Acclaimed Music Forums

Thanks for getting this transcribed so quickly! I did jump straight to the top 50 when I visited the RS website. I'm sure the rest of the list will confirm the initial impression that this is a fascinating and frustrating effort by RS to revamp the canon (I have no doubt they're already receiving h...

Was this one ever included?

Consequence of Sound 100 Greatest Debut Singles of All Time:
https://consequenceofsound.net/2017/10/ ... -all-time/

We shouldn't attribute it to Rolling Stone, per se, as the list was actually compiled by artists, writers, and industry folk. You can see whose participation led to the rankings here: https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/how-we-made-the-greatest-songs-of-the-century-so-far-list-666941/ To t...

They have a 2012 list, too:
http://popdust.com/2012/12/10/the-100-b ... lor-swift/

Well, I posted a link to that Carrie Underwood single review. That was from today (as in, September). Here is a review of the Aretha single from this month: http://popdust.com/2014/09/29/listen-aretha-franklins-painful-cover-adeles-rolling-deep/ And here is one to the new Fergie song: http://popdust...

They definitely do. This is one from today:
http://popdust.com/2014/09/28/carrie-un ... le-review/

They cover various music, too. Here is a track-by-track review for Drake's last album, for example:
http://popdust.com/2013/09/16/drake-not ... me-review/

http://popdust.com/2013/12/23/top-100-s ... 2013-year/
I can type it up later assuming it counts. Is there a reason this wasn't included for 2013? Maybe no one knew about it.

I think there are too many lists that cater to alternative music anyway. It's nice to get some other music represented. Plus, don't the Yeah Yeah Yeahs fit alternative? Plus, there is reggae and Latin in there, as well as pop-country and R&B. Great mix.

2009 1. "You Belong With Me" - Taylor Swift 2. "Heads Will Roll" - Yeah Yeah Yeahs 3. "Zero" - Yeah Yeah Yeahs 4. "Fifteen" - Taylor Swift 5. "Da Style Deh" - Busy Signal 6. "Hey Playa!" - DJ Quik & Kurupt 7. "9xs Outta 10" - DJ Quik & Kurupt 8. "Sweat It Out" - The-Dream 9. "Loba" - Shakira 10. "My...

2010 1. "Wile Out" - Zinc f/ Ms Dynamite 2. "Wut" - Girl Unit 3. "Hasta La Verdad" - Javiera Mena 3. "Take That" - Wiley & Chew Fu 5. "From A Table Away" - 6. "Coma Cat" - Tensnake 7. "BRKLN CLLN" - Joy Orbison 7. "Shutterbugg" - Big Boi 9. "The House That Built Me" - Miranda Lambert 10. "Holdin' Yo...

Yeah! Since it's counting, I will continue to post the lists. 2011 1. "212" - Azealia Banks 2. "Hell on Heels" - Pistol Annies 3. "Love Done Gone" - Billy Currington 4. "Countdown" - Beyonce 5. "Y'all Get Back Now" - Big Freedia 5. "Ass on the Floor" - Diddy-Dirty Money f/ Swizz Beatz 6. "House" - P...

No, I am assuming the 4 non-winners are all counted the same. Couldn't the same rule be used for lists that don't rank?

Hmmm, the fact that they simply list out their highest reviewed songs and call it a list gives me doubts, but these look like they could be eligible (on a personal note, thank you for mentioning the site itself fionalive, I've had great time browsing through it :D ) It's a bit of a different format...

2012 1. "Luz de Piedra de Luna" - Javiera Mena 2. "You're the One" - Charli XCX 3. "Climax" - Usher (classic!) 4. "Inspector Norse" - Todd Terje 5. "Loyalty" - Invy Da Truth 6. "Thinkin Bout You" - Frank Ocean 7. "Kings of Hearts" - Cassie 8. "Digital Rain" - DJ Raff 9. "Don't Save Me" - Haim 10. "F...

2013 1. "Still Into You" - Paramore 2. "Dreams and Nightmares" - Meek Mill 3. "Poetic Justice" - Kendrick Lamar 4. "#Beautiful" - Mariah Carey & Miguel 5. "Black Skinhead" - Kanye West 6. "You & Me" - Disclosure f/ Eliza Doolittle 7. "Music" - Sakanaction 8. "Hot Knife" - Fiona Apple 9. "Pata Pata" ...

Have these ever been mentioned?
http://www.thesinglesjukebox.com/
If you look on the left, the top songs from each year are listed (i.e. in order by average).

I'll type them out if it's something that might be counted.

That makes sense to an extent, but other things that count - like the Grammy nominees - don't have a full ranking. Why not just count all 50 equally as from a best-of list?

Is there a thread for general questions? I am wondering why the Slant list of Top 50 Pop Albums counts as ratings and not as a list.

Why do you question those 3 and not Beyonce?

I assume the inclusion of those songs has to do with how blurry the lines have become between R&B and hip-hop. Hip-hop is just as much about the rhythm and production as it is rap.

http://www.refinedhype.com/hyped/entry/best-hip-hop-songs-2000s-the-complete-list This source has now joined with DJBooth. 25. "Intl Player's Anthem" - UGK f/ Outkast 24. "We Belong Together" - Mariah Carey 23. "Get Low" - Lil Jon 22. "Trapped In The Closet" - R Kelly 21. "It's Hard Out Here For A P...