among other criteria) for eligibility. This is an int...

Harold

which albums realesead this decade had the bigger impact in culture and molded the progression of music as the years went by So by this logic the best films of the decade should just be all the MCU films? Please tell me you're not implying that Blonde and Ctrl are the musical equivalents of MCU fil...

Harold

Third time's the charm! Spreadsheet update uploaded.

Harold

Still not uploading for me, sorry. Thanks in advance to Henrik.

Harold

Updated with: USA: Stereogum; Consequence of Sound Rest of the World: Rockdelux (Intl) [Spain] I'll start entering the unranked lists at a later time (have I ever mentioned that I hate entering unranked lists?). Current top 60: 1 / Kendrick Lamar / To Pimp a Butterfly 2 / Kanye West / My Beautiful D...

Harold

Despite personal dramas and her annoying fan base, Taylor Swift is an amazing songwriter and has given us some pretty solid albums. Im glad she is finally getting the recognition she deserves by music critics. On the other hand, Adele being shutted out of many of these lists is such a win for music...

Harold

Here's a list of sources used for the 2018 albums spreadsheet. A few potential new ones have been noted in the EOD forum, and I'll keep my eyes out for those as well. USA/Canada : A.V. Club AllMusic American Songwriter Austin Town Hall Billboard A Closer Listen Complex Consequence of Sound Decibel E...

Harold

A request regarding EOD album and song lists (and this applies to those who will be posting EOY lists as well): Please transcribe all lists within the thread for each source, and please do so in a way that clearly demarcates artist and title (for the less-well-known entries). The transcriptions don'...

Harold

Not a critics' list, so not eligible. But thanks for posting anyway!

Harold

Harold

Hi Harold, yes I think so to answer your question. I translated their presentation of this particular best of and it goes like this: "A few months from the end of the decade 2010, we have designated the 150 most important records of the past ten years and, through this large file, makes an inventor...

Harold

Is this framed as their official, unranked best-of-the-decade list? Just trying to make sure before taking the time to add it to the spreadsheet.

Harold

Henrik wrote: ↑
Sun Oct 20, 2019 4:31 pm
Here are the EOD and EOY templates for albums. National lists should be entered in columns GA-HA.

Thanks, Henrik!

Harold

Generally I would say that scores from different eoy sheets should be summed up. However, I think that in some songs spreadsheets placements from a previous year are included again in a new spreadsheet. Then the sum of scores would be too high. Is this ever the case for the albums spreadsheets? In ...

Harold

I think [DMB's] only success in France was "The Space Between", they are one of those bands that were huge in the US but pretty small abroad (and they don't have the excuse of playing country adjacent music). I guess that would make them the modern Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers ! That noise we al...

Harold

I'm planning to include all albums from the EOY sheets in a massive template for the EOD lists, with a EOY score column that is not used for the EOD sheet ranking, but will be useful for me when deciding what albums that will be added to the site next year. For example an album that is included in ...

Harold

I can take on the end-of-year spreadsheet again, although this will probably be the last year I do it and I may not be able to post updates as frequently as I have in the past. I can also get the ball rolling, at least, on the EOD spreadsheet too. Please feel free to send me both spreadsheet templa...

Harold

Henrik wrote: ↑
Thu Oct 10, 2019 4:55 pm
I had a look at the EOY sheets and saw that artists in the 2011-2013 albums lists ... are listed as "Surname, Firstname" and "Band, The". In all other sheets artists are listed as "Firstname Surname" and "The Band".

That was my fault - sorry for the extra work!

Harold

Apologies to everyone who have been waiting for an update in 2019. I came fairly close, but during the last couple of months I haven’t had any time at all to complete the work. Now, when the decade lists are coming in, I feel it’s better to wait and do a big update next year. I will need help with ...

Harold

I think we know why Swans aren't in it... Can you tell me why? Not trying to offend you.. I'm just really curious Presumably this is referring to the rape allegation made against Michael Gira a few years ago by another artist. I didn't think the story was given enough credence at the time to impact...

