Acclaimed Music Forums

Holden

Hello! As many of you know, I am currently working on an aggregation site dedicated to the greatest athletes of all time. I have been throwing around a couple of methods for this, and I would like to ask you guys to help me decide on one. In order to help with this, please leave below any/all of the...

Holden

Today I was listening to Waterloo Sunset on the way to work, and I realized that I had, at one point, really not liked the song, even though now I would probably say it’s my favorite of the top 50 AMF songs. So that’s speak the question: what songs/albums blew your mind on first listen, and which on...

Holden

I'm starting the rollout tomorrow, likely, so any reviews you would like featured should be sent soon!

Holden

Just so you know, acroamor, it might be good for you to just remove my list from the rankings as of right now. It will likely change to a very drastic extent, not just like me changing around a few places but me starting from scratch.

Holden

Last day!

Holden

Rate the Albums has been updated!

Holden

New Rate the album poll up!

Holden

Please rate the Talking Heads' Remain in Light on a scale from 1-10. Thank you! Also vote for your favorite albums to join rate the album!

Holden

In order to allow someone to fully check my work, I am going to have to hold off on presenting until Tuesday. Hopefully anyone else who would like to submit reviews will have the time then! I'm sorry about the delay, I just want everyone to receive the best possible roll-out! And thanks so much to m...

Holden

Alright, everybody! Looks like the presentation is almost ready for tomorrow's presentation, but I would LOVE more individual comments/reviews about albums! I'd love to have all of the top 10 albums, if not more covered with comments, so please PM me any reviews! Although our top albums do vary pret...

Holden

Janelle Monáe -Americans (2018) Gang Gang Dance - Mindkilla (2011) OutKast - Hey Ya (2003) The Knife - We Share Our Mother’s Health (2005) Kendrick Lamar - King Kunta (2015) Flaming Lips - Fight Test (2001) LCD Soundsystem - All My Friends (2007) The National - Fake Empire (2007) White Stripes - Fe...

Holden

Also, it seems as though pictures are going to have to be taken from multiple sources. Could someone tell me how to edit the photo size in the forum posts?

Holden

Jirin wrote: ↑
Fri Feb 21, 2020 7:19 pm
I thought I had Mercury Rev in my top ten, did I put it lower?

You listed me for Malibu Ken so must have been counted, I would just expect to also be biggest fans for Mercury Rev.

You had Mercury Rev at #18 in the List Thread, which is how it is listed in my spreadsheet.

Holden

Alright, so, this one list by Chris K. that I missed for some reason is going to shake up the results pretty drastically. I will fix this all tonight, and I intend to start a new roll-out thread that will start tomorrow. So sorry about all of the inconveniences, there on me, but I will begin the tru...

Holden

61. (Sandy) Alex G | House of Sugar (327.022 Points | 7 Votes) Critics’ List: 35 MegaCritic: 66 Biggest Fans: Jap123 (#12) Songs in Top 100: “Gretel” (#83) I should be included in the biggest fans of this album (my #8). Um unfortunately that would be because it seems as though I missed your list al...

Holden

Three days!

Holden

Visit new thread!

Holden

3 Days Left on the Current iteration of this poll!

Holden

Only a week left!

Holden

It turns out that Jenny Wilson's Trauma is near to impossible to find cover images for-the only nice one I managed to find is Rate Your Music's, which doesn't work, so if anyone manages to find one let me know!

Holden

I feel like in this specific instance, yes, that is valid, but I also feel like comparing other songs might yield different results. Maybe try comparing other highly ranked albums next to each other?

Holden

Also, how about a competition? Keep predicting your top ten, and I’ll figure out who is the most accurate after the roll-out is done!

Holden

Looks like allmusic is going to work on mobile, so I guess we’re gonna be doing that! I’ll update later tonight, I’m not home right now

Holden

Yikes-are the images showing up on anyone’s? They show up fine for my laptop-but of course I’ll find a new source so everyone can see them!

Holden

Visit new thread!

Holden

Visit new thread!

Holden

Unfortunately it seems that the two diffeeent sources I have used for images (Rate Your Music and Album of the Year) both don’t have images that work on mobile. Do we know of any sites that will?

