Acclaimed Music Forums

Hmm. So it looks like there's no consistent rule applied, as there can be exceptions and it becomes Henrik's judgment call. I guess there's still no way to tell for sure which version is on the list without additional context or explanation.

It's always the year of first release. It counts for all versions of the song recorded by the artist. Ok, then that lines up with what I'm seeing with the particular example I showed and makes more sense. Unfortunately, doing it this way doesn't let you know which is the more acclaimed version of a...

Hello, Apologies if this has been answered before, but it's such a general question that a search doesn't seem to yield the answer. For any given entry in the Top 10,000 Songs list (or previous Top 6,000 Songs lists), does the "Year" specify the year of release, recording, or writing of th...

In addition to the Top Albums of All Time (Acclaimed Music Ranking Since 2008) and Top Songs of All Time (Acclaimed Music Ranking Since 2008) links, I was sure that I had put the excel files on the history page as well. I couldn't understand why so many had problems with this. But they are not ther...