Harold

"Runaway" was #3 in their half-decade 2010-2014 list, so I guess this represents them dumping Kanye for Kendrick, and foreshadows 2015's P.I.M.P. overtaking MBDTF, wherever that ends up now in the full-decade album list. Not that I feel terribly sorry for Kanye, and P.I.M.P. would be a good choice,...

Harold

Gonna have to echo what I said about this list on RYM: This list is awful. No TPAB? MBDTF? Channel Orange? You have to be kidding me. But Charli XCX and Young Thug's mixtapes get included. Like bruh. TPAB and Channel Orange are missing because - as it states clearly at the top of the article - they...

Harold

I find myself wondering if there are other publications that will do a "Best of the First 20 Years of the Century" list instead of an end-of-decade. In terms of their overall level of acclaim, the two most glaring omissions, by far, are Illinois and Yankee Hotel Foxtrot. A little surprised to see on...

Harold

Does the new King Gizzard actually have less than 70? :( Which one? :mrgreen: They've already released two albums this year. KGATLW is one of those bands that have a fervent cult following that doesn't often correlate with critical acclaim. Nonagon Infinity was more or less an exception. Part of th...

Harold

When’s the update happening? If only there was, speaking purely hypothetically, a post from Henrik just a few posts above this one where he explicitly says that because of all his real-life responsibilities he simply cannot say with any certainty when the next site update is going to be. If such a ...

Harold

I think its a fairly safe bet that it was suicide given his history of depression / wife leaving him last year / some of his lyrics. American Water is one of the best indie albums of the 90s and everyone should give it a try, especially if they like Pavement. Joe Pernice (of Pernice Brothers) poste...

Harold

The version of "All the Young Dudes" that appears on NME (UK) - Bowie: His Real Greatest Hits (2014) may actually be Mott the Hoople's version, or possibly both versions at once. From the page you posted, it looks like NME intended this as a list of Bowie's best songs (as songwriter), regardless of...

Harold

Honorio wrote: 13. She's My Best Friend (1985), Doug Yule (or so it says in the Internet, not sure about this one).

Yes, that's definitely Yule singing lead on the VU version of this song (revived by Reed, in a drastically different version, on Coney Island Baby).

Harold

I can understand your views on song lyrics, because that’s just personal taste. But dude, have you heard “Candy Says”, “Who Loves The Sun”, or “Oh Sweet Nuthin!”. You can’t tell me that Reed isn’t in the same class as vocalists as Berry or Diddley, if not better. Sorry to jump in here like this, bu...

Harold

1. Pulp- Common People ("Rent a flat above a shop..") I'm not a musician, nor am I versed in music theory, but I always thought this section was part of the chorus, not the middle eight (which is synonymous with the bridge, right?). Wouldn't the middle eight of "Common People" be the part that begi...

Harold

Is Originals not considered eligible for MC? Or has it not been reviewed by enough MC sources?

Harold

Henrik, there's an album which, in my opinion, shoud be included on AM. it's Gerry Mulligan "Gerry Mulligan Quartet/The Original Quartet with Chet Baker" 1953. I believe this (or, a version of this) was included on AM at one time, when Henrik was first adding jazz albums to the database (2005); alo...

Harold

And news has broken of the death, at 77, of another great figure: New Orleans legend Mac Rebennack, a.k.a. Dr. John, "The Night Tripper." The good doctor's extraordinary 1968 album Gris-Gris belongs in everyone's collection, but everything he ever recorded or played on is worth hearing and imbued wi...

Harold

A post in the "Survivors of the 60s" thread prodded me to note the passing of two more legends. This thread is to honor the legendary Texas psychedelic rocker Roky Erickson (lead singer of The 13th Floor Elevators), who died over the weekend at 71. Much like Brian Wilson, Erickson made a remarkable ...

Harold

I have tickets to the show for July 5. I look forward to seeing it and I will tell you my thoughts once I see it. I love the album and would love to see it performed. For those who would like to see it, or maybe you already HAVE seen it, I am sure it will be a good time. I didn't know it was still ...