Holden

I just want to warn everybody that I too am using the formula that acroamor used, and, in my opinion, it does a good job of representing the tastes of our forum members. I think that most inverse formulas overvalue high placements, which is why I switched once I was shown acroamor's formula, which I...

Holden

Visit new thread!

Holden

VIsit new thread!

Holden

Alright, we can hold off a bit, thank you for your input!

Holden

Hello! Starting later today I’m going to begin posting the results of our EOY Albums Poll, and here is the format for the results: (Image) Rank. Artist | Title (Total Points | Total Votes) Critics’ List: MegaCritic: Biggest Fans: Songs in Top 100: Plus some additional fun for some albums! Feel free ...

Holden

Worry not! I don't plan to actually start this poll until June or so (after the decade polls). However, I would like to begin a planning thread where we outline several things: 1. Album List Minimums and Maximums 2. Equations 3. Information y'all would like in the roll-out. 4. Start and End Date for...

Holden

Amazing rollout, acroamoar!

Holden

Fred wrote: ↑
Wed Feb 19, 2020 6:03 pm
Hey! You got the wrong Arcade Fire song!

My nomination is:

Arcade Fire - Intervention

Do you want to put all 10 of your nominations in this one song, or will you add more? (Great song by the way)

Holden

Question: can ratings be changed after having already inputted a different rating and doing many comparisons with it?

Holden

Here’s my personal list, maybe will change it!
LCD Soundsysten-All My Friends-2007-4
Gnarls Barkley-Crazy-2006-2
Sufjan Stevens-Age of Adz-2010-1
Sufjan Stevens-Fourth of July-2015-1
Arcade Fire-Neighborhood #2 (Laika)-2004-1
The Strokes-Barely Legal-2001-1

Holden

Hello! Holden here. You may remember how I hosted a Top 32 Albums of All-Time Tournament a while back. Here I am for round 2! This time, the top 64 songs of the century! But this time, you get to nominate them! Below, nominate your favorite songs from 2000-the present, and from your nominations I wi...

Holden

Hello and welcome back to AMF Survivor! Last time, Beach House's Teen Dream was barely ousted over Frank Ocean's Channel Orange! Only six remain: 1. Frank Ocean-Channel Orange (154) 2. PJ Harvey-Let England Shake (170) 3. Arcade Fire-The Suburbs (178) 4. David Bowie-★ [Blackstar] (179) 5. Sufjan Ste...

Holden

Money machine only 113?! That’s one of my favs of the decade!

Holden

Album submissions are gonna be closed too so I can start putting together the results without interruption!

Holden

OutKast-Hey Ya!

Holden

Last day!

Holden

Alright then! If anyone else would like to put an album list forward now is the time to do so, but I am going to begin to put together the roll-out, and hopefully I will be able to start it right away once the songs roll-out is done!

Holden

Dang the longer I watch this the more I wish I’d voted! Here Comes Your Man and Dancing in the Dark are two of my all time favorite!

Holden

Are we voting on the UK version (from May 67)? Or the US version (from Aug 67)? The US version includes Purple Haze, Hey Joe & The Wind Cries Mary, which the UK version doesn't. [/quote} I'm not familiar with the UK Version, so I guess average them if you've heard both, or just the one you're famil...

Holden

Krurze wrote: ↑
Sun Feb 16, 2020 10:15 am
Holden, I edited my list, too. I put in Peggy Gou's Starry Night at number 8 and moved everything after that a rank down accordingly. I hope it's not too much of a hassle for you to include this edit. Sorry for the late change!

No problem at all!

Holden

Moonbeam wrote: ↑
Sun Feb 16, 2020 1:44 am
Could I ask for an extra day for this?

Of course!

Holden

Out of curiosity, what is the list of ranks that go by the usernames, and what are the number of posts that go with them?

Holden

Dan wrote: ↑
Sat Feb 15, 2020 6:00 pm
Holden, I've just made a minor change to my albums list - I've replaced my previous #25 with Gérald Genty's Là-Haut. Thanks!

Done!

Search found 334 matches