Harold

If you like authentic blues, you really gotta check out Blueshammer.

Harold

50 De La Soul - The Grind Date (2004) 49 Malibu Ken - Malibu Ken (2019) 48 Curren$y - Pilot Talk (2010) 47 Shabazz Palaces - Black Up (2011) 46 YG - Still Brazy (2016) 45 El-P - Fantastic Damage (2002) 44 Missy Elliott - Miss E…So Addictive (2001) 43 Raekwon - Only Built 4 Cuban Linx Pt. II (2009) 4...

Harold

It also reminds me of an anecdote from Neil Young. A live show in the mid 70s. Somebody was loudly requesting Southern Man and he basically said “If you can go back to where you were two years ago, I’ll go back to where I was two years ago.” Not to mention what happened to Dylan after his accident....

Harold

I actually first thought about this dynamic thanks to Ringo Starr -- I believe in the Anthology coffee table book, he says Sgt. Pepper's was his least favorite record, because of where his head was at, at the time. I thought that was so odd, the first time I read that. Then Billy Idol sort of trash...

Harold

I'm pretty sure the Michael Gira allegations were proven false, but may be wrong on that one. And i think everyone knew or suspected the Jackson stuff way before this documentary (even way before he died) because of the general creepy nature of how many kids he kept around him all the time and the ...

Harold

Scott Walker, the American-born singer who became a British teen idol in the Sixties with the group The Walker Brothers and then took a sharp left turn into decades of acclaimed, wildly experimental and avant-garde music, has died at 76:

https://pitchfork.com/news/scott-walker-dead-at-76/

Harold

Forum veterans probably know that, once the EOY albums spreadsheet is complete, I usually post a completely unscientific set of predictions as to which of the year's albums will end up on the AM all-time top 3000 when the site is updated, and in what order. My "method" is simply to add each album's ...

Harold

People always ask me which famous Rob I am. I am Rob Thomas, the one from Smooth with Santana. "There are two things I know about white people. They love Matchbox 20, and they are terrified of curses." -- Wamapoke Native American tribal elder and casino owner Ken Hotate, on Parks and Recreation

Harold

Final update (most likely), following Kacey Musgraves winning Album of the Year at the Grammys. The top 200 list directly above remains the same.

Harold

Album of the Year: Golden Hour - Kacey Musgraves
Record of the Year and Song of the Year: "This is America" - Childish Gambino

Harold

I was looking through the final spreadsheet posted in the EOY 2014 thread for best songs. I noticed that the rankings in the spreadsheet don't match up with the list posted on the following page: http://www.acclaimedmusic.net/year/2014s.htm. Which version of the list is more up to date? The second ...

Harold

Updated with: USA/Canada: Village Voice Pazz and Jop Poll Top 200 Albums: 1 / Janelle Monae / Dirty Computer 2 / Low / Double Negative 3 / IDLES / Joy as an Act of Resistance 4 / Pusha T / Daytona 5 / Mitski / Be the Cowboy 6 / Robyn / Honey 7 / Kacey Musgraves / Golden Hour 8 / SOPHIE / Oil of Ever...

Harold

These links have been posted in the 2018 Songs spreadsheet forum, so I'm giving them their own thread. The Voice apparently decided not to wait until the rollout of all the previous P&J lists was complete before posting this year's results: Top 100 Albums: https://www.villagevoice.com/2019/02/06/paz...

Harold

I am surprised no one has commented on my post regarding Village Voice in EOY Albums: Sources. Attached are scans of the entire list of 101 albums that was briefly posted on January 24. Thanks for the screenshots. Since the list clearly was posted accidentally, far in advance of when they're planni...

Harold

Updated with: Rest of the World: Rockerilla [Italy]; Porcys [Poland] Plus a number of adjustments and corrections made by Henrik (particularly with regard to national-only columns). It's getting very near the end (we'd like to thank you once again...), I think. I'll edit the Grammy column after Albu...

Search found 1962 